0:00Today on How to Build the Future, I'm sitting down with Eric Glimman, co-founder and CEO of RAMP. RAMP started seven years ago as a corporate card with one promise. Save companies time and money. Today, it's a $60 billion platform that runs the financial operations of tens of [music] thousands of businesses. And increasingly, it does all of that work using agents.
0:22We're sort of at a pace [music] that I think most people would look at and go, "This is kind of remarkable." This is the story of [music] how Ramp is reshaping the way companies are built from the ground up. [music] Thanks for being here, Eric.
0:44Honestly, Gary, it's great to be back.
0:45Thanks for having me.
0:46Welcome back. Uh you and your co-founder, Kareem, uh you built Parabus and we got to work together YC Summer 15. actually you sold it to Capital One and then you went on to start ramp. Walk us through that journey. What was that like you know deciding to apply to YC uh coming in doing it and then how'd you get you know to to your next thing?
1:06A decade ago we had a pretty simple idea which is what if every time that you bought something online and it dropped in price you could get that money back automatically. Uh and so we built Parabus which was back then a savings app but I really think was one of the prehistoric AI agents that did that for you. So, it would link up with your Gmail or Yahoo account. It would scan your inbox for receipts, structure the data, go check the price, and if you were eligible for a refund, it just emailed um from your account asking for a refund of the difference. And worked
1:34really well. We launched. Um a month later, we were here at YC. We actually applied twice. And so, for anyone thinking about it, if you don't get in on the first time, uh try again. Uh and we're very happy we we came because it set us off on a completely different trajectory. um within a year of graduating from YC, we had uh almost a million users uh every day and we had a budgeting offer from Capital One to buy the company. And so, you know, we ended up spending the next uh two and a half years uh just over that at Capital One
2:03and we got to see how in in many ways a world-class organization operated, how it used information to revolutionize its industry of credit cards and learned a lot of incredible things. Also learned some anti- lessons. Um, you know, seeing an organization that had so many good processes that often killed great ideas, uh, saw how incentives sometimes that are not always aligned with customers led to outcomes that could be much better. and and ultimately the years of
2:33being there led us to question what if your financial products were not designed uh just to go and make the company more money but were actually designed to help individuals spend less. You could compete on value not on the basis of price and you could build a very different kind of company.
2:49That's fascinating. What was like the zero to one like on the first startup idea? Like how did you come up with it?
2:55you know, did you need to pivot or was it sort of like this is what we wanted, