We can't find the internet
Attempting to reconnect
Something went wrong!
Hang in there while we get back on track
Consumer AI: wide use, narrow spending, and a shift in share
a16z's seventh Top 100 Consumer AI list ranks apps by revenue for the first time. The data is consumer card spend, so enterprise and SMB spending is not included. Traffic rankings are settling: only 11 new products entered the web and mobile lists, the fewest of any edition. Of the 50 products ranked by spend, 29 did not appear on either traffic list .
Spending is concentrated among a small group of heavy users:
- About half of Americans say they use AI, but a16z's Yipit panel puts paying subscribers at about 4.5% of US consumers. Some other sources put it at 2–2.5%. a16z says the share has doubled in a year .
- Among people who pay, the top 10% generate more than half of revenue and the top 1% generate 20%. The top 1% spend $903 a month, against a median of $25. Most of the spending goes to developer, productivity and creative tools .
- 85% of web-list apps make money from subscriptions, 62% from credits or usage charges, and only 13% from ads. Olivia Moore calls this an "unnatural inversion" of the usual consumer-internet model and expects ads and transaction fees to return .
- Nine of 15 consumer internet categories have no AI product in the Top 100: streaming, social, dating, gaming, travel, retail, finance, real estate and jobs .
The diligence point: in consumer AI, revenue rankings and traffic rankings now pick out different winners. And the open categories are the ones that have historically been funded by ads and transactions, not subscriptions.
Claude is taking share. a16z says ChatGPT still leads, with about 6x Claude's web usage and about 3x as many paid US consumer subscribers as Gemini or Claude. But a16z's US spender panel shows Claude has passed Gemini in paid subscribers. About 7.5% of Claude subscribers are on plans costing $100 or more a month, against about 1% for ChatGPT and Gemini . Big Technology's numbers ahead of Anthropic's IPO point the same way:
- App users: Apptopia puts Claude's share of daily active users across AI apps at 14.9% in September, up from 1.4% in January. ChatGPT's fell from 41.8% to 30.7% .
- Downloads: Claude's US downloads peaked at 7.42M in March and fell to 3.26M in September .
- Web traffic: In August Claude's site had 950M visits, up 540% year over year .
- Enterprise: Claude's SSO login traffic, which Similarweb uses as a proxy for enterprise use, has roughly quadrupled since March .
The competitive question for agents. Andrew Chen says new horizontal consumer agents (Muse, Town, Instinct, Grokbot) are making thousands of vertical-agent startups rethink their position . He argues agents don't have network effects by default. Better models, UX and memory can build large companies, but those advantages are not network effects . The question that matters is where network effects end up. If identity, reputation and context sit in open protocols, vertical agents can thrive. If horizontal agents keep them proprietary, switching agents means leaving your network behind .
Open weights: Reflection's Beam
Reflection AI announced Beam, an "agentic open model" with 501B total parameters and 23B active, trained from scratch. Reflection says Beam advances Western open models on coding and agentic tasks and that full weights will be released this month . These are the company's own claims, and no outside benchmarks appear in this period's sources.
How VCs are playing the AI cycle: Menlo's approach and a dissent
Harry Stebbings credits Menlo's Anthropic round at a $4B valuation with making the firm "$50BN+," followed by Lovable, Higgsfield and Legora . Venky Ganesan of Menlo made these arguments:
- Seed checks as options. A seed check buys an option; you size up only when revenue data shows a company is an outlier . Menlo has put 20% of a fund into one company, Anthropic, by "laddering up" as new data came in .
- The return bar. Startups pay compute and model costs to hyperscalers, while LPs can buy those same companies without fees or carry. So private VC has to beat public markets by at least 1,000 basis points .
- What breaks a cycle. Defaults on leveraged debt, not equity write-downs .
- Tranched rounds as froth. These rounds raise lower-priced "build with me" money first and then more at a higher valuation. Ganesan says everyone now uses them, regardless of company quality .
Sarah Guo disagreed. A lead seed investor can treat the check as a full bet and back it for years: "structure determines strategy" . Stebbings separately predicts incumbents will start acquiring AI customer-support companies .
Agent infrastructure: harnesses, test environments, memory
- Harnesses as training environments. Hugging Face turned unmodified coding harnesses into RL environments by routing their API calls through a capture proxy. The same model scored 62% in Mini-SWE-Agent and 33% in Claude Code. Training a 2.6B model across four harnesses improved all four (42%→54%), while fine-tuning on rollouts from a larger model plateaued at 47.5%. All of it is open source .
- Grep AI (YC F26) builds agents that turn repeatable steps into code and reserve frontier models for exceptions . It says customers including IG, Airwallex and Worldpay have saved more than 250,000 hours . Garry Tan argues that lab harnesses have an incentive to burn tokens, which leaves real room for startup-built harnesses .
- Era launched free. It generates a simulated enterprise across Salesforce, Slack, Jira, Zendesk and other tools with known ground truth, so agents can be benchmarked and post-trained on their failures .
- Cognition's "Dreaming" builds Devin a memory graph across sessions and cleans it up overnight. Cognition is also proposing an open Agent Memory Repo standard . Harrison Chase's open question is how inferred memories get validated before an agent uses them .
Deals and early-stage signals
- Sensible Bio (YC S21) raised a $47M Series A to make mRNA inside engineered living cells. Current cell-free methods, it says, can't supply the doses and purity that therapies like in vivo CAR-T and gene editing need. Its platform already makes about 1,000 sequences a week .
- Jeevy Fabrication makes rocket tanks, piping and structures for customers including SpaceX and Lockheed Martin. Standard Capital led its Series A. The founder previously worked on Starship ground-support equipment, and the company is using AI to get parts delivered to spec and on time .
- SF Tech Week lists more than 1,700 events, over double the count two years ago. Hardware-themed events tripled. Cybersecurity events more than tripled, driven by AI security as companies deploy agents. Deep tech doubled .
- Yandex Music's Sona replaced more than 15 candidate generators and its ranking stack with a single transformer in an A/B test. It raised active users 4.53% and listening time 6.30%, but catalog coverage fell and it has not shipped to full traffic .
Policy
Sam Altman argued for lighter-touch regulation that accepts "some bad things" while guarding against catastrophic loss of control. He said he would not support licensing for models a generation or two behind the frontier . He said tight silicon wafer supply, not financing, is driving up costs, and that he expects OpenAI to be ready for an IPO once it has "a few safety cases under our belt" . He believes OpenAI's best internal model is "well ahead" of the best Chinese ones but can't say by how much . Scott Kupor says the White House Super Intelligence Force will advise both on staying ahead and on doing so responsibly . Brad Feld and others launched Founded Colorado, an advocacy group that came out of the fight over Colorado's SB 24-205 AI law .
- Consumer AI use is broad but paid spend remains concentrated: roughly half of Americans report using AI, while about 4.5% of U.S. consumers pay for an AI subscription; within the paying segment, the top 10% account for more than half of revenue and the top 1% for 20%, with the top 1% spending $93 monthly versus a $25 median. The report’s spending data is based on consumer card spend and excludes enterprise and SMB spending. Of 50 products ranked by spend, 29 were absent from the traffic lists, while only 11 new products appeared across the web and mobile traffic lists.
- Consumer assistants are growing quickly but have not yet reached mainstream users; in an early-adopter community, coding and technical automation remained the leading agent use case, while assistants aimed at mainstream consumers reportedly cost tens rather than thousands of dollars per user-month. The speakers identify trust, privacy, and security around access to personal email, life details, and credit cards—and the risk of unexpected actions or sharing—as major adoption constraints.
- Consumer AI monetization still leans heavily on paid use: about 85% of products on the web list monetized through subscriptions, 62% through credits or extra usage, and 13% through ads or other options. High inference costs can make companies wary of growing too quickly without usage controls. The speakers said OpenAI had reached about a $1B annualized advertising run rate as of August and cited 1.2B weekly active users; they see commercial queries as an ad opportunity but stress that ads must fit the interaction without undermining trust.
- ChatGPT remained the leading consumer product, with roughly six times Claude’s and twice Gemini’s web usage; a U.S. spender panel found Claude had passed Gemini in paid subscriber count despite Gemini’s larger overall user base. Anthropic’s no-ads position coincided with about 7.5% of its subscribers on a $100-plus monthly plan, versus about 1% for ChatGPT and Gemini.
- The speakers’ startup thesis is that differentiated software experiences, accumulated user or organizational context, and networks can create value above the model layer; they cite Town’s hard-to-migrate user-specific email playbooks as an example, and argue incumbents have struggled to innovate beyond existing chat and coding interfaces. Potentially open categories include dating, recruiting, shopping, home buying, and retail; they report no social-AI product taking off and say gaming and entertainment generation remains constrained, with AI micro-dramas an exception. Audio offers a specialist-product signal: ElevenLabs and Suno ranked highly in traffic and spending, while the speakers said Suno had built a strong lead as large labs had not prioritized music amid IP concerns.
- Menlo is targeting the defining AI companies of its era. The guest described AI fundraising as exceptionally large, with some new labs seeking billions, and said large funds may treat seed checks as a way to secure access—accepting seed prices they might otherwise question because they intend to invest more if a company becomes an outlier.
- The guest frames each seed investment as an option: make enough bets to find an outlier, then increase position size when revenue and other quantifiable evidence supports it. Because investor-favored metrics can be gamed, he prioritizes founders building terminal value over markups.
- Menlo says it owns less than 2% of Anthropic and has reached 20% fund exposure to one company; the guest’s preferred approach is to establish a position and scale it as evidence improves, rather than take the largest risk before the company is proven. Menlo also estimates that a 10% initial stake may fall to 3.5–4% by exit, with dilution depending in part on the time horizon and pace of growth.
- The guest argues that AI companies need substantial compute and capital to scale, driving fast fundraising and deployment; he says LPs should question how managers handle deployment pace and vintage diversification. He also argues that the AI infrastructure and model “tax” means private-market returns must beat the no-fee, no-carry public-market alternative by about 1,000 basis points.
- He cautions against underwriting a presumed incumbent acquisition as downside protection: strategic buyers may hire founders rather than protect investors, and he cites dot-com-era acquisitions of companies with no product or revenue as a precedent that did not guarantee a floor after the cycle turned.
- For early-stage diligence, he looks at what brought founders together and how they understand one another’s strengths and weaknesses, as clues to decision-making and company culture. He asks how a founder’s friends would describe them and checks references against the founder’s self-awareness.
- A host floated oxytocin nasal spray as a possible consumer-health product and suggested telehealth brands such as Hims or BlueChew could sell it; the hosts stressed that efficacy and safety were unknown and that available evidence was limited and not yet conclusive, making this a speculative thesis rather than validated product-market evidence.
- The hosts propose interest-based membership communities as a way to monetize belonging through financial products; they cite AARP as a trusted brand and marketing channel that partners with United for health insurance rather than providing the coverage itself.
- Angel Studios was described as having 2–3 million members paying $13–$20 monthly and about $450 million in ARR; members vote on proposed content, and projects need more than 70% approval to proceed.
- Altman favors broad access and lighter-touch AI regulation, accepting bounded misuse risks for AI’s benefits and human agency; he says catastrophic loss-of-control risks warrant caution and that OpenAI would not advocate licensing models one or two generations behind the frontier.
- Altman said OpenAI was preparing further incident disclosures and that he knew of no additional incidents at the severity of the cluster under discussion; some disclosures involve security vulnerabilities being given time for remediation. He also called for a liability framework for model providers, potentially including a separate regime for AI training, and said this behavior during training is unacceptable.
- Altman said silicon wafer supply, rather than financing, was driving OpenAI’s cost increases, while financing remained easy to obtain. Asked about a reported 2027 IPO delay, he said he expected OpenAI to be ready from safety and financial perspectives once it had several safety cases under its belt, while noting market changes could affect plans.
- Altman said OpenAI’s best internal model was well ahead of the best Chinese companies’ internal models, but he could not quantify the lead and said the basis for the assessment was imperfect. He also said making products harder to distill could reduce open-ended creativity, and OpenAI had not settled on a preferred response.
- Altman cited economic-impact anxiety and concentration of power as drivers of negative public perceptions of AI; he said political spending would not fix that perception and that parts of the industry were tone-deaf to public concerns.
- The Two Minute Papers presenter says Sonnet 5.5 ported part of the AVBD research code into a single HTML file and reproduced its physics experiments; he also demonstrates ray tracing.
- He claims Opus 5.5 roughly matches Fable’s quality at about 2.5 times lower cost, and Sonnet 5.5 is about five times cheaper than Fable; his suggestion that lower cost means smaller models is an inference, not a stated model-size measurement.
- The presenter argues that capability may depend more on training than parameter count and predicts frontier-level systems could eventually run on laptops or phones, lowering the barrier for individuals and small teams; he explicitly cautions that he could be wrong.
- AI use is broader than paid adoption: about half of Americans report using AI and roughly 25% say they interact with it close to daily, while a16z’s Yipit panel estimates that 4.5% of US consumers subscribe to an AI product (other sources cited put the figure at 2–2.5%); the panel estimate has doubled in a year.
- Monetization is highly concentrated: among paying consumers, the top 10% drive more than half of revenue and the top 1% account for 20%; the post separately quotes the top 1% user spending $903 per month versus a $25 median. Spending is concentrated in developer, productivity, and creative tools used to build, make, and sell.
- In its accompanying discussion, a16z says subscriptions may not ultimately be the model that brings consumer AI to everyone and points to white space in shopping, entertainment, social, dating, and marketplaces.
Grep AI, a YC Fall 2026 startup, says its agents learn from each run by moving repeatable steps into code and workflows while reserving frontier-model reasoning for exceptions, with the goal of making the agents cheaper as they scale. The company reports that its agents have saved customers including IG, Airwallex, Worldpay, FV Bank, and Citizens Bank more than 250,000 hours; at IG, it says agents reviewing compliance alerts help over 80% of traders onboard without manual intervention. Garry Tan argues that startup-built agent harnesses can provide practical utility where lab harnesses have an incentive to burn tokens, citing Grep’s approach of turning token use into deterministic, tested, repeatable code based on observed agent use.
Garry Tan says AGI science loops are coming and describes Halmos as building “Muse/Instinct” for them. Halmos frames the opportunity around roughly $100 billion in annual life-science experimentation spending and its claim that 93% of drug programs entering Phase I never reach approval; it says it is changing that.
- Andrew Chen says a new wave of polished, consumer-friendly horizontal agents—including Muse, Town, Instinct, and Grokbot—is prompting vertical-agent startups to reassess their market position. He argues agents are not inherently networked: they can interoperate across products, and models and context can be switched or ported, so better models, UX, integrations, memory, or distribution can build large businesses without necessarily creating network effects.
- For investors, the key question is where agent network effects accrue. Shareable artifacts and shared identity, reputation, relationships, private context, and intent could strengthen acquisition or engagement; horizontal agents may try to capture those functions, while incumbents and startups may expose their networks to agents generally. If network functions remain open or specialized, agents could stay interchangeable and vertical agents could thrive; if horizontal agents keep valuable network assets proprietary, switching could mean leaving those networks behind.
A proposed future media model combines print with podcasts and video.
- a16z’s Olivia Moore frames an underexplored consumer-AI opportunity as products that help people spend time, not merely save it: she contrasts the appeal of social and entertainment products with AI’s current focus on making tasks faster, easier, or more impressive, which she says may not create a compelling daily or hourly proposition for most people.
- The consumer-AI discussion says only a small share of consumers currently pay, with spending concentrated among developers, creators, and other power users; it questions whether subscriptions will ultimately bring consumer AI to everyone and identifies open categories including shopping, entertainment, social, dating, and marketplaces.
Paul Graham says problem selection is a learned skill: “juicy” problems tend to lead to interesting discoveries, while “nasty” problems tend not to. He distinguishes juicy problems by their unity around one main thing to solve, versus nasty problems’ collections of often extrinsic constraints. Nasty problems can still be worthwhile: real-world problems are often nasty, and working on them can make money or improve lives; the caution is to choose them deliberately.
For founders whose company name’s .com is unavailable, Paul Graham recommends choosing another name rather than using a workaround such as try<name>.ai . He argues that “the .com” is simply the only .com they have thought of so far .
Standard Capital recently led Jeevy Fabrication’s Series A; the company builds rocket hardware—including tanks, piping, fluid systems, and structural assemblies—for customers including SpaceX and Lockheed Martin. Jeevy is using AI and a data-rich coordination layer to address the hardware bottleneck of getting parts on-spec and on-time; Jeevesh previously worked on Starship ground-support equipment at SpaceX and at Rondo Energy.
- Venky Ganesan says tranched financing began as lower-valuation “build with me” capital followed by a higher-priced tranche, but is now widely used without being tied to company quality—an indicator to watch for financing-cycle froth, not proof by itself that a company or the market is in a bubble.
- Harry Stebbings credits Menlo’s $4 billion Anthropic round—which he says will make Menlo a $50 billion-plus firm—with subsequent investments in Lovable, Higgsfield, and Legora; he says the Anthropic win helped re-establish Menlo among leading venture firms.
- The post’s seed-stage guidance is to treat each deal as an option: build a broad enough portfolio for sufficient opportunities, then increase investment only when quantifiable, revenue-based metrics show an outlier.
- The post argues that AI startups’ compute and foundation-model costs give public-market alternatives an advantage for LPs, so private VCs need to outperform public tech indices by at least 1,000 basis points to justify private capital. It also argues that AI’s high capital needs make smaller funds and slower deployment difficult to reconcile, since faster-moving competitors may capture category winners.
- Ganesan identifies leveraged-debt defaults, rather than equity write-downs, as a typical market-cycle failure point, making leverage and timing important risks in an AI boom. The post gives a two-sided valuation view: paying a premium may be warranted by a larger-than-consensus market opportunity, while markups chased by copycats for momentum rather than fundamentals can inflate a bubble.
