0:00Do you ever worry that you helped somehow to create a generation that struggled with being focused and with being present?
0:06The Facebook had been around for years, Google was around for a long time, Amazon, all these companies were around for quite a while. I learned from these companies and the gaming companies, the casinos, the video game companies, they had known these techniques forever. And so what I did was to try and democratize them for the rest of us. And the idea was that we could build habit forming products for good. Do you think that most people today are addicted through technology or addicted to escaping themselves when we speak about that?
0:33I don't think most people are addicted period that we know that about 3 to 5% of the population is addicted to something but that's nowhere near the majority. Not even close. Yeah. Yeah.
0:41You know, addiction has a very specific definition. An addiction is defined as a persistent compulsive dependency on a behavioral substance that harms the user. You know, if you like to use it a lot, that's not an addiction. That's a distraction. Now, if you [music] can't help but use it constantly, if you have a persistent compulsive dependency on something that hurts you, that's a different story. You know, I would argue that most people have a persistent dependency to their car. You have to use your car. If you don't use your car, really bad things happen.
1:09Where do you think that it's [music] line between influence and manipulation?
1:13And how do you see these two?
1:15Manipulation has a negative connotation, but I don't think it's necessarily negative. That there's two kinds of manipulation. How big of a research is behind your bookstep? What scares you of the future of humans attention? How do you see this point? And how do you see that humans attention will be driven?
1:32And what can take their attention in the future? Guys, I need to say something. We're building something really special here. The level of guests, the conversations, the depth we are going in week by week, it's becoming better and better, more and [music] more valuable.
1:45But there is one thing which doesn't make any sense. Almost 90% of you who keep watching the episode, who keep coming back week by week are not subscribed yet, which means one thing. You're not fully part of that journey. I get it. It's one click. It feels small, but for us and myself personally means everything. It tells the algorithm that we matter. It help us reach bigger guests and create better and better podcast episodes, which at the end of the day are equally
2:13for myself like for yourself. They bring the value. So, if there was ever a moment to support us, I please you to do it right now. Check if you're subscribed, and if you're not, it's completely free. It doesn't mean to you that much like it means to us. Just click the subscribe button, and by that way, you will help us grow bigger and bigger. And what I can promise you is that me and my team will continue making improves and very soon move ourselves to the real studio where we will record even more powerful episodes with sane
2:42and new guests. Check. Are you subscribed? and subscribe right now. Thank you, Mirael. Thank you so much for coming to my podcast today.
2:51My pleasure. Thank you.
2:52I will not take you so much time considering your time zone at the moment, but uh for the very beginning um I want to tell you that you made a real boom among the entrepreneurs with your book.
3:05I saw it from a great friend of mine uh Dr. Joe Vital and he told me, "I don't know the man, but I know that his book is amazing. You should check it out." I checked it out. Listen it twice.
3:17And I can't start differently but ask you who were near ale before near we know today.
3:25Who was I before the near ale you know today? Well um I'm changing every day.
3:30Uh you know I I don't write books because of what I know. I write books because of what I want to know. And um that's what drives me. I I I follow my curiosity and I write about problems that I have. And if other people have those problems too and they learn from it, wonderful. Um, but honestly, it's it's I'm I'm I'm I'm looking for answers. Um, so I'm I'm constantly evolving. You know, when I when I was struggling with distraction and I read everybody else's book on the
3:59topic and it didn't fix the problem, I had to fix it for myself. So I went into first principles and tried to understand the psychology of distraction and then 5 years later wrote indistractible with beyond belief. Same story. I had uh the the these problems in my life that weren't resolving that I wasn't able to fix and I I couldn't figure out why. And it turns out that I was limiting myself based on my belief system. And so I need to understand the deeper psychology of beliefs. And so that that became my my next book. So I I'm I'm constantly
4:27evolving. I you know they they say that a man never steps in the same river twice. And I think a man is never the same. Uh every every day we're constantly evolving. if you're if you're looking for kind of my my origin story, I guess you could say, is um you know, I think one thing that really shaped my my perception is that I have a really weird name [laughter] and I I grew up in uh in in uh the deep south in central Florida
4:56uh in a different time. Now, c Central Florida is much more cosmopolitan, but at the time it was uh a pretty homogeneous. And um I was the only kid with this this really weird ethnic name. And uh uh you know, today my website is called nearandfar.com. But that's what like near near like near and far like people couldn't really understand it.
5:18And it and it was very like it was it was annoying, right? like why couldn't I just have a name like everybody else has, you know, like a a Dave or a Tom or something easy? Um, and but so I kind of always felt a bit of an outsider uh because every time I would introduce myself, people would know that I wasn't from around these parts. But I think in a way it became an attribute. It became something that I like grew into of um like enjoying being a contrarian,
5:47enjoying being a little different that I started believing that that would be an asset. And I kind of I I like being I like being contrarian. I like I like taking conventional wisdom and and seeing is it all it's cracked up to be. And it turns out that a lot of what we believe is not a fact. [laughter] It's just an interpretation.
6:06uh and and and many times those beliefs can serve us and many times they hurt us.
6:12Whenever you come to the saleserson, the salesperson would tell you I know how to help you. We are having perfect solution for you. But in fact, you have a great product, you have a great offer, you know that you can help so many people but yourself still inconsistent. Why it's like that? Because you misunderstand two basic principles. And let me tell you something, it's not economy, it's not war, it's not current presidential politic situation, none of that. Because simply you and money were always on the same planet, planet Earth.
6:38You never left the planet and most likely money never did it, right? The only two ways are the reason why it's [music] like that. Number one thing which can be the reason is that you don't know the right way of presenting your offer. Number two can be that you don't know the proper way to whom to present it which boils down to you don't know to whom to sell or you don't know the right way to speak to the people to whom to sell. I have been scaling in the past 10 years multiple of my own companies and companies of my clients
7:06from zero to $200,000 in sales being in China selling physical perishable items like food and beverages and without speaking Chinese without writing Chinese and without knowing how to sell to Chinese people. But I knew one core principle and this is that psychology of people never change. So I knew to whom to sell and I knew exact way how to present my offer to them. I was scaling up my digital businesses to hundred thousands of dollars. Again, understanding two core principles [music] to whom to sell. So, who can
7:35benefit from my offer and the way, when, and how to present the my offer? And there is no magic and there is no secret behind that. It's really easy to understand it. But in order to this video be very short, I put all of this together in the school community which is completely for free. You can join it right now clicking on the link below in the description box and you can discover these two principles. It will take you a couple of days to figure it out yourself and to practice it and then your sales will become consistent. Until then, see you in the school community. Bye for
8:06You says here a couple of things which open my next couple of questions and uh somebody this podcast before told me Nick there is no better brand but your name and I thought with that for a while and I said like yeah that's actually very right. And I must tell you that as unique your name is, as powerful your brand is. So that there is definitely no chance that somebody can forget you in the space. But the way how you write books is actually 100% opposite than
8:36everyone else I was speaking with because usually people tell me I want to help people. I have the knowledge. I have the skills which I acquired and I want to spread this as a pattern, as a steps, as a procedure, as a system so that people can really take a notes and learn. You tell me you want to solve your problems and you want to learn by writing those books. How big of a research is behind your books then? And how does
9:05Yeah. So for me um I I kind of think there's three attributes to a a book that I like to read and um those three attributes are that number one has to be true, right? that I I I I don't like and and true in terms of of universally true, right? It's a it's a fact. It's an objective truth. It's something that's true whether you believe it or not.
9:27So, um like and this is a certain genre, right? When we're talking about about self-help non-fiction um and there's a lot of self-help non-fiction that um is true for some people but not true for others, right? When people are saying, "Hey, this worked for me. It's going to work for you." Well, like I I need to see the studies. like I I need to see the research. Okay, even it's just anecdote. If it just worked for you, I want to see will this work for a general population. Like show me the the show show me the the peer-reviewed study. So,
9:56number one, it's it's true. Uh number two, it has to be useful. You know, there's a lot of research. I mean it takes me about five or six years to write each one of my books because I spent a lot of time going through the research and you would be shocked at how much research from you know well reputable you know very reputable institutions is horrible just poorly run doesn't replicate um you know small sample sizes all the stuff that you see in the media yeah like just
10:25just you know very rarely pre-registered studies so there's a lot of really really crap crappy research out there.
10:31Um, and then a lot of it can be interesting in the lab but doesn't have real world applications. So, a lot of my time is spent looking through these studies to make sure that they actually have real world consequences. And then finally, so not only does it have to be true and useful, it also has to be novel. And that's probably the hardest part that to find stories that someone who's well read like you who's read a lot of books, you know, if if you you know, I don't know about you, but if I hear about the marshmallow study or the Eisenhower matrix one more time, I'm
11:00going to barf. You know, it's just, you know, a lot of business books, a lot of uh how-to books, just recycle the same studies over and over and over again, and it's boring. I I don't I already know those studies. So that's probably the hardest of the three is finding something that's novel that that people haven't heard before. And that's where I think, you know, being a bit contrarian is is is is fun like to overturn. Hey, we keep doing the same things and it's not working. Why isn't it working? Well, it's because maybe some of our fundamental understanding of the subject isn't exactly correct.
11:30100%. And when I'm reading the book, I usually like to check the author, what is the age and when he eventually begin to write that book so that I see how different we are age- wise because I believe that as older we are, we are more and more evolved. We're smarter, getting more experience. But with all of that grows something what they call responsibility. And I must ask you one thing. Uh I don't know did anybody else ask you that? But in your book hooked,
11:59you thought to the world how the product can hook people. Do you ever worry that you helped somehow to create a generation that struggle with being focused and with being present?
12:12Well, the book, how do you see that?
12:14Yeah. So, Hooked came out in 2014. Uh, and I didn't invent these techniques. None of the techniques in the book are original. uh I stole them and I stole them from the tech companies. You know the the Facebook had been around for years. Uh Google was around for a long time. Amazon, all these companies were around for quite a while. I learned from these companies and the gaming companies, you know, the c the casinos, the video game companies. They had known these these techniques forever.
12:43And so what I did was to try was to try and democratize them for the rest of us.
12:48And the idea was that we could build habit forming products for good. And that's exactly what's happened with the book. You know, one the the case study.
12:56Do you remember what the case study is at the very end of the book? There's only one case study in the original edition of the book. Do you remember what what it is?
13:02Right now, I cannot recall it exactly.
13:04Yeah. It's the Bible as a principle of of of of all life and of all of us, which is very well. No, not not so philosophical uh or metaphysical, but very practically speaking, the Bible app is a habit forming app. [laughter] not the Bible Bible the Bible I get to I get to know you and so I wanted to show how you know it's it's really about how we use the tool that if you're someone who believes
13:32that religion is is is helpful in people's lives that it brings them comfort that it brings them purpose that it brings them meaning and apping technology is wonderful if you believe that religion is the opium of the masses like Karl Marx did then you think it's used to manipulate people so is the Bible app good Yes. Is the Bible app bad? Yes. Is social media good? Yes. Is social media bad? Yes.
13:58It's it's of course both and there's nuance. So it's what what I wanted to do was to democratize these techniques. And of course I was very well aware of their potential for manipulation. And that's why in the book there's a a chapter called the morality of manipulation where you know I was talking about this back in in uh 2014 uh when the book was first published about how we need safeguards and how we need to make sure that that this doesn't uh uh have adverse consequences that we need a moral code for how we use this
14:27technology. So I I was one of the first people to to to talk about the potential downside. Now, I think um I uh you know, when I wrote Hooked, uh I had to convince people that they were that these companies understood how to use psychological tactics to to get you to click. Uh now I don't have to convince anybody, right? We all know this.
14:50Um but I I I still think that um that that you know, waiting for these companies to change is a waste of time.
15:00that one technology evolves way too fast that you know now nobody's worried about social media anymore now we're all worried about AI and I I knew that I called that years ago that when people were freaking out about techn you know about social media melting people's brains it's like just wait a few months you know it's or a few years it's going to be some other technology and then the next technology because we always have these moral panics and two you know what I wanted to do with indistractible was to show that we can use habit forming technology for good we can use habit forming technology to build fitbod uh to
15:30build uh you know companies like u uh Dualingo uses the hook model to get people hooked on learning a new language. You know we talked about the Bible app. All kinds of products and services can use the hook model for good. But then we also can make sure that we that we disconnect from the products we don't want to get hooked to.
15:46We want to get fit uh hooked to the app that makes us work out in the gym but we may want to not get distracted by Tik Tok or Instagram or one of these other products. Not that they're necessarily bad for us. It's about how we use them.
15:59just like any other tool. So, I don't want to live in a world without the iPhone and Instagram and uh social media. I think these products are are great, but of course, it's how much how we use them. And and let's not forget, you know, the the the much bigger problem to me is not people using social media because look, that's a time waster, okay? Um I'm much more concerned about the kind of of things that waste not just time, but money. So, I'm
16:28against legalization of online gambling.
16:31And I've never worked with any company that uses my work or or any company for that matter, use anybody's work that's in the gaming space. I I think that, you know, because when people lose time, that's one thing, you know, if they're using time on spending on YouTube versus watching TV, what's the difference?
16:47People have been watching TV for a long time. Why is watching golf different than watching YouTube? I don't know. It's to me it's the same. But you know when people gamble online they can lose their livelihood. They can go into debt. This can have some severe severe consequences.
17:02You know much drug abuse. You know I I I used to be very liberal about drug use and now seeing how there are you know people can't handle it. We have over legalized. We have made it too easy to get your hands on drugs these days. I mean you can't walk through the streets of Manhattan without constantly smelling pot. You know I'm walking with my daughter through the city and all she smells is pot. It used to be cigarettes.
17:25We Oh, god forbid you should smoke a cigarette. You know, you'll go to jail if you smoke, you get a fine if you smoke a cigarette.
17:30Social everywhere. It's ridiculous. And I think that a lot of people just don't realize how harmful these real addictions are. So, for all the time we talk about social media, I think we're really focused on the wrong thing. I'm way more concerned about online gambling, about drug use. That's the kind of stuff we need to worry about.
