0:01Okay, we're in. Oo, Eric.
0:06Always a pleasure for for lesson 11 out of 10. I love it.
0:09Yes, definitely. Eric, it's going to be all you today, except I'm just going to show I know I haven't shown you or Jonno how I got your questions yet, so I'll show everybody else at the same time. So, we've got a list of questions for you um that as you know were from the um Discord um which I'll share my screen. So, we've got lesson 11 has some questions.
0:45Bonus lessons request lesson thread has some questions. Lesson 9 and 10 had some questions.
0:50Oh, so many. Um, so I um jumped into solve it and I uh already have some functions to basically talk to Discord. It's quite cool in Discord. You can if you go into cookies, you can like select your your cookie session key and you can provide that as a token that also works as an API. It's kind of unofficial um but it
1:17works great for me. Um, and so we just got these little functions that use HTTPX to make a request to the API and then you can use that to make requests like search for messages or get a thread so forth. Get the messages for a thread. Um, so then I you can go into Discord, which is quite neat, and rightclick and say copy channel ID.
1:44And so you can just dump them in here.
1:45Here, I think you have to click something to turn on developer mode in the settings to have that added. This is a good trick if you're in learning mode, but you also say, "I'm on a deadline cuz I only started this 2 hours before the lesson." It it's reasonably more back and forth, but it also doesn't say like, "I hope you learn the Discord API. All you need to do is do these five things."
2:04It's like, "No, no, no." It's like, "Okay, okay, okay, here it is." So, grab the messages with it. That's great. Uh, so I just tried it on lesson 11, tried it with a thread.
2:15Um, and then what I did was I, um, Eric G, uh, as you might have seen, did an amazing job of like creating detailed information about each lesson, um, skills and all kinds of stuff. So, and then at the very end there's this kind of like quick narrative of Did you know we had a four act structure in our courses? So, I popped that in there because I read the summary.
2:44Yeah. And then um then I just ran that which um and now I've got all the questions from each section. And then I uh told Sulit who I am and what I want to do. Uh I said have a look through the list of questions.
3:07Tell me about which ones you think are relevant or not. I like yep that looks pretty good. Um so go ahead and create a dictionary of topics and questions sorted in this way. Uh do you want to add some more? Sure.
3:22Here's some more if you get to them. Um, then I just checked a couple and it's like, "That's weird. This message entirely says golden sword." And I was like, "Wait, got a message says golden sword." So yeah, don't mind me. I'll try again. Um, yeah. So then I just went ahead and looped through them, added all the messages in sections with what pick these topic summaries.
3:45Yes, it did all that. So I said, um, Oh, yeah. You just said topic description AB.
3:52Yeah, exactly. clever.
3:56Um, and I have exported equals true.
4:00Um, and so then I hit the publish button and added a HTML on the end. And so there you've got the publish lesson. So that's what you have, Eric. Um,
4:18so we could like start at the top like do do you want to do this like do you want to share your screen and show what question you're looking at or or I could jump between sharing screen and not mine what you answer or any thoughts let's do it.
4:34Yeah, I think I think if we just literally go through the questions it's going to get kind of mind-numbing and the conversation will be very disjointed because we'll be switching topics so often. And so I think it's better if we kind of have a conversation kind of guided by these questions as inspiration rather than great just wrote answering them because there's so many I mean I just I'm just getting a sense of how many are in this thing. It's so here's the first topic right organizational structure and governance.
5:01Um so the questions are how do we set up answer AI?
5:07Um, yeah. What's the heart of answering?
5:13Yeah. What What the heck are we doing?
5:15Yeah, exactly. I mean, I appreciate this is more eloquent than that, but um, cool. Yeah. Yeah, this is great. And, and I, first of all, I want to say special thank you to everybody who has posted their reading dialogue from the book. I've read every single one of those and have found them just absolutely utterly fascinating. So as a as an I want to ask about that too which is would you would you want to like is there some dialogue shared that you want to start start there and talk about some reaction to your book or do you want to start with these? Um let's do the questions because I didn't I didn't expect to get so many questions
5:44and I don't know how many we'll be able to get through in the time. I I would mean I would find it very self-indulgent and fun to read through some of the feedback but I think a lot of it was um I don't know if it would be interesting to other people versus they can just click on the on the links themselves.
5:57What was your overall takeaway from what My overall takeaway was Yeah. like um so many people posted a dialogue where um close reading bailed them out of a misconception or opened up a um a level of insight they weren't able to get on their own that I just feel like that is such a gamecher and I don't know even how many of the readers appreciated this. There were quite a few times when someone it can either because they didn't understand something like there were people who are like you know I I didn't know there were people who didn't
6:26know the word status quo you know like I thought everyone knows that but no it turns out that's some people were like what's what does status quo mean it's like so great to be able to get that question answered because if you're confused about what a word means it's super valuable to know before you continue but the more important ones were the people who were skeptical and who were like I just don't agree or I'm worried about or I don't think it can be right and I think even one of the one of the somebody actually put in there that they tried to have Claude debate with them and often it's too agreeable to really debate. So I did notice that like
6:55if your first comment the very first thing you say in the dialogue is something somewhat skeptical, Claude will then be skeptical with you the whole rest of the way. And if the first thing you say is like I really like the writing of this, it'll it'll start to get really exaggerate how much it loves the writing too. So you got to be careful about that. But just this the basic idea that there were like times when people were like I'm skeptical. Is this really true? Claude would be like actually this is well established by research. Here's what you need to know.
7:18Like if you don't have that grounding of trust with the author, then your whole reading is colored by this like wrong sense you have that something, you know, that you're being tricked and that something's being pulled over, uh, you know, something something's happened to you that's not appropriate. So to me, that was the most interesting part of it was the unlocking of comprehension that that the reading experience did for people. That was super cool.
7:42Great. And then I just appreciate all the feedback. Like so many people had great comments like I've seen this at my work or like what do I do about this?
7:47The people who applied it to their own situations. It's just so incredibly interesting. So you know I know it's a little bit vulnerable to share stuff like that and I appreciate it very much.
7:58Um yeah and folks are also welcome to ask in the um YouTube chat of course um if you have any questions. Um okay. Yeah. So the first kind of set of questions is basically about um how we set up answer AI's governance to protect its mission and what is that mission and why is that its mission um
8:32you know also LTSSE how did you set that similar Um, okay. Then there's a couple of other related ones, but maybe, yeah, let's start.
8:43Well, I do think this is one of the downsides of the book book makes it seem a little more complicated than it really is in practice because there's so many different I'm trying to address a wide range of situations. the situation of a venture-backed company, you know, with an extremely missiondriven approach that is like really integral to the strategy of it and a, you know, charismatic and and credible founder is one of the easiest cases of all where you have to figure this stuff out because you're you
9:13get to design it from scratch from the beginning. So, we you know, Jeremy and I set up Answer AI when it was just an ID on a napkin. There was no no legacy anything to have to worry about. But we were able to design it just the way that we wanted and we were able to choose investors who were bought into that vision and who therefore would do the design with us rather than having to have an adversarial process which was you know super helpful. And I think the main reason it went so well is that the investors understood that this was not just a random
9:41um request to do things in an odd way but it was integral to the vision for the company. So you know uh we've talked before I think uh in these classes but if not you know answer is a public benefit corporation. If you're not sure what that is you can read chapter 9. Um you can get the whole whole history of how how uh public benefit corps were invented is in chapter 12 and why there are actually a restoration of an older idea about how corporate companies should run uh is covered in chapter 4.
10:09So I'll try not to be redundant since those things are easily accessible to everybody who's listening. But we had to draft a corporate charter amendment that literally says the purpose of Answer AI is and then it has a little paragraph about um what we're planning to do uh with the company. Now I have not memorized this paragraph and so I'm not going to attempt to remember correctly exactly what it said. Um Jeremy has a better memory than I do so he may he may be able to remember the language that we
10:38used. But I guess I want to emphasize that like it's not like a big deal that we had to get it like perfectly word smmith. We didn't spend months on like the most exact perfect thing because the point of a public benefit corp is not that you then are bound to only do this thing and therefore if you get it wrong you're like stuck and can't do what you want to do. Uh the purpose is to allow the management of the company and the board in particular to balance this purpose against the standard purpose of maximizing shareholder value. So, if
11:06we're ever in a situation where we have to choose between, you know, doing something that we think is beneficial for our mission versus something that has like immediate short-term investor u, you know, returns, we have the freedom to say, no, we've told everybody, we're going to make these choices sometimes, and even if they appear to you as an investor or as an outside observer, they don't seem profit maximizing to me. You understand that the whole thesis here is that by achieving this mission, we're all going to make more money in the long run. And on that there's a question at the end
11:35which is like PBC lets you define and measure your own mission. A simple majority can change it. So says when I should say if you and Jeremy move on what keeps answer AI a force for good?
11:50Yeah that's a great question and that is um to still be done like I don't consider our governance to be finished um precisely because of this problem.
11:59like if we were to die then there would no longer be any mission guardians to um protect the company. So that's actually very important um that we do more than just this. But to correct one misconception in the question um PBC and it depends on what state you're in but I believe in Delaware PBC requires a 2/3 or 3-4 majority of investors to undo it.
12:16So it's actually not super easy to undo but it is very much like a constitution. Constitutions as people I think have been learning more and more lately are not self-executing.
12:27they require a mechanism, a human mechanism to make sure that um that structure is maintained and preserved uh through leadership succession and through other kinds of situations. And of course, a lot of the book is about how to create what I call a governance fortress or even better a spiritual holding company that that creates that that structural mechanism. So because there would be like that's something would be a force, right? There would be a force to keep it on mission. The force would be Jono for example and folks like Jono in the
12:57company but I presumably if Jono wanted to run a company he'd be running a company rather than being at ours. So that's the problem. Yeah that's why a lot of companies have succession problems. I I and in the book we're talking very much because you asked about PBC's we're talking about the the structural side of it. I think it's really important and again for you who haven't read the book, you have to see this as an integrated operational/cultural plus governance/structural solution. So like the real reason that answer is
13:27going to be a beneficial force in the world is because of its ethos. Why does it have such a strong ethos? Because of people like Jonno who actually do the work and live the values every day. I call people like Jonno torchbearers. people who regardless of their formal authority or like whatever it says on their business card, nonetheless embody and act out the mission in ways that they don't have to be told to do so.
13:45That's just naturally how they see what the company's purpose is. And so the true reason that answer is um something worth protecting is how I say it in the book is because we have this ethos. Now, so if Jeremy were to die tomorrow, god forbid, um it's not like the ethos would evaporate overnight. I think we would still keep it going. But we would be now vulnerable.
14:08A mission guardian who had stood as a shield protecting the company's ethos would now be removed and we would want to replace that with something. So the best shields are um structural in nature, not personal in nature. Um so for example in the book we talk about the Costco governance fortress that has preserved Costco's ethos through now four CEO transitions um over 40 years. That's pretty impressive. You know Patagonia is going up on 60 years now.
14:32like and of course um Nova Nordisk has a really really strong version of this and they're they're going 100 years strong. So at some point I hope that the governance that we set up for answer is only the initial governance and we'll continue to evolve and add the things that are needed to make it a permanent institution.
14:48Eric, one thing that helps a lot, I think, is that there's two of us. And although you made a conscious decision to kind of say like, well, Jeremy, my I'm going to tell you from the start, my job is to help you protect your mission. I'm not going to try and tell you what the mission should be. Nonetheless, we are set up that well a you and I built up a deeply trusting relationship long before we started
15:16about building a company and then b highly recommend you do actually have super voting shares like I do less of them but I believe if I did die you would become the super voting majority shareholder so as somebody who lives the mission even though you're not personally primarily setting it that seems like the kind of thing that can help a Yeah.