Scott Kupor said the Super Intelligence Force will advise the President on both keeping the U.S. ahead in superintelligence and doing so responsibly, considering economic, security, national-sovereignty, and individual-rights interests. USOPM described him as Vice Chair of the White House Super Intelligence Task Force.
YC startup Sensible Bio (YC S21) raised a $47M Series A to develop mRNA manufacturing using living cells as factories. Its platform can produce around 1,000 mRNA sequences per week; the company says this addresses the higher dose and purity requirements of emerging mRNA medicines such as in vivo CAR-T and gene editing, which current cell-free processes designed for vaccine-scale doses cannot meet.
- a16z’s seventh Top 100 Consumer AI Apps edition adds a revenue leaderboard alongside its web and mobile traffic rankings. ChatGPT remains on top, with 1B+ monthly mobile actives; Claude ranks #3 on web with nearly 1B monthly visits.
- Consumer AI has expanded beyond chatbots and image generators into vibe coding (Lovable, Cursor, Replit), music (Suno), design (Figma), voice (ElevenLabs), video (Higgsfield, Kling), agents (Manus), and hardware (Plaud).
SF Tech Week 2026 lists 1,700+ events—more than double the number two years earlier—with 1,266 hosts from 1,058 companies; Andrew Chen says a16z/Speedrun is hosting a Demo Day with 1,000+ investors, and Speedrun portfolio companies are hosting 100+ events.
The fastest-growing event-calendar themes were hardware (tripled, the strongest and most consistent growth), cybersecurity (more than tripled from a small base, largely driven by AI security as companies deploy agents), infrastructure (more than doubled amid interest in compute and the AI stack), and deep tech (doubled, with more science- and research-led startups).
- In a16z’s seventh Top 100 Consumer AI Apps edition, 9 of 15 consumer internet categories have no AI product in the Top 100, including streaming, social, dating, gaming, travel, retail, finance, real estate, and jobs—pointing to gaps in consumer-AI coverage across categories that produced major companies in earlier internet eras.
- The same edition reports ChatGPT at 1B+ monthly mobile active users and Claude at nearly 1B monthly web visits, while consumer AI apps now span areas such as coding, music, design, voice, video, agents, and hardware.
The Current State of Consumer AI
- Consumer AI use is broad but paid spend remains concentrated: roughly half of Americans report using AI, while about 4.5% of U.S. consumers pay for an AI subscription; within the paying segment, the top 10% account for more than half of revenue and the top 1% for 20%, with the top 1% spending $93 monthly versus a $25 median. The report’s spending data is based on consumer card spend and excludes enterprise and SMB spending. Of 50 products ranked by spend, 29 were absent from the traffic lists, while only 11 new products appeared across the web and mobile traffic lists.
- Consumer assistants are growing quickly but have not yet reached mainstream users; in an early-adopter community, coding and technical automation remained the leading agent use case, while assistants aimed at mainstream consumers reportedly cost tens rather than thousands of dollars per user-month. The speakers identify trust, privacy, and security around access to personal email, life details, and credit cards—and the risk of unexpected actions or sharing—as major adoption constraints.
- Consumer AI monetization still leans heavily on paid use: about 85% of products on the web list monetized through subscriptions, 62% through credits or extra usage, and 13% through ads or other options. High inference costs can make companies wary of growing too quickly without usage controls. The speakers said OpenAI had reached about a $1B annualized advertising run rate as of August and cited 1.2B weekly active users; they see commercial queries as an ad opportunity but stress that ads must fit the interaction without undermining trust.
- ChatGPT remained the leading consumer product, with roughly six times Claude’s and twice Gemini’s web usage; a U.S. spender panel found Claude had passed Gemini in paid subscriber count despite Gemini’s larger overall user base. Anthropic’s no-ads position coincided with about 7.5% of its subscribers on a $100-plus monthly plan, versus about 1% for ChatGPT and Gemini.
- The speakers’ startup thesis is that differentiated software experiences, accumulated user or organizational context, and networks can create value above the model layer; they cite Town’s hard-to-migrate user-specific email playbooks as an example, and argue incumbents have struggled to innovate beyond existing chat and coding interfaces. Potentially open categories include dating, recruiting, shopping, home buying, and retail; they report no social-AI product taking off and say gaming and entertainment generation remains constrained, with AI micro-dramas an exception. Audio offers a specialist-product signal: ElevenLabs and Suno ranked highly in traffic and spending, while the speakers said Suno had built a strong lead as large labs had not prioritized music amid IP concerns.