17:48And frankly, you know, we know when you look at children, you know, people say, "Well, what about children?" one, you know, I've advocated for over what since 12 years now since Hooked was published.
17:58I've advocated for laws that protect children uh for for forever now uh from social media. But even, you know, even when it comes to kids, this is the most the the the safest generation in history. If you look at all the things that used to kill kids in our generation, drunk driving, record lows, truency, record lows, homicide, record lows. All the things that used to kill kids, record lows. The only thing that's
18:27gone up from a very low baseline, from a historically low baseline, is teen suicide, right? That's gone up a little bit, but actually is going back down. And teen mental health issues. It rose and now it seems like it's it's leveling off and going down. So, in a way, if you wanted to create a device that keeps kids off the streets and safe at home, not such a bad idea. [laughter] Yeah, right.
18:51We forget about the upside.
18:52I fully agree about that. And yeah, we can probably argue about that timewise, how long social medias exist and how long exist, for example, alcohol and drinking and so on. But again, you're very right in what you're saying because I believe that the real danger lies in the mis use in in in wrong way of using the assets because if we will be completely against technology, you and me would not be speaking half of the world right
19:19far away right now. Uh near do you think that most people today are addicted to technology or addicted to escaping themselves when we speak about that?
19:30Maybe in some moments I think that maybe people are trying just to escape their problems and then this create a momentum that they cannot get rid of this dopamine effect of scrolling and of being addicted. How do you see this situation knowing that you are very deeply into the human psychology? Well, I I don't think most people are addicted, period. Uh that we know that about 3 to 5% of the population is addicted to something, but that's nowhere near the majority. Not even close.
19:59Yeah. Yeah. You know, addiction has a very specific definition. An addiction is defined as a persistent compulsive dependency on a behavior or substance that harms the user.
20:08You know, if you like to use it a lot, that's not an addiction. That's a distraction. Now, if you can't help but use it constantly, if you are if you have a persistent compulsive dependency on something that hurts you, that's a different story. You know, I would argue that most people have a persistent dependency to their car, right? You use it every day. You have to use your car. If you don't use your car, really bad things happen. But is it
20:35hurting you? No. It's a tool. So, is are we addicted to social media? Are we addicted to technology? I mean, it's persistent. We need it. But is it harming us? H very few people can you argue that it really harms them and that they can't control it. You know, if you can sit down at the dinner table with your family and have a conversation, they're probably not addicted. You might be distracted, right? I think that the majority of people are certainly distracted. And maybe we have bad
21:03habits, right? But a habit is not an addiction. You'll notice my book habit, you know, how to build habit forming products hooked. It's not how to build addictive products. It's how to build habit forming products. A habit is an impulse to do a behavior with little or no conscious thought. And about half of what you do every single day is done out of habit. A behavior done with little or no conscious thought. Now we have bad habits. We also have a lot of good habits, right? That habits generally serve us very very well. Now your point, so that's one. I don't think most of us
21:32are addicted. Not at least not into the the medical way. And I think actually this this language is very very harmful because remember the word addiction you make me question now myself and I'm consistently now listening to you. I resonate 100% with everything you said and I'm thinking oh my god did I use the word addiction too easy without some real leverage behind that.
21:54I use it kind of like a slang like kind of like what's up?
21:57Yeah. And it's it's dangerous because remember the word addiction comes from the Latin addictio which means slave. And that's kind of how we use the word when we say we're addicted. It's we're we're zombies. We're enslaved. Not enslaved. It's not hijacking your brain.
22:12You know, Tristan Harris says this that technology is hijacking our brain. Hijacking is what those bastards did to us on 9/11. Okay? It's it's it's it's offensive to use that term describing Candy Crush. Give me a break. Come on. We're not addicted. We like it. [laughter] It's fun. You know, it doesn't mean we're addicted. You know, lots of things that are potentially addictive doesn't mean everyone's addicted. You know, let's take Sorry, just to interrupt you for a second going that going that global. We
22:41may say that we're addicted to football, which basically it's a healthy to do because it's a healthy you're exercising, right?
22:48So, yeah. Yeah, I mean if you know you're you're most of what we call addiction to technology is an addiction if anything to friends that we're when we're we like people we like to connect and before you know if we can't be there physically look at look at us we're on two different sides of the planet we like to connect we're we're using screen time we're using technology are we addicted to it I don't think so lots of things that people use that are potentially addicted to some people not everyone gets addicted to I mean a lot of us have a glass of wine
23:16with dinner we're not all alcoholics We have sex. We're not all sex addicts. Why do we think that everyone who uses technology is addicted to technology?
23:24Some people are. Some people definitely are. But that's a very very small proportion. What what majority of us are is distracted.
23:32Yeah. And that's that you're very right about that because if we then take a hook in the way of like I just want a second of your attention. Why? Because everybody else is distracted. Why is he set? Because there are a lot of advertisements and informations which you have to process. You're very right on that and you're really right now I can even say crack the belief which I used to had for a very long I used to have a belief for a very long that people are easy like addicted now I can
24:00say to shorts real scrolling this and that and that all you need is to turn their attention but in fact I realize that I use too easy that word thank you for this well and I would I would add too you know what happened if all this stuff went away let's say tomorrow oh it's all addictive. Okay, it's all bad for you.
24:18Let's let's make it all go away. You really think people are going to go back to reading Shakespeare and Chaucer in their spare time? No, we'll go back to what we used to do. Watch sports, watch soap operas, gossip, you know, distraction has always been here. Plato 2500 years ago, 2500 years ago talked about how a crassia in the Greek, how, you know, people do things against their best interest. This is not a new problem. People have always been distracted. And in fact, it's a sign of
24:46progress that, you know, it tells you something about society when our biggest problems is not that we can't feed ourselves. It's not that we're struggling with starvation. It's that we have so much time that we're scrolling. I mean, if our grandparents heard about this is our problem, this is our biggest complaint, they would laugh at our face. [laughter] 100%. I strongly believe that we are having way easier problems nowadays.
25:12However, they look like oh my god comparing with even my parents and then going backwards with my grandparents. uh when we speak here about addiction we are very incorrelated with attention vice versa right I want to ask you is there anything now and and this very interesting to ask you actually uh what scares you of the future of humans attention how do you see this point and how do you see that humans attention will be driven and what can take their
25:40attention in the future well I do think that there's there's going to be a bifurcation that Um, I think there will be people who ha have and will continue to allow their time and attention to be controlled by others. And this isn't necessarily new phenomenon. It's just that it's more accessible, right? Uh, you know, in my generation, they used to call us couch potatoes because we sat there and watch TV all day. So, you know, every generation has this moral panic and
26:08every generation does have people who kind of waste their life away watching too much media. But that's not a decision for me to make. I can't tell somebody don't watch golf on TV. You should be doing something productive. I mean, what if you want to watch golf, watch golf. It's not up to me to tell you what to do with your life. But I do think that there will be people who who look back and regret on how they spent their time. Did they spend too much time consuming and not enough time creating?
26:34So there will be people who spend their time and attention controlled by others.
26:39And then we have a people who stand up and say, "Wait a minute. Well, I I don't need to have my time and attention controlled by others. I can decide for myself how I use technology, how I use the media in all forms, not just social media, but all forms of media. How do I make sure that I spend my life according to how I want to live it so that I don't regret how I spent my time? And so, I think I think that that's what will continue to happen. And I think those who can master this skill of the century, the ability to control your
27:08time and attention. I think this is this is the most important skill because information is no longer scarce, right?
27:15It used to be if you had some kind of secret information, some special knowledge that was scarce, but that's not scarce anymore. Anybody who has anything interesting to say, you know, you're you're writing a blog post about it, you're publishing a Substack, you're writing something on social media, or you're making a video. Absolutely. You know, there's no special knowledge anymore. What is what is scarce is protecting your time and attention for your values and and I don't think it's up to us to regulate how people spend their time and attention. I think that needs to be an individual decision based
27:44on your values because this what you mentioned just for a second is we basically all become a media. We all become a journalist.
27:52Everybody has a camera. Anything happen everybody will pull up the phone instead of firstly running to help or to give to somebody first aid. Uh and when you're saying that attention it's probably nowadays coming to be the most important skill or it's already the most important skill. Uh if we turn that into that slang word attention is a currency who do you think that it going to be the richest man or organization in the world
28:19in the future by that?
28:22Well, you know, the the something becoming scarce doesn't necessarily mean it it's going to create a single business. Uh it was a very good it used to be a very good business to be a publisher. You know, if you were Time magazine or life magazine, remember Life magazine or Entrepreneur. I was talking to my friend who works for Entrepreneur magazine and Entrepreneur magazine used to mean something. And now, did you know that when you publish an entrepreneur, you pay to publish online? I didn't know
28:51that. But but it's it's become such a such a crappy business that it used to be such accessible.
28:56Yeah. That that advertisers would pay to be next to the writing. Well, today the writing is the advertising. It's essentially an entire online publication of ads. I had no idea. I just learned this a few days ago. So, but that's not a very good business, right? Just because they they publish information doesn't mean that they're they're a good business. Just because they have attention doesn't mean it's a good business. So I think in many ways attention has been fractured and um uh now we can create content ourselves
29:26which I think is is very empowering. I would much rather live in a world where lots of people have uh had the ability to share their perception of reality from from you know their perspective uh versus just a few media sources who we know were were you know frequently biased and and and didn't give us uh the whole truth especially if they were some kind of government controlled uh influence you know where where they didn't have a free press that controlling the media was was how you
29:55control people's minds. Well, that's become much harder today in you know what's the first thing when a country goes to war you know Iran goes to war they shut down the internet because they don't want disscent they don't want people knowing the truth you shut down information and you centralize it well I I like living in a world even though we have many more conspiracy theorists and we have disinformation and misinformation I think those are solvable problems so remember we we you know technology doesn't solve problems we we many people think technology solves problems technology does not
30:23solve problems technology gives us better problems.