15:39Yeah. No, you definitely want belt and suspenders, stuff like that. Um, and the other thing is that answer has the advantage of being intentionally small from a headcount point of view.
15:50Everything we're describing gets more difficult as the number of human beings that need to be aligned grows. Now, we're recording this video, so you know, will this still be the case 2, 5, 10 years from now and people watching this video? And we hope that's our that is absolutely our intention. But, you know, we have to make sure like one of the things I try to really advocate for is that people see governance not as a one-time thing. You set it up and then you're done, but like an ongoing form of maintenance where you're always checking to see like, are we actually still being true to our purpose? Do we have
16:18fidelity? So, it's a little bit like people often say like, oh, you build a strong foundation of your house. As if once you build the foundation of a house, you're done. But if anyone's ever been a homeowner, you know how much like routine maintenance and checking and how many foundation issues just like that is a um uh absolutely recurring uh recurring nightmare of owning owning any kind of structure and this and a corporate structure is no different. So I kind of view it like Jeremy and I have paid the down payment on Answer Aai's future governance and we are committed
16:46to maintain and defend it as we go. Including you know if this we're doing this for a really long time you know we don't even need to be hit by a bus.
16:54there might come a time when we're like naturally it's time for us to retire and therefore like what happens. So a lot of companies leave succession questions like that to the end and then have a crisis. Um so hopefully you know my hope is that we'll be at this a long time yet before we have to get to these issues. But that will we won't waste that time.
17:13We'll use that time to build up um the roster of people that we want to have join us as mission guardians and we want to you know build these other um more permanent structures before that becomes necessary. Jonah, do you have thoughts about all this?
17:28Um, not hugely. I I I I guess I I I I feel that Enzi does have this sort of special case status in that we have it a lot easier than a lot of other places because it's so built around um the two of you and that vision and being a small team. So there's never like there's never an imaginable future where it's like oh you know Jono and his friends and their handful of shares must try and outvote the you know evil corporate overlords. It's it's very it's like yeah
17:57like you said Eric it's it's easy mode when you have aligned investors who are on board from the start with the structure. You have um you know the the two people whose core vision still involved rather than um you know uh deep in their retirement home somewhere. So yeah, I feel like you have it easy, but it also the nice thing is with something like this, it is self-perpetuating in that at any point in the future when a decision comes up around how to structure something or who to bring on or anything like that, you do have this thing to point at, right? Where you can
18:26say, "Okay, well, we do want to also make sure that we stay aligned with that original thing back when we were getting started. We said we'd always be small. Jeremy, we're up to 16 and coming on 20.
18:37You know, should we be thinking about slowing down on the hiring?" you know, whatever the like original values are, you've got those touch points to say, is this going to make a benefit everyone or is this just a cash grab for us? So, look, we've got a public benefit. Um, yeah, it feels like there is that security in knowing that as we go on, even if I'm not like the super voting majority, we all have the like piece to point to to say, "Yeah, we have the mission and we can make the decisions that perpetuate that." I think it's also
19:07interesting how those early like specific rules of thumb help. So we we had a specific rule of thumb of um aiming to average around 12 people. And it's interesting even though we haven't expressly done things to explicitly do that. If you actually look right now at like the average headcount we've had throughout our history, I think it's almost exactly 12. Uh it's like you can kind of when people everybody has in their head a
19:35vague kind of vision of what the company would look like operating then you can kind of dayto-day make it happen that way. Um Eric you mentioned um being a smaller company and how so many things are easier that way. There's been a very interesting set of questions and discussion on Discord about about that.
19:57um at a kind of a really what I find quite an interesting abstract level. So um if I could provide a little bit of background for everybody else that you all know um nobody says that there has to be companies or or firms uh the the theory of the firm from Ronald Coast in like 1934 or something says that um firms exist uh basically in order to decrease transaction costs.
20:26um uh kind of coordination problems are much easier when people exist within this particular kind of structure we call a firm. There's been some questions in discord about like well
20:41is what answer.ai AI is doing suggesting that the theory of the firm which is so then co said co said that where if transaction costs lower you would should expect more cooperation to have happen through marketplaces rather than within a firm. So yeah there's a lot of interest you know there's a to make this very practical a lot of people are asking like okay I've got things I want to do and make money from doing do I
21:10need to create a firm you know can we envisionage a future in which there's a bunch of very small entities possibly with one person in um would having a marketplace you know of cooperation between those entities be a good idea and then uh just today there was a question like is this community we have the solver community potentially a place that such
21:36a marketplace could form. One of my very favorite parts of the book that I had to cut um so many good things I had to cut um was um in in the one of the early chapters I tried to really help people understand like what is an organization. In order to do that I pulled I think 20 different definitions by 20 different thinkers who all define it differently.
22:02um and then tried to show why we have such a wide variety of ideas about why firms form and what they're what they're for. And I likened it to like if you imagine all the different specialists of a human body, you know, like if you study the circulatory system versus the nervous system, it's natural for you to see that as like kind of the most important system in the body. And so like people who study the nervous system will be like very much like the brain controls the body. The brain says what to do and what to do. But like people who study the immune system are like what are you talking about? nothing the
22:32immune system does under the conscious control of the brain. The brain is at best an appendage, you know, that there to help. And anyone who's challenged on like, well, you're saying your thing is the most important always resorts to the same thing. It's like, well, take my thing away and the body would die. True.
22:46True. They're all absolutely 100% essential, but like does that make them the reason that the thing exists? So, first thing is like, so anyway, I had to cut this because it was like I found this this history fascinating and a lot of test readers were like, "What are you talking about?" So, um, well, well, I'm trying to figure out if we can find a way to make it a downloadable bonus or something. I thought it was super cool.
23:07Um, and I wanted to show how if you kind of if you group these stories about what a corporation is into roughly two camps, they basically tell the exact same story but in reverse order. So, it's like some people are like a founder has the brilliant idea and then they raise money and assemble a team and build an ecosystem and from that figure out a business model. the business model demands certain products which are then distributed and then get to the customer. So like you begin with the founder and you end with the market. But like and and a lot of people watching
23:36this will be like oh yeah obviously how else could you do it? Well talk to people in economics or a lot of other fields. They'll be like the start of a company is a market need. There's a hole in the market. A thing must be done. And so products are summoned up out of the market's need to serve this thing. The fact that products must be assembled requires a business model to do that which summons other vendors and partners to come together and collaborate. And as a result, you work your way up and like the last thing that happens is like some
24:04doofus has to be like the person who privatizes all these social gains for themselves and that person's the founder who's like you know an administrator of this social phenomenon has like the very like very little to do with the formation of the company. You know how founders hear the story are always so outraged. But like part of the reason we can't we have such a political disconnect when we talk about these things is we're operating from such very different stories. And if you go through the history of how people think about this generally people do is they locate which of those two stories they want to
24:33be part of and they slice out the part of the story that they're interested in doing their research on and then they write a definition that's like this is the the purpose of company. And I give you all this history just because one of my subtle goals with the book is to blow up people's confident understanding of what a company is. So the book actually defines it multiple different ways and tries to expand people's horizons about what is a company. Starting with the early idea that a company is actually a living super organism, a form of emergent intelligence just like AI. The
25:03oldest form of AI probably that we have uh is the joint stock corporation. But as the person who asked the question about fast AI and its alumni asked um when we get to chapter 10, I also then try to imagine get people to imagine something very different because although many times when people say I bought a product from a company like I bought a Coke and I say who did you buy it from? I bought it from the Coca-Cola company. They didn't actually transact with the entity the legal entity of the Coca-Cola company. Coca-Cola company
25:31actually just makes the syrup. Um they mostly own the patent to the syrup. The actual making of the syrup is made by bottlers and distributors as part of this massive constellation of companies that together produce the illusion of the Coca-Cola company.
25:46I've consulted for one of them in Australia. It's called Coca-Cola Amato and it's one of our biggest companies and their job is to be the uh logistics and distribution and packaging company for Coca-Cola in this region.
25:57Loves that. That's how they and I I McDonald's is the same way, right?
26:00McDonald's is mostly a real estate ownership company that licenses the right to be a franch. Anyway, you can like if you actually try to go to a normal person and try to tell them that when they went to McDonald's, they didn't buy the hamburger from McDonald's, they will look at you like you're crazy.
26:14Like it's such a convincing illusion that and if you look at the research, there's tons of academic research on this phenomenon. They always call it all these different names and they go through tremendous there's a lot of work people have to go through to avoid just saying that McDonald's is the company.
26:27And I just feel like it's so much simpler if we just acknowledge that since everyone who involved the people that work there and the people that buy from them and they're everyone understands that this is one thing, it's better to just call it one thing. I use the metaphor of the constellation. Um precisely it's the only um astronomical term in the book that is not a scientific astronomical term because of course people who have a science background read the book are often complaining to me. They're like, "But a constellation's not real."
26:53But that's my point. It is real. Oh, if you look up in the sky, you can clearly see Orion. You could only see it from this place on planet Earth. If you were on planet Mars, you would not see Orion, but like to human beings, it is real.
27:05So, the perception is actually the reality in this case. And I bring up all this long history to answer this question because I think it's feeling very unsettling to people that we're about to see this massive reset in transaction costs and therefore the configuration of firms and um the idea of the one person firm the the ubiquitous market that's a staple of science fiction. You can read um uh diamond age is a great book where this is just like not even what the book is about but in the background like what we
27:34think of as corporations are like long gone and there's a whole different thing going on. Um, and most people don't have a job in the conventional sense. They're like microcontracting, you know, via their AI agents to other people. That's like any staple of a lot of good science fiction. So, what I want people to realize is this is not a big deal. This this like slider of transaction cost has moved around a lot in history and will continue to move around a lot. What matters is what is the purpose that this collection of human beings have
28:03together. And I think that's why the fast AI constellation question is so interesting to me. One of the downsides, like one of the reasons why corporations are so eagerly embracing AI, even companies that are not able to get AI to do anything are still massively laying off human beings out of their excitement. It's like there's definitely like a big excitement about just getting rid of human beings who are the most unpleasant part of business and just be like finally we could just tell completely obedient, you know, intelligence will do what I say. that
28:31that idea is so alluring to the bosses of organizations that they're they're doing a lot of layoffs, premature celebration. But I think there is an insight to pay attention to here, which is that um if we if we didn't have firms and we only had individuals microcontracting, then we actually lose our ability to embed larger scale values into work. Everyone would just be, you know, at the mercy of the market and whatever its values are. So I actually think it's
29:01very important for people to start to think about how we can build organizations that are using AI in a powerful way with with nonetheless keeping human values at the center rather than these kind of more exploitative values that tend to be transmitted through these you know people who currently control uh control markets. So yes, I think there's a lot of startup opportunity right now in just a small team, maybe a team of one, you know, armed with the power of AI to go solve workflow problems that before required a lot of collaboration. I've
29:30already talked to many, many, many people who have gotten used to using AI in their daily life who just like they get a level of companionship and advice and structural supports that you just can't get from a human being because like human beings are actually very annoying. Like even the good ones, you know, it's just like requires a certain level of overhead to like communicate what you want to another person and have them communicate it back to you and they can't do it at 3:00 a.m. because they're asleep. Well, Claude is never asleep.
29:55Solve it is always on. It's always available. So, you know, so so it's like there's a whole recalibration that's going on here which is going to shake out a lot of business opportunities.
30:01with a bigger it's interesting like answer AI Eric as yeah you'll well remember is explicitly constructed in this way because we went back to first principles thought about the nature of the firm thought about how AI would impact and decided that from first principles it doesn't make sense to have a firm that scales headcount anymore um and one of the things that really stuck with me as we were putting it in
30:29place was saying like you said to Like, Jeremy, you you don't understand how weird this is. Like, I know you would assume everybody's doing this because we've thought through it and it obviously makes sense, but this is the only company I know that is actually structuring in a way that reflects [laughter] where we're actually at with technology.
30:53Um, so it's like it's certainly not something that lots of people are doing yet, even though it seems like more than when we started, but still quite rare. And this is one of those dog that didn't bark situations. Like every once in a while, a company like Anthropic will put out a post about how they're using AI internally.
31:14Um, and like it's cool. It's super cool. So compared to the baseline of how like normal companies operate, they're doing a lot of cool stuff using it internally. But if you're like if we're like minutes from AGI and we have this type like shouldn't it be a lot more than this? Like there should be a lot more going on than what you see going on. Now part of that of course is is there's a lot of hype effects happening and also like these companies are under tremendous pressure to scale
31:43rapidly and so like they're actually their opportunities for for innovating with AI is actually ironically constrained by the same and all of their advisers and investors and everything will be all telling them the standard playbook of how one scale is VC driven companies. No, I I know from I know from experience um that um yeah, I I've had some pretty unpleasant experiences of that um having to deal with conventional advisers being like actually winning these arguments um in ways that I think um are quite strange.
32:09But anyway, but but in the book I talk about how how the value of having a principled ethos and being able to think from first principles, think for yourself like this whole chapter on figure it out as a as like a a rallying cry that one thing that makes sensei work is that and and Jeremy is not unique in this but I one of the things I admire about him when we encounter a difficulty so like for example um we need something done that requires hiring
32:37a person but we've already said we're only going to hire 12 people. So now we cannot do the thing, nor can we hire the person. Most people encounter these difficulties as a source of frustration.
32:47Like that's annoying. Now I need to break one of the two rules cuz I have to get the thing done or I have to be mad about it. But the really really great entrepreneurs love these moments as an opportunity to figure it out. let us find a new solution that honors both of our commitments that will drive us to all kinds of um opportunities both to discover a new solution but also to demonstrate our ethos is how we demonstrate that we're serious about something when we encounter difficulty.
33:14We don't give up. We always look for the synthesis or like new possibility. And generally speaking, because human beings are very creative, when challenged to do so, they generally can if if the principles are good, you will find you will find solutions you didn't previously um you didn't previously imagine. And so um learning to see that as an opportunity rather than as a source of frustration is like a really valuable uh really valuable skill.
33:38Um I want to take a live question from the YouTube chat.
33:43Um I'll just read it directly. Um, how can So, this is from Yonathan. How can I find like-minded co-founders for a PBC or nonprofit? Few people in my existing network seem drawn to missiondriven work.
34:04I don't think you're going to like my answer very much, but I will give it to you anyway because of course the CL so I'll give you the classic Silicon Valley answer which is that you should first have had a long-term working relationship with their co-founder because you did something else together already which is super unhelpful because obviously if you knew somebody like that you would not be answering this question but I think a a a helpful way to reframe that as like well go do something go do something where you can have a chance to meet people like that um if you're in a social circle in a situation
34:34where you're not meeting people like that, maybe go do something else like and and there's so many great things you can do like I talk about in the book, go work on an open source project or like go be put be yourself in a work situation where you might be able to have collaborators who have the same shared ethos.
34:47And this is what happened for us, Eric. Like you and I both decided to try to help contribute our skills to the co response.
34:56And amongst other things, you started a podcast. Yeah.
35:00Um, you did a lot of community organization.
35:03I started masks for all and then somebody I think I can't quite remember how it happened but somebody said I should go on your totally it was and very funny how these things happen. Well and and so go back to co co's a great example. I spent when co broke I was just like instantly in motion. I've done this through a lot of crises where I was like okay things need to be done. I know how to do some things. So I'm going to do what I can to try to help. And I I probably helped start I don't know how many nonprofits during co like quite a
35:32few because I was like people were like trying to do some crazy thing like I had a reputation here's a person you can call with a crazy thing and he won't say you're crazy he'll try to help you. um that has served me well uh over the years. But what was interesting is so many people I would be pitching everyone I talked to are like listen it's an emergency. People are dying in the street. You're stuck at home. You're going to feel better and it's your moral obligation and you're going to it's going to be really good for you in the
35:58long run if you help. Like that didn't work on a lot of people. Like a shocking number of people were like I don't see what's in it for me.
36:09No. And so like I mean I just spent all my time trying to find people who would help with things. I was like work involved with a lot of stuff. Now what's interesting is the those of us who were all part of that inner circle of people who were actually trying to get something done because there's so few of us. We all got to know each other and we're all like bonded for life anyway that like I have gone into business with multiple of those people and doing all kinds of stuff in the years since not just answer but lots of cool things. So like it generated lots and lots of professional opportunities for me and for lots of other people. That's not why
36:36I did it, but um it's a great way like if you find any opportunity to do something mission driven, but I will give you another answer that I think is more even more frustrating.
36:47This is very hard to believe until you've seen it in action. But if you can actually introspect truly and be like, I don't just want to do a mission-driven thing, but actually I am truly personally inspired to do this like specific huge impossible thing that just like I feel drawn to do.
37:08Um, most people don't have the courage to even face this in themselves because it's so terrifying. I tell you the first time it occurred to me that I was going to have to build LTSSE myself.
37:17I was not a happy camper um is not fun is actually quite frightening. Um but anyway, if you can face it, then secondly, can you have the courage to say it out loud? Not easy because people will look at you like what? That's not something that a human being does. What are you talking about?
37:33You you're mentally ill. Um but if you can do the introspection and you can say it out loud, like you will be shocked how the universe will part for you. And I can just tell you story after story after story of synchronicity after synchronicity where just just the very thing that I needed came to me when I least expected it. Uh including co-founders and all kinds of stuff. Um because there's something really magnetic about these deep hard missions that are being pursued in a principled way. Perhaps in the the book there's a
38:02whole chapter called harder is easier where you can read about the the evidence that these magnetic powers are not some metaphysical woowoo but actually like there's hard evidence that what I'm saying is is true had been repeatedly measured uh in very empirical ways. So I I think you might consider trying it out and see what happens. Now the key is you can't just be like well I'm going to do my little thing. You have to have the courage to be like, I think we should solve global warming.
38:28And you have to whatever it is, right?
38:30Like you have to that's that's maybe the one place I I see people miss. It's like, okay, I'm going to work on this really hard problem because hard problems attract talent. It's like, okay, but if you're like shut in your garage, if nobody knows, how are they supposed to find out that you're working on the high? Totally. Oh my god. I So maybe that's another like another reminder for people who you've got the hard problem like or you've got the set of values, right? Even if you're just broadcasting that set of values somehow like these are my things I care about doing something about this ongoing crisis or doing something about this particular challenge.
38:58You're in the fast AI or the solvent community you're already surrounded by tons of capable like-minded people. So like sometimes it's just a matter of saying it out loud and just like does anybody want to work on this with me?
39:06I was going to mention that Eric actually um so Kevin Bird just mentioned in the chat he found his co-founder through Fast AI 10 years ago. Um that's a common story and fast is an interesting community and always has been in that it's not even necessarily people who are drawn to the same mission but it is a community that generally draws missiondriven people and also people who are prepared to think about bit outside
39:35the box you know because we're not accredited by Stanford and we don't you know we're not associated with answer AI, you We're not a c credential based organization and we also don't just teach the math in a bottom up way the same way as everybody else like we do things weirdly. So it is a good community if you're looking for folks who are creative and you know um have the you know to spend
40:05time working on ideas that are outside the mainstream.
40:11I couldn't agree more.
40:13Um, okay. So then, always difficult to figure out where to put the Zoom window, isn't it?
40:22[clears throat] Um, there's been a number of questions about existing organizations.
40:32Yeah. And yeah, you know, you've touched on that before, but it came up again this week or maybe in the last couple of days or somebody saying they they they tried to use a technique that you talked about.
40:49Oh, I love that in the course. So, do you Yeah. Do you want to just talk about that story?
40:54I have a lot of experience there. So, we haven't even talked about what a large chunk of people out there know me as the corporate innovation guy. I wrote a whole other book about it and and know a lot about about applying to to existing.
41:06What was that called? Like the startup way. Is that the startup way? Yeah. Um yeah, the basically startup is the blue book and the um startup way is a red book. So depending on what your background, you know me for one or the other. And of course I'm sure everyone in this audience knows me only for the blue book, but but if I go to cor more corporate elite settings, they know me for the red book. Um so I know a lot about about this and it's a really it's tricky because um there are techniques for applying these ideas in established organizations but they're harder to talk about universally because different organizations have different structures different cultures different different
41:36things but yeah we had this example in I guess it was in the previous solvent course I talked about this idea called the golden sword for cutting through bureaucracy which is one of my you know one of my oldtime favorites and somebody tried applying it and it and they said that summarize it what's what's the golden sword sure the golden sword is basically Like if you can find a decision maker in the organizational hierarchy who actually cares about getting things done, you can offer them a trade which is like in exchange for you give me permission to actually try this different way of working. I'm going to give you the
42:05things that you want much greater insight like scientifically valid much more frequent um insight into what's actually happening and no, you know, no political And for the right kind of leader, this is an irresistible offer. And I've seen a lot of times that that's actually that is the thing that's empowered teams to then go prove that some other way of working and that can be the germ of a new thing. So somebody posted in the forums that they tried this and it failed because um you know they they made the proposal, everyone said their proposal was great but then
42:34then the actual project was given to somebody else. And to me the idea that that's a failure is like so interesting because that's not a failure to me. I was like, you've got the most essential information you really needed to know about how this organization actually works. Um, and then I don't want, you know, people respect the privacy of the person who was asking the question, but like, um, they came to the the conclusion on their own of what that what the consequences of that are. And that's really when we talk about existing organizations, taking it back
43:03now to to more of the stuff we've been talking about so far, the most important thing is to realize that you as an individual person have a lot more agency with regard to the organizations you interact with than you realize. Mhm.
43:17Um, in the book I there's a whole chapter, chapter 15 that I talk all about this, but basically you perceive that you live at the mercy of the organizations that govern your life. You have a job. You work for a company. The company has a boss. You have to do what the boss says. And that's true. You live in a society. You have political parties. They control the government. Government passes the laws.
43:40You have to do what they say. You choose to buy this product or that product. You know, go into the supermarket. You choose the product that you can afford.
43:47You know, you you feel like they control you. But you have no idea until you've been behind the scenes like I have. You have no idea how much time and energy these organizations spend obsessing about what you will or won't do and what you will or won't put up with.
44:06So, one of the most valuable things you can do when you want to apply these ideas to existing organizations is just to have a really clear vision in your mind of what the right thing that they should be doing is then to hold them accountable to that standard. So, part of the reason I wrote this book was I wanted it when people go meet some company that says, "We're the good guys.
44:27We treat everybody like family. We're really awesome." You know, the people companies make these grandiose claims about how virtuous they are. I want people to be like, "Oh, really? Great. Did you do the stuff from chapter 5? No.
44:36How about stuff from chapter six? You do the stuff in chapter. Like it's a checklist. Do you do any of this stuff?
44:41And then next time someone tells you how great they are, you can be like, "Oh, you're lying to my face. Good to know." But more importantly than just yelling at them, say like, "You're a liar." Whatever. To condition your consent on their willingness to do the things that you want. Like this person was talking about, "Maybe I'm not at the right company." Yeah, maybe.
45:00That's a dangerous idea to realize you have agency here. If you don't think an organization is structured properly, you can work somewhere else. And because if you may think that they treat you like crap and they don't care, but I trust me, they care. They care a lot about what is going to attract talent. So, it's funny like these things don't go by the name of, you know, making employees happy or doing what they want. They go by other names like willingness to pay, you know, retention rates, employment, brand. There's all these different euphemisms that are just the question of
45:29like, will people put up with our or not?
45:33So, you actually have a lot of say over that. Like when you buy when you go into a store, you just think, "Oh, I'm buying the red box versus the green box." But the algorithms are watching you so carefully to be like, "Will this guy pay an extra 2.5 cents for the ethical product or not? They really want to know." And in every every time you make a choice like that is not a private choice. It ripples out into the whole economy. And anyway, I bring this up
46:01because um every time you make a choice like that, I guarantee you there is a corresponding meeting that somebody is having about your choice, right? Like there's some product manager who's desperately trying to convince their boss that we should do the right thing because customers will pay for it and the boss is saying no, they won't. And there's a HR person sitting with a manager being like, I really think we should stop treating people this way because they're going to quit. And he's like, "Nah, they're going to take it."
46:28And they treat it like a like a law of nature, but you are not a law of nature. You have choice. You have agency. So, yes, I believe it is possible to make even dramatic change in very stodgy old organizations. And I've done that on the innovation side, you know, many times in my career. So, I I I know of what it is really hard though, you know.
46:45Yeah. But I don't mean to make it sound easy at all. I I will say though, so the the example that was shared um they were kind enough to actually share the u proposal that they wrote for their organization and I asked you about it, Eric, and you said, "Yep, that proposal does successfully channel the things that you advised and it was not successful." And my perspective was,
47:12you know, my thought was like, well, writing the proposal is like the first one of it, you know, like definitely so to to in to to influence an organization, you need to know a lot about influence, you know. So I I actually suggested like couple of books like there's a book called to sell as human by Daniel Pink we've discussed before. has another really great book called influence by Robert Seondini which studies the the
47:40academic side of like what causes influence to happen. It's not it's absolutely not uh gather the logical pieces, place them together in a logical way.
47:54Write it down on a piece of paper. I share a story which um just to give a sense of kind of how I think about this uh which I think you know Eric which is uh after I went through the science of checking whether masks help reduce the transmission of respiratory diseases. I thought okay I need to now try to influence people to take advantage of this science.
48:24Um and I came across another guy who you know who seemed interested in the same topic and he couldn't have been more different to my kind of politics and values than me. He so the the kind of thing I think of as like being one of the worst decisions ever to be made in the United States was the Citizens United case which made um corporations basically have be treated as people um and given the same rights as people. Uh
48:52the guy I found was the main guy who developed that case and successfully brought it to fruition. And I thought, okay, well, anybody who can do that, like that's just seems like such a terrible idea that anybody could see.
49:06Anybody who can do that must be very good at influence. [laughter] And him and I teamed up and he was great, you know, and we remained friendly to this day, even though I continue to disagree with many of the things he holds dear. And um you know he turned out he was on really good terms with all the key politicians on you know in the Republican party who could get involved and you know and he ended up actually suggesting like oh we should talk to Robert Selini and this is another case of that kind of agency of
49:35being like oh yes we can actually ask the guy that wrote the book on influence to help us with this [laughter] and so he did he wrote a letter and we chatted to Bob and he's like yeah I actually I showed your email to my wife cuz I and she was like, "Oh, this guy really read your book, didn't didn't, you [laughter] know, it's like the book to the influence guy trying to influence him to work on the masks campaign and yeah, you know, ended up spending months trying to
50:04influence the WHO and the United States government, you know, and and we did successfully influence all of them. Um but it's just the whole thing was all about yeah you know the science was wrapped up within the first 3 weeks and then it was just so much work to get big organizations to actually move to understand all the humans involved and how are they
50:33influenced and to me that's if you're going to do something in a big organization you got to really invest in in that Right.
50:43Yeah. It you know and it depends you know the most important thing is to get started. So you know it can be it depends on the scale of the influence that you want to wield. You know sometimes yeah if you want to do large scale stuff you're going to have to bring out the big guns in terms of tools. But even some in some organizations just to get small scale stuff done requires just be willing to accept that the way the organization says that it works is not how it actually works. If you just master this one concept that will help you. so much
51:12um then you can then use these books very effectively to be like okay I need to map out how the company actually works and that's why I was so proud of the person who posted the golden sword experiment is they learned this critical information from which they can now plot and scheme and and and do stuff. Um, but I also think that
51:32the other thing people uh I think underappreciate is like because I've been I've been in the room where like an a manager will be talking to HR or talking to another manager and just be like, man, three different people said the same thing to me this week. We got to change. And none of those three people knew that anybody else said it.
51:49Each person was going out on a limb and saying it themselves. But like when you take that action, you create the conditions for other people to do it too. And you never know how um how impactful that can be. So I guess um don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good. And be willing to to act in accordance with your own values and trust that that ultimately is going to lead you where you want to go.
52:12You want to move on to the next one?
52:15I'll be curious to hear what you say about this about um work life [clears throat] balance.
52:21Um so a lot of people say yeah entrepreneurship takes a lot of sacrifice personal sacrifice personal life sacrifice work 996 um you know do you need that um you know what kind of sacrifices have you had to make to do what you're doing?
52:46Sure. Yeah. Um yeah yeah yeah yeah. Um I'm not a big believer in sacrifice because to me if you um trade a higher value if I try a lower value for a higher value you haven't really sacrificed anything. So the question is like what do you really value? And I think part of the one of the issues is that many people do a job that they don't like and don't actually think is very rewarding and then they feel it's really intention with what they're trying to do with their family. And that
53:15that tension creates a lot of stress.
53:17Like go do something mission driven. You won't feel that way. It's nice. But I don't mean to say that there are never any trade-offs. Trade-offs are real. Um I personally am not a fan of the hyperworkholism, you know, grind culture. Like I think that we all know that the code you write at 2 a.m. generally sucks anyway. You're on the 40th hour of a death march. Like if you can't if you can't even write syntax conformant code, like how good is your other thinking, you know? like I don't think that it's actually too too useful. Um and it's interesting like I
53:46have I spent a lot of time with my family and my kids. Um I have carved out always um time for that and viewed it as really important. And also most people think that I work extremely hard. So I don't know I don't in order to make that happen I have to prioritize the things that I really prioritize and I have to dep prioritize a lot of other stuff. So like I I couldn't have a regular job even if I wanted to. wouldn't be compatible with my values. Um I need to be able to have I need to be able to work with people
54:13who really believe as I believe. So I I just like yeah I think it would be um I've been privileged to be able to be selective about those kind of things.
54:22But also when you're working on something that your family can understand and be proud of that also matters a lot to them then then the time you're spending working on that is not lost time but time that they also feel like they are um they are a part of. So yeah, I think um I wouldn't I would just basically just ignore most of the popular discourse about this. Um try to find work that you find really personally meaningful. Um and then don't be a martyr. So like I think that you have people that like especially in the nonprofit sector you see this a lot where people feel like you know my work
54:52is so important I it's like you know it would be a betrayal of of people's value of my values to ever stop working and that's that's not true either. That's all a form of ego mania. So trying to find a certain level of balance. Look, I want to really be create the conditions where I can do my very best work and part of that requires me to be living a life that I think is in accordance with my values, you know, all up and down the stack.
55:15What do you think, John? I was like, you know, first engineer in a small startup. It it feels like in in some ways like trying to measure productivity by lines of code, right? It's like trying to measure like your contribution by hours worked. [laughter] If it's it's definitely like if you're doing good software, you'll probably be writing some lines of code and if you're not doing any, you won't, right? So there's some correlation there.
55:46Um but yeah, it's a correlationization thing.
55:50It's it's very different and like I mean from my perspective I I've never understood the the the like picture that you can just consistently work 40 hours a week your whole life or 60 hours a week or whatever the like threshold that people aim for is. Um I'm somebody who who sometimes can't do much at all and then sometimes can you know go on a long drive yes deep dive. Um, and so yeah, it it just feels like almost a non-quest, you know.
56:18I I guess maybe there's other types of work where you could say, look, if we just bring in people as fast as we can, nose the grindstone for exactly 60 hours a week, you know, if it wasn't like creative R&D, I guess maybe you could show a lot of results that way, but for what we're doing, it just absolutely doesn't, you know, even work as a concept. Um, and also it doesn't work with the long-term picture, right? Like there's been periods even in my tenure at answerai where it's like oh I I could get more done by next week, right? And
56:47the price for that would be burnout next year or [laughter] or or the work would be uncreative and and have more maintenance burden in the code, you know, like the the payoffs are very long long term. the like negative externalities of like oh I could get like some short-term positive just the same with like you could do more in a day I think by coding than intentionally coding but maybe you pay the price later. Um and so being able to dial that up and down being able to say look today
57:15is a a day where I need to take it easy so that I can be creative tomorrow. Um I took some time off before this course so that I could be like excited about all the new things we were teaching. Um, I don't know. It just seems like the obvious, like when you look at area under the curve and creative output and all of that, the obvious answer is not 996. It's whatever like threshold you're excited about. And sometimes that's more than 9 hours a day. Um, but also a lot of the time that's, you know, 0 to four.
57:40Does that make sense?
57:42Yeah. I um I feel like my Hey guys, I'm back. Hey, I feel like my attitude to to this might have changed a bit. Sorry, Eric. Can I say something?
57:56No, go ahead. Go ahead.
57:58Yeah. Like in my 20s, I remember telling people, "Wait, you're going to try doing a startup and you have a family?
58:09That's just an awful thing to do um to your family." And I guess that reflected that at that time. Um um you have to go Eric.
58:24Unfortunately, in a few minutes I will have to drop off.
58:26Okay, no problem. We can we can wrap up.
58:29Um yeah, at that time I I guess I ran my startups in a way that was pretty or all involving and but yeah maybe so you can do it that way but maybe you don't have to. So I think you have to be careful. Yeah. Oh yeah, I was going to say sorry and sorry for the interruption. Yeah, speaking of work work life balance, I'm dealing with a family issue myself even uh as we speak.
58:56So so I apologize. Um, I was going to say, yeah, obviously like the way I think about it now with three kids is very different than I thought about it when I was 22. Um, and there were advantages to how I used to do things, but there are some disadvantages, too.
59:08So, I think, you know, it's one of these things where you have to find your own way that's authentic to what you actually believe. And I just think a lot of people, they do work um, in a way that is like the way they learn to do it in school to get an A+ from somebody.
59:22And a lot of the hustle culture stuff is like I just I need need to like some like people work really hard and they have extra time to post about how hard they work like what's going on but they want someone to give them a gold star and say like you're doing a good job. Um and so like they're allowing other people to be the judge of whether they're they're on track or not. The real advantage of having a valuesdriven like principled approach is you could say like my goal is to achieve this thing that if I achieve the thing then I did a good job and it doesn't matter what how many hours or how many lines of
59:51code as Jon pointed out it's just ridiculous. Um yeah okay well look uh why don't we um wrap it up. It's been over an hour um and uh yeah been super interesting. Uh there's plenty more questions we haven't got get to, but maybe we can talk about them.
1:00:11Yeah, we love to figure out ways to get I I feel like the more time we allocate, the more questions we get and then every time we're like now I have way more too many questions. So yeah, let me think about a best way to Well, then we'll have every question answered. So yeah. Yeah, exactly. So I'm sure if we do it on the Discord, we'll we'll do it.
1:00:24But anyway, I appreciate the chance to do it. Want to say a special thanks to everybody who um who did the test reading and uh if people want to continue to do that and post um comments, I'll be I'll be reading everyone. So, thank you very much and thank thanks Jonno and Jeremy for setting up this extra time.
1:00:36Thank you. Bye. Bye.
1:00:37All right. Take care, guys.