0:00She's now the CEO of RaiseUs, a nonpartisan nonprofit that works with governors, employers, and trading providers to help American workers successfully make this transition. And Mark Andre is one of her supporters in her new effort. Uh Mark is a co-founder and general partner of what I would describe as perhaps the most influential venture firm in the world. Uh he was a student at the University of Illinois.
0:28He co-creator of Mosaic, went on to co-found Netscape, created a company before cloud before the cloud was anything at all. Created a company in around the cloud. I think he might say he got there a little too soon. He serves on the board of Meta, is an old friend and more important than all of those designations, he is one of the co-leads of the Federal Reserve's jobs and productivity task force, which in my mind goes to the top of his
0:56resume. So, Gina, Mark, uh, welcome.
0:58It's an honor to have you with us. Um, before I go into some detailed questions I have for either for both of you. Let me start with you. Uh, Gina, where do we go from here? You know, what a transformative moment this is. I think you've taken this this moment seriously with concerns about what it means for the US labor force. Where do you think we go from here?
1:19Yeah. Well, first of all, thank you for having me and think you're doing a terrific job. Um you guys can hear me. So uh we had an election recently. I'm sure many of you saw that. And in the election apart from the democratic landslide uh you saw many of the data center flavors of data center moratorum the vast majority passed and I actually think that's a very troubling sign. So where I think we need
1:54to go from here. So why did they pass? I think they pass because people are afraid. It's when the average American hears AI, they hear, "I'll lose my job. My kids will lose their job. My children's mental health, national security, some version of that." And so when people are afraid, they say stop. Except that would be I think very bad for America and for them actually.
2:21So where we I think have to go from here is to figure out how how do we address people's legitimate concerns and go f you know further and innovate. I gave a speech the other day see like Americans come our companies are some of the very best in the world the most innovative the most dynamic. We lead the world in AI that's where we want to be.
2:50Where do we go from here? That's where we want to be. But in order to do that, we have to figure out how to bring folks along with us because I think a very bad outcome would be a set of stifling regulations um that stifles growth. And so I somehow we have to get ourselves to a place of growing the growth and but you know dividing it fairly and making sure Americans can see themselves in this AI
3:18future. So Mark, let me turn it to you.
3:21I've heard you say um that you think in and around this new technology wave, both the utopians and dystopians are going to be gravely disappointed. So where do we go from here?
3:33Yeah. So let me start with it's it's great to be here. It's a and it's a privilege to serve on on the task force.
3:38And I I do want to briefly brag on my my my colleagueuh Chad who said uh uh he said uh he he currently works for a company that's in the process going public and so he's in he's in the quiet period and he said whatever you do not calling me from the stage. So [laughter] I just wanted to highlight that he's sitting right over there. Um, and then our third uh our third uh our third member Asha who's a you know fantastic operating executive uh at Microsoft who couldn't be here today for personal reasons but uh it's great and then I also just wanted to to to note and I guess I should be happy about this that
4:07um none of the panels today including ours so far have had an AI bot as a panelist.
4:12Um is uh was that was that was that considered and dismissed or uh do do we do we have another year's worth of panel appearances in front of us uh before we we too are cruy taking as a rhetorical question I get to ask the questions here Mark okay sorry okay sorry okay sorry sorry um yeah so look I mean obvious this has been you know these have been fantastic discussions and I think a lot of the a lot of the you know twists and turns I think of of the different of of the debate around you know economic change and so forth and social change that flow from from AI have you know have been
4:41discussed by the very smart people who preceded us. Um, yeah. So, yeah, my my my line has been both utopians and and the doomers are going to are going to be disappointed specifically disappointed by the the scope and magnitude of the real world impact and specifically the economic impact. And I think the reason for that um the reason for that is is is basically as follows which is the world is a very complicated and messy place.
5:02Um, and just because there's a new technology and just because it looks like there's obvious ways to deploy it and things that should happen does not mean that any of that actually happens. Um and in fact there are historical precedents for new technologies that have simply been frozen in their tracks.
5:14And you know the the the you know the big one in our lifetimes has been civilian nuclear power you know which at one point was was you know was the panacea for for for US energy you know global energy growth and by the way was a you know zero emission carbon-f free technology that in retrospect would have been you know tremendously beneficial uh you know even even from the environmental standpoint and you know it you know it was basically killed and and by the way it's you know it's the remnants of it are being killed both in the US and Europe right now. So um you know so the these things don't don't don't have to get deployed. Some sometimes they're simply stopped and
5:43then if they do get deployed they can take a very long time and then and and the reason is because they they involve really radically changing how how how things operate, how organizations operate. Uh a reference was made earlier to the now famous Dynamo uh paper in the economics literature which I think is is is 100% correct. Um, and so I just I just think like the the world is really complicated and messy. And so you're you're you're you know, you've already seen this morning, you're going to have a set of companies are going to race ahead on this and, you know, I think get significant um uh competitive advantage versus their competitors. And I think you frankly you'll have a lot of
6:13existing incumbent, you know, both companies, institutions that, you know, we'll we'll it'll just take a long time.
6:19And then look, you you've got other parts of the world, you know, Patrick Patrick, you know, Patrick this morning from his uh vantage point as as having been born in Europe, you know, observed it, but you have other parts of the world that are absolutely determined to not have any of this happen and if anything to shut it down and kill it. So I I think it's actually going to be quite a messy period.
6:35So time seems to be the big dimension in some sense. Uh Gina, central bankers were in the business of buying and selling time. That's what we do with interest rates.
6:45My sense, but I want you to to disabuse me of this. Part of the reason of your concern is looks like time's accelerating. Looks like we might be having a long period, a period that would normally be creative destruction that would take a decade or two might be happening faster. Is it that time element that's made you say we need to find a way to get through this so that we both win with the new technologies and we haven't lost lost lost the society along the way? Part of it is
7:12time, but part of it is honestly less about the technology and more about America's workforce system.
7:23So much of what we're trying to do, you know, the chair said we're working with governors. I mean, m we have [snorts] we have a workforce system that needs to be fixed, period. So if we can use the occasion of AI and everybody's focus on it to do the big changes that need to be made, that's what I'd like to do. So what am I talking about? You know, by the way, I agree with Mark about a year a year and a half ago or a year ago when
7:51I started to talk about Raise Us, I spoke with one of the founders of one of the big labs and who at that time was saying there's not going to be any jobs for humans in the next couple years. And I said, I don't agree with that. And I said, don't forget, just because you can do something in a lab doesn't mean it will be automatically proliferated through the economy like that. Like there is a friction to diffusion and it takes time. Um but and in any event,
8:19yes, it's the time, but it's also look, we spent hundreds of billions of dollars last year subsidizing higher education. 35 plus percent of people who go to co four-year college in this country don't graduate.
8:34like that is not a system that's working by and large. Those are people who wind up with no degree and a lot of debt. Uh if you want to do something that's not four-year college, there aren't that many fantastic options relatively [snorts] the way I was a governor. The way governors um invest in workforce or community college or higher ed, it's just attendance. We incentivize attendance. you show up, they get paid
9:04with their PEL grant. You show up, they get paid with, etc., not, you know, outcomes. Unemployment insurance created a hundred years ago in the Great Depression and literally hasn't been reformed since. So, there's so many examples. So, what I'm worried about is this change is coming. I personally view the transition to AI just as that a transition and I think there will be
9:32jobs that go away. You know there's I think you would know better than me 10 12 13 million like administrative jobs benefits verification people back office folks those jobs aren't are either going to go away or be different that is innovation. So I think there's a transition. We are here now. We will hopefully get to this an agentic economy and there'll be new jobs and new businesses and hopefully a lot of new
10:01startups. What I want to avoid is a spike in unemployment from here because some jobs go away before the new ones are created. And what I'm saying is the workforce system, support system, safety net for unemployed workers, incentives for companies to redeploy, it it just doesn't exist. So I'd like to get it ready. by the way, so that we can flourish at AI.
10:29Because if we don't do it and we have double-digit unemployment, that's when you that's when policy makers do things that aren't necessarily long-term the right move.
10:41Mark, you let me build on Gina's comment. You've you've said, I think publicly, that the labor displacement story is not true. that the employment shifts won't come anywhere near the people that some of the doomers would have us believe. Is that because we society won't let it? Is that because the uh politics are changing around it? Is it because companies can't adopt quickly
11:09enough? Help us understand why you're seemingly less concerned about labor market disruption in the in the near term.
11:16Yeah. And by the way, look, I agree with Gina's objectives completely and I'm, you know, very proud to be, you know, to to to help with her efforts. So, I I don't mean in any way to to disagree with what she said. Um, I would just say, look, it takes 900 hours of professional training to become certified as a hairdresser in the state of California.
11:33[snorts] It's illegal to be a hairdresser in the state of California if you're not professionally certified as a hairdresser through the 900 hours of training. Um the machine cannot become a doctor, cannot get admitted, cannot get an MD, cannot prescribe medication. The machine cannot get admitted to the bar.
11:49The machine cannot get hired by the government. The machine cannot get civil service protections, cannot belong to a union, private sector union, public sector union. Um like our like to the extent our economy is a free market economy, then maybe you could see you know the the sort of let's say extremely rapid displacement scenarios people are talking about. But like we've mostly outlawed the kind of job transition that I think the again sort of [snorts] both the utopians and the doomers uh um talk about uh just like large large swasts of our economy are are basically controlled. I mean they're either
12:17flatout monopoly K through K through 12 education AI cannot become a public school teacher but I mean ask Randy weard right like you know there's no chance. Uh and so so we we've effectively like outlawed that that that kind of economic dynamism across much of our economy. And then and then mechanically and I'll I'll just give you a preview of the the the work that we're doing on the on our on our task force.
12:38So my contribution to the task force is going to be to make in the report we're going to do is going to make make the following case which is if you disagregate sectors of the economy um you classify them roughly into two categories which what you might call the the the sort of very fast sectors of the economy which are economies that c can have and do have rapid technological change rapid rapid economic change rapid job turnover. Um you know those are sectors consumer electronics um you know media and entertainment um uh you know are examples of that you know many many
13:06sort of uh you know commodity goods um you know those sectors can those sectors have that but what those sectors all have in common is they have rapidly falling prices um and and and then you have these other sectors of the economy that I I would call this the slow sectors which is health healthare [snorts] um education um housing and then sort of the combination of law and government you know sort of legal and governmental administration those sectors of the economy like are not legally allowed to have rapid change like literally not. And and in fact those sectors of the economy are
13:35typically characterized by extensive subsidization uh restriction of supply. Um so cartels right where you literally can't light up new supply. You can't build new housing. You can't start new universities. You can't create new hospitals. You can't you know whatever.
13:47You can't you know you can't create lots of new doctors. um they have extensive subsidization of demand which is the government that you know the voters get outraged that these things cost so much and so the government steps in and does federal student loan programs and K- through2 education funding and housing subsidy you know cal I guess we're up for another big new housing subsidy in California you know in in in the face of continued restricted supply so of course prices can only go up um and and then extensive government involvement if not outright government monopoly control of those sectors um and then what's happen
14:15and then in those sectors prices are rapidly rising right and of course and of Of course, every American experiences this because, you know, this is kind of, I think, the core fundamental maybe political dynamic, you know, right now is just basically every American is basically being told it's like good news, your iPhone's getting cheaper, you know, um the flat screen TV on your wall is getting cheaper. The bad news is, you know, college education is going to cost a million bucks. You know, healthcare is becoming unaffordable and, you know, good luck buying a house. Like, it's not you know, it's no longer possible. Um, and then if you think mechanically, what happens is as the fast sectors, as their
14:44prices crash, they they they basically exit out of GDP, right? They're, you know, they're don't, by the way, this has happened before. Agriculture used to be 97% of the American economy is now 3%. Food prices crashed dramatically.
14:54Food is not, you know, up until recently, food was not a significant part of the average American's budget relative to healthcare, education, and housing. Um, but but the the slow sectors are growing. Healthcare is already a fifth of US GDP, and I don't see why it doesn't go to a fourth, a third, and then half, and then ultimately 80%. and and healthcare like you you you literally legally cannot have technological transformation in most of healthare and so I I think we have a a political economy problem and a
15:21I don't like a you governance legal governmental political problem that is going to prevent the kind of radical transformation that people see coming and I again I would word it as a concern it would you know you might interpret this as good news because it means the AI revolution is not going to you know destroy all the jobs or kill everybody you could also view this as very negative which is productivity growth just simply may not grow very much.
15:42Economic growth just simply may not grow very much. We may just continue to stagnate.
15:46So Gina, let me come back to you. So Mark is showing is describing a divergence between two parts of the economy. Call it regulated versus less regulated or unregulated. In economics, as you know, we think about inflation products versus services. We look at the trends of product prices which had gone in one direction in the last couple of generations versus services. Um let me ask you about another divergence which you referenced the United States versus
16:14the rest of the world. Um how well do you think we are positioned? What do you think the future holds? Where do we go from here with respect to US economic growth and potential growth versus the trading partners that you know well from your commerce days?
16:31Yeah. Is this better? Can you hear me?
16:34Um so so much in there. Let me say this. I think that AI provides a fantastic experience for America, opportunity for America to draw the world towards us. So if you believe as I do that we are in a strategic competition with China, China is not our friend. Whatever words you want to use, they are not our friend.
17:03Then they are too big. my view they are too big, too determined, too rich for us to compete and win on our own. We must have allies.
17:16And so then you this is what I think Korea, Japan, much of Southeast Asia, India, Europe. Okay. What do we have that these countries want? many things, but one thing is compute. Another thing is our models. So, we could say to the rest of the world, uh, no, you can't have this stuff or you can have a little bit of it. Or we could
17:46say we could show global leadership and set and set the rules of the road for what we think of as, you know, national security, safety, cyber standards, etc., and draw these countries towards us, providing them with the compute and the technology and the AI, by the way, which will make us a better country, a stronger country, our companies stronger, hopefully more
18:15productive. We can talk about what Mark said and also help those countries and draw those countries closer to us. And this is something that I try to advance in the Biden administration with candidly very, you know, mixed success because there's a different view which is you know we got to keep a lid on this at all cost and which I think is a mistake and the reason I think it's a mistake the the the uh analogy that was often used
18:44is well you know AI is like nuclear weapons but that isn't really true I understand the dangers I do I really do and I worry a lot about cyber and I worry a lot about bioteterrorism and I worry a lot about non-state actors are, you know, doing bad things and criminals. So, I'm not diminishing that one bit. Quite the opposite. I'm saying if we have the similar standards, we can all work together. Um, but AI is the
19:12economy, right? It isn't. It is how health care will be done, how banking will be done, how shopping will be done, how retail will be done. So, if you tell another country, sorry, you can't ever chip, you can't ever compute, what do you think they're going to do? They will go to China. They won't say, "Oh, okay, no problem. We'll have an oldfashioned banking system and not have it be AI enabled." So that's why I think we just have to be much more sophisticated in
19:38terms of using this as an opportunity to make friends not enemies in terms of like will it make us as productive as possible. I mean, I think that's a this is a complicated thing.
19:53I'll just I'll tell you one really quick anecdote. When I was secretary, I was in charge of administering the chips act semiconductor and we, you know, I killed ourselves. We got this thing passed. Historic legislation, bipartisan. The money came to my department. I negotiated this very difficult to negotiate deals with TSMC and Samsung. And then I was told it was
20:21going to take seven years because of permitting [snorts] to get a shovel in the ground for the first factory.
20:30The these guys are laughing. It's not It's a true fact because you have layers and layers and layers and layers. You talk about housing, same thing. We cannot build if we strangle ourselves with red tape. You want the prices of housing and manufacturing to go down, then you have to shrink the time. Time is money. Anyway, so I worked with bipartisan group of people in Congress.
20:53We changed it and now we're making chips in America in Arizona and Texas. But my point is these regulations are there for good purpose. But somewhere along the way we got over torked because if it takes seven years to put a shovel in the ground, that's a problem and that's expensive and that's bad for America and stands in the way of productivity.
21:18Mark, so um some years ago I think you wrote something called it's time to build. The moderator here has become completely irrelevant. So, is it time to build and how are we doing?
21:31It is. It is. So, so the I wrote this it came at the peak of CO u. It came at the peak of CO when I hit sort of maximum frustration and everybody hit their own point of maximum frustration during CO. Mine was when the city of New York put out a call for people to drop off their used rain ponchos uh at the local hospitals to use as protective equipment for the first responders uh dealing with CO patients because the they they were out of surgical gowns. Um and so yeah, I mean it just, you know, we we this has been, you know, we've tal we've all talked
22:01about this at length. Um again, I would go back to this, which is the this is a political economy and you know, ultimately, you know, an ultimately political kind of question is, you know, what what do we want? U what do we want as a country? You know, what what what kind of pace of change do we want? How much productivity growth do we actually want? Um I mean, I you know, I just, you know, I guess I've stated my my priorities before, which is I think I think ignorance ignorance is bad and intelligence is good. Um I think low productivity growth is bad, high productivity growth is good. I think low economic growth is bad. High high
22:28economic growth is good. Um you know AI gives us a I mean AI gives us a magic formula. I mean I mean I did not think I would live to see what's happening in AI. Like I didn't think it would ever work. I mean the these are ideas in AI the things that are working in AI are ideas that were first formulated in the 1940s. Um, I got a computer science degree in the 1980s and these ideas were completely discredited and the people who worked on them were like in the back of the building and this is like the stuff that like everybody knew was just like never going to work. And in the last decade it's all started to work and it's just like this this absolutely
22:57amazing miracle. And so it's like we've been handed this elixir to boost productivity growth, to boost economic growth, uh, that can be applied a thousand different ways. And for sure it won't be 100% positive. For sure that you know there will be negatives and for sure that there will be issues. But we we've been handed this and we we do we we have we have very very important decisions to make about what we actually want out of this. Um and I think those decisions and the policy implications of those decisions are going to matter actually way more than what the technology is capable of because without those decisions being being made in the right way the technology will simply not
23:28So Gina let me come back to you. Chad can't defend himself but he's written some incredible academic work and what he said about prior my own take of his work not his words in a quiet period is that what he said is these productivity revolutions are amazing but there's always a weak link so the question Gina for you is is the weak link electricity data centers chips or is the weak link us
23:54D all the above Um, so look, here's what I think. I I'm I think us in the following respect. In America right now, we have a situation of political instability, divisiveness, extremes on both sides, and a level a a deep economic insecurity.
24:26that most Americans feel, many Americans feel. We have 10 plus million people working full-time, working full-time and poor enough to be on food stamps and Medicaid. And then on the other side, you know, extreme wealth. And so, and now AI, now you're putting AI on top of that.
24:50And it has the potential to be unbelievable, as Mark's been saying, like all the things we know, but also if if unleashed without safeguards, etc., to just put a match in this powder keg of inequality.
25:09And so like my view, it's the way I've governed, it's the way I've fixed pension systems, we were talking about earlier, is always like growth is the answer. But we do have to find our way towards a form of regulation and governance which is growing and distributing more equally or fairly.
25:30And so if we can do that, I'm just what I said earlier, there's an opportunity for America to really emerge as a global leader with this technology and to have it make things better in our country, making us all more productive.
25:49But if we fail at that, it's because of us, right? That that's why the politics of it is like if we could, and I criticize my own party as much as anything. It's like you know the permanent example when I went to Congress and did that in a bipartisan way when I opened school I was a Democratic governor I was the only Democratic governors that open schools public schools in the fall of 2020 pissed off a lot of people in my own party but it worked. So it's like on
26:16both sides if we could come together and have serious policym this could be amazing. If we don't it's by far the weakest link humans. So Mark, let me come back to you with a thread that Gene had brought up before, which was China. The distinction between where the United States is, where our G2 rival is China.
26:38Uh there's a couple of meetings that are involving the two presidents over the course of the next week or so. What's your mental model about this new technology and the rivalry between these two great powers?
26:51Yeah, so start with I mean there's no question that like it's a straight up it's a straight up geopolitical rivalry.
26:55I mean this is the this is the 21st century cold war. You know, both countries have, you know, very expansive visions of the way that the world should be configured um and the way that things should work and um uh you know, and both are are aggressively trying to, you know, kind of proilitize those and and expand those um uh you know, it's very big deal that, you know, the technologies of the time are going to be, you know, critically important in this for the same reasons they were during the during the first cold war with the Soviet Union. And so, you know, it's it's, you know, obviously, you know, completely serious, very big deal.
27:24Um, the way I would describe the dynamic, the the puts and takes. Uh, and you know, I'd say like many American investors over the course of the last 40 years were actually encouraged to go invest in China. My my firm is actually late late enough to the to to the to arrival that we never did. So, I say we're kind of on the other side of this.
27:42And so, you know, my my day job is investing in American companies that in many cases are going to have to compete with Chinese companies. Um, so you know my my kind of take is that the in America we have all of the pros and cons of a decentralized you know liberal democracy free market system notwithstanding all my complaints about bureaucracy you know we to the extent that we you know still have a both democratic and and free market system in this country like we we you know we have a highly dynamic and and uh and well we have a highly dynamic private sector I'll brag on the private sector for a moment the private sector in the US has
28:11rec and the financial system recalibrated 7 trillion dollars or something of uh money in the last what two years to AI like absolutely staggering like you know way way beyond you know any sort of you know the Apollo program or you know any anything like that in in history and and primarily through through public sector or private sector action you know supported by a financial system uh you know that you know that generally speaking is the best in the world. Um and so we have all of the advantages of a decentralized dynamic environment. We have all the disadvantages of a
28:41decentralized dynamic environment which is like you know man you read the newspaper it seems like everything's a total mess. you know, the government always seems like it's in some form of meltdown. Like, you know, why my god, why can't these people get together and get along, you know, like where's our plan? Like, where's the national plan, right? Um, China has all of I think the uh advantages of a centralized, you know, command and control uh system. Um, and that they absolutely 100% do have a plan and it is dictated top down and it's like written down on paper and it's very clear and the orders fan out, they're executed. Um and then they have all the all the disadvantages of a
29:11centralized command and control system which is you know they routinely go through you know periods of time where they just like start arresting all their entrepreneurs and throwing them in jail and they you know do all kinds of crazy stuff you know as a as as as as dictatorships uh you know tend to do. Um on balance through technological revolution after technological revolution the decentralized dynamic system has has outperformed and I and by the way I think is outperforming today.
29:33you know, the the US is the global leader in AI, but they have a plan [laughter] and and and they're definitely executing on the plan. Um, and to the extent that we put fault uh or that the disadvantages that we have from having a decentralized dynamic system, you know, become too intense, um, you know, they are 100%, you know, racing to catch up. And I would characterize it as, you know, they're maybe a year behind. You know, it's and it's it's and and it's basically it's a foot race. Um, and I, you know, I would hope in three years we're still at least a year ahead. And I would hope that
30:03maybe even we're three or five years ahead, but we're, you know, we're going to have to make that happen.
30:07So, let me try to distill if I could the last 45 minutes, maybe this morning's discussion simply and I'll turn to Gan and Mark for a final comment, they should feel free to to disabuse uh their moderator with this point. Um I think if there's a general view at least of the panelists today and I certainly talked about it in my speech this morning um this is a hugely consequential moment and it's easy to think that this moment
30:36everyone would think that their moment is the moment that will determine the fate of our economy but this time it does seem different. We are at a hinge point for the US economy, the United States role in the world. And as I said this morning, I don't think any of us are impartial to how we want that to come out. Secondly, I would say this for all the considerable problems that we have in and around transitions of this new technology, the n the nature and structure of the economy that Mark
31:06talked about, the challenges that we central bankers have in navigating this moment. as investment hits both supply and demand. It hits demand first. But I'd rather have our problems than anyone else's in the world. So with that cautiously optimistic statement, Gina, let me turn to you and Mark and give a final comment.
31:25I certainly agree with that. When I I would I would rather be an American and an American business person than running a business, starting a business anywhere else in the world. I really would. That being said, uh you know, democracy, what we're doing, it's uh has we have to be continuously self-improving.
31:48We and we have to be honest about what isn't working and just get to the business of fixing it. And so that's what I think. Yes, I'm optimistic. I keep doing this because I'm optimistic. I see the promise. I see the potential.
32:02But I just wish we could just kind of be practical. And there's nothing we can't fix if we don't get together and, you know, be serious and try to solve these problems. And, you know, that's why you're here. That's what you're doing. And we just have to stay at it.
32:17Mark, a final comment. Is this human agency thing, does it matter?
32:21Yes. Look, I'm extreme I'm extremely optimistic. I'm extremely positive. I I think this is going going to be absolutely fantastic. Um, uh, Kevin knows I have an 11-year-old at home and he's he's all AI all the time, and it is one of the most amazing things I've ever seen in my life. um he's able to advance in all kinds of fields at a pace I I I would not have thought was was possible.
32:38Um and so I I think there there's just like incredible opportunity here, incredible payoff. Um maybe I can just close by saying I you know maybe confession or something which is like I I I think a big part of this is the responsibility of the technology industry um and and the AI industry to really like step up and provide leadership here. And I think that so far we we collectively in the tech industry have not done a great job on that. Um and and you know in some cases I think you know at least some some some some of some some some some folks on our side have been you know maybe even you know net destructive in this process by you
33:07know maybe spreading you know very high levels of fear and so forth. Um and so I I I guess maybe I close with like I I think our industry needs to aspire to to to to uh you know to to step up and be to be more part of these of these solutions. Part of that isn't in in in the sense of like how we actually explain and articulate what we're doing.
33:23Um part of that is the policies that we advocate for. Um and then a big part of that is the the actual design. Somebody mentioned earlier the products can be designed in different ways. And I think the product should be designed for human potential and human enablement. Um and uh and and and to put the technology in everybody's hands so that everybody has an opportunity to benefit. So I guess I maybe close by saying I I would hope and aspire and I would encourage um uh my my industry to uh to to to try to contribute more to this.
33:48Well, this concludes the public portion of the field hearing of the productivity and jobs task force. On behalf of Mary Daly, the team at the San Francisco Fed, all of us at the board, we're grateful for your participation. And we'll just end with applause for Mark and Gina for leading us out. [applause]