30:28That's what technology does for us. So that you know when when um uh you know the green revolution solved hunger. This is the first generation in history where we don't have mass starvation anywhere on earth.
30:38You know there's pockets of it. But it's because of of politics. It's not because we don't have enough calories. We have enough calories to feed every human on the face of the earth. But the green revolution because it it created such abundance in in food. Now we don't have starvation. Now we have new problems.
30:53Now we have obesity. [laughter] Well, now that we have obesity, we need GLP-1s to help us reduce. So, this is this constant cycle of technology create solves problems and then creates new problems. I'm sure GLP1s will also have problems. So, so this this is a constant cat-and- mouse game. Uh, but overall the long-term trajectory is that things get better and better and better. This is how we improve our standard of living.
31:15This is how we make life better. So, we have better and better problems to deal with. and and going backwards, you know, if you if you go to a developing country, you'll see how difficult it is without these technologies. So, so I I think on on the whole we're getting better and better. Now, to answer your question about um you know, who who becomes wealthy, I I don't know yet.
31:35It's uh I think it's still too early to tell. And now with the the dawn of AI, I think you know um uh entertainment um and and capturing attention is is is constantly being reinvented. If we keep thinking, if we keep looking at the rearview mirror and saying, well, it's now easier to create a certain type of content because of AI, well, when things become abundant, uh, they they become cheaper, right? Supply and demand. And so, what we're probably going to see are
32:02new forms of of content that are scarce, that are special, that are interesting.
32:07So, just copying what's always been done is is is not necessarily going to make sure that things work the way they always have. So, I think it's still too early to tell. But I think from an individual perspective I I have no doubt that uh this is something we can do something about that we can uh make sure that we protect our own attention.
32:25I love your beliefs about that. Uh absolutely every solution pretty much creates a solution for certain problem like any offer in the space but also uncover another problems and this is ongoing cycle always and always. Uh when we speak about addiction, I want to ask you something what I'm pretty much battling with. I think for myself that I'm very ambitious person because in my childhood I can say that I was hungry
32:54not literally hungry hungry to succeed hungry to do something different and I started thinking hm is it ambitious being addicted or it's absolutely normal and I would like to hear you how do you see it I already know part of your answer because you already told me that I was using addiction too strong so I would like to hear how do you see that and how do you see interpreneurs who are hungry to succeed and very ambitious in their work?
33:23Well, would you say that it's something that you were that was causing you harm?
33:30Yes, in in the way that it wasn't easy to succeed, but I got used to that because if it would be easy, everybody else would do it. And if it would be just because it's hard that struggling doesn't necessarily mean suffering. Exactly. A lot of things are hard, but that doesn't mean that it was causing you harm. You are right. I can agree with that.
33:49And yes, you're right. It didn't harm me. It was just So then it's not an addiction. Addictions always have to cause harm.
33:56Yeah, that definitely that definitely you're right. It it didn't harm. I just looked towards that to maybe maybe from the wrong angle or maybe not not having that knowledge which I have from the very beginning of our conversation. Yeah. I mean look, ambition is what makes our species better. We need ambition. We need people to have that disquitude. We need people to be uncomfortable to want to make things better. I think that's that's a defining human trait.
34:25Absolutely. Give me an answer then.
34:28Where do you think that it's line between influence and manipulation? And how do you see these two?
34:35Yeah. So manipulation has a negative connotation, but I don't think it's necessarily negative. That there's two kinds of manipulation. Uh there's what we call persuasion.
34:45Yeah. So persuasion is getting people to do things they want to do. Persuasion can be a very good thing that uh if I'm persuading you to go to the gym, to save money, to uh communicate with your family, to to do something that you yourself want to do, that's wonderful.
35:03So persuasive technology is very healthy, right? That's why I wrote Hooked, you know, to help people build the kind of products and services that can improve people's lives if they would use the product. That's persuasive technology. Now, the opposite of persuasion, which is helping people doing do something that they wanted to do, is coercion. Coercion is not ethical. Coercion is the the wrong side of manipulation. Coercion is when we get people to do things they did not want to do. And in business, you can't coersse
35:32people. The only people who can coersse others legally is the government, right?
35:35The the government can conver coers you to pay your taxes because if you don't pay your taxes, you're going to go to jail. That's coercive. getting you to do something you did not want to do. So, in business, we can't coersse people because if you coers people to do doing something that they do not want to do, not only will they not do business with you again, they're going to tell all their friends not to do business with you ever again either. So, you know, coercive uh practices are not only bad business, they're not not only unethical, they're they almost, you
36:05know, no company that's coercive stays in business for very long.
36:09Nowadays when when we look at the entrepreneurial world the world where I can say I belong to because I really enjoy sales and sales events and creating them for people. Uh I want to ask you do you think that entrepreneurs besides ethics leadership and company cultures they should understand human psychology and until what level?
36:35Yeah, I think I think consumer psychology is the unlock if you want to understand the deeper why of why people do what they do. Uh and you don't just want a surface level understanding. You know, I think most people in business, they just kind of copy the competition.
36:48They just do what everybody else is doing and then they get results like everybody else gets. But if you really want to excel, if you want to uh get ahead, you have to know some kind of secret. You have to have some kind of alpha that other people don't see uh to to make that to you give you that edge uh to understand uh your customers better than your competition does and and the key to that is consumer psychology.
37:10Have you ever found any company which does this exactly to you or you believe that it does to masses but people are maybe not assuming the situation to to to see that in reality they just like how they feel it.
37:24Sorry I'm not sure I understood your question there. Say it again.
37:26Have Have you ever looked at a company who actually does exactly that just that do it sophisticatedly so that you as an expert of human psychology can see and say, "Oh yeah, that's actually what they're doing pretty much clear to me."
37:45So many products. Uh look at look at, you know, look, we were talking about alcohol. That's just the first thing that comes out of my out of my mind. you know, alcohol uh spirits, you know, the the the bottle is worth more from in terms of our production value than what's in it. Alcohol is incredibly cheap to make. It's it's rotten fruit.
38:06It's rotten grapes. It's rotten uh you know, barley and wheat and you know, it's it's nothing. It's garbage. Ethanol is is super cheap. Not only that, it's poison. [laughter] Yeah.
38:20Yeah. on top of the fact that it's, you know, it's very very cheap to make spirits and yet, you know, we it costs pennies to produce. Uh, but it's the branding. It's that we tell you that this poison uh that that that makes you feel a certain way that that's a good thing. And then we convince you that it's very rare and the whiskey is this and the taste of this and the the label and the story and the wine and you know, it's it's all mythology. It's all consumer psychology. So I think you know wine and spirits is probably one of one
38:47of the best uh uh industries that that leverages um consumer psychology and of course to some degree addiction right we we do have people unfortunately who struggle with with addiction which is why I don't work with with any spirits companies and never have uh gambling I never work with those type of companies there's lots of companies that that use consumer psychology in a way that people think is just life you know sports is a wonderful example we get so into, you know, what happened on the World Cup and
39:16did you see what happened in the Super Bowl and what happened in the World Series and who gives a It's a it's a ball bouncing around, but it's very very very important to people and and when you say something like I just said, who gives a People definitely give a You know, you go to a you know, we talk about social media being addictive, go to a sports bar during a big game and try and turn off the TV.
39:39you you will not leave that bar with your life, right? People people have been addicted so many people are addicted to spectator sports for for for a long time, forever.
39:51Oh, absolutely. Yeah.
39:52And and what's the psychology? You're not playing in that game and you don't even you don't know anybody on that team. They don't even represent your country or your city. They're imported. You these players come from everywhere. And yet, oh, we're fanatic and we'll beat people up if they don't like our team. We get we spend so much of our life watching this stuff. Not that it's bad.
40:11I'm not I'm not here to judge how people spend their time. I mean, what is life about if not to enjoy things and get into things and become obsessed with them? I think it can be a very beautiful thing to get obsessed with something. But man, if you think that that's not engineered, uh, you're so you're sorely sorely mistaken.
40:27That's very beautiful what you're speaking here. Never thought of this about alcohol. Right now, after our podcast, I will be going to Google some facts about that. That's a very interesting topic. Thank you for this especially it's about sport. With respect to your time I have a couple of questions more which I would like to you answer me and one of them is that with AI with all distraction we are having right now around that we are kind of like panicking not knowing what new going to happen. Uh most of the times I hear the sentences AI going to replace
40:56us or AI going to replace us within two three years if you don't join now if you don't learn now this and that. What do you think which human qualities become most valuable in nowadays world and in near future?
41:12Well, I think first of all uh anybody who thinks they know anything is sorely mistaken that uh most of the time these things don't play out the way we think they're going to play out and it's just getting started. I mean right now um I I've never liked the term AI. Uh I don't think it describes what's happening right now. I think we have we have LLMs.
41:31Uh that's what we have. Uh we have algorithms. Um I don't I don't I don't like AI to me is is you know we we we substitute artificial intelligence to mean artificial consciousness. And I don't I don't think that's what we're seeing. At least from what I I I'm not an AI expert, but that's what I I'm not seeing artificial consciousness. We're we're seeing problem solving. We're seeing very very impressive tools which are absolutely mind-blowing, absolutely amazing. Um and I'm sure that they will replace some jobs. They already are. But
42:01I'm I I don't think uh at this stage that we're seeing evidence of that being a long-term trend. I I I think in many ways um what history teaches us is that uh we have new jobs, right? That that um uh you know used to be that for the American workforce that a huge proportion of Americans worked in farming, right? They work in agriculture. Now singledigit percentages of people work in agriculture. Well, what happened to all those jobs? Why,
42:30you know, all those jobs were eliminated during the green revolution, during mechanism, during the industrial revolution.
42:37All those people still out of work. No, we we we now employ people in much much better jobs. We're thankful we don't have to work in the fields farming that now we can work with our our minds as opposed to with our hands. And so that is likely, I mean, if if history is to be some kind of guide, that's likely what's going to happen. that um that that the fact that we can all build things in a way we never could before with AI. We don't need the technical skills you used to need to code um to to to access information. I mean, we we all
43:06have been handed an amazing superpower.
43:08It's just about how we use it. Now, I'm sure there will be disasters. I mean, we should all prepare ourselves for crashes and uh huge errors. There will be hidden Hindenburg moments, right? with every new technology as you know you remember with the Hindenburg this this awful Zeppelin disaster that burned that was a step along the way to powered aviation um that you know now we have we have uh thousands and thousands of flights taking off every day and landing safely
43:38and we never hear about the ones that you know every time I get in an airplane I I I it it it blows my mind that here I am in this machine with millions and millions of parts and somehow you know the these this tons of cargo and weight are able to go into the air at almost the speed of sound and land on the other side of the planet. It still blows my mind, but that path to get us there took a lot of time, a lot of uh money, and a lot of disasters along the way. A lot of plane crashes along the way. So, no
44:08doubt about it. There will be AI crashes. There will be terrible things that happen because of AI. But um uh I I it seems to be that uh we're going to get a lot more benefit than than downside. At least that's what I choose to believe. I don't know that for a fact because it hasn't happened yet.
44:24Yeah. But I agree with your belief. Uh the message behind my show is inside out. And I like to ask every guest what do they think that is one internal quality in inside of any interpreter when expressed outwardly can create an impact and success knowing that you're very deeply human psychology and in beliefs as well I would like to ask you what do you feel
44:52that it's inside out for you? Yeah.
44:55And for people in global, I I think the the most important trait for entrepreneurs is what's called entrepreneurial alertness.
45:05It's to believe in opportunities that other people don't see. And and thank God we have those opportunities. We have those dreamers. I think in many ways um we don't celebrate entrepreneurs enough.
45:16You know, I think recently entrepreneurship in a way is you know we we think about billionaires. We think about people who get super rich and and I think there's a bit of a cynical uh streak right now. You know, this goes in waves that right now it's it's kind we have kind of an eat the rich attitude that uh people who got successful got successful because they took money away from people. And that's that's not how business works. Anybody who's been in business for very long knows that if you take from people, they won't do business with you. that great entrepreneurs, not that everybody's perfect. You know, there's definitely cases of fraud and
45:46malfeasants, but the vast majority of entrepreneurs are are successful because they gave to others, because they made something people want. And as a reward, the market gave them back. And um I think I think having that optimism of you can make the world a better place through innovation through industry you know that that has far and away produced more benefit much more than government has ever given us or not that we don't need good governance. I mean that's the basis of business to excel but direct
46:14handouts from the government that's not what's built prosperity and and and standard of living. What's improved standards of living is relentless innovation is making what people want cheaper and cheaper. Giving them the the basics of of of an existence uh of reducing the amount of of of toil and backbreaking labor that people have to do through automation. And this is this is the long march of history to improve our lives through business. Not that you know regulation isn't important. We need
46:43good regulation but mostly we need good regulation to establish free markets and free minds.
46:50Thank you for this n uh you you you really with every with every second or third answer crack my brain and I start thinking like oh ho ho ho ho okay that's I need after podcast to recall it once again and and and to put my thoughts on the paper about that n with all that said uh I would like to ask you is there a final message for all our audience who is listening or watching to this podcast today what would you like to let them be yeah I think I think my message would be and this is this comes from my my latest
47:18book beyond belief is that um that you don't see reality clearly. You see reality through your beliefs. That you are capable of far more than you ever imagined. And that your beliefs shape your perception of reality. That's I think the three messages I would love to leave people with.
47:38And that's very beautiful. Knowing that it's very late in the Singapore at the moment where you are, I want to thank you for coming to my show and to thank you for all the wisdom you shared with us today. Dear audience, this was near ill. Thank you so much.
47:52Thank you, Nick. Great to see you. Thank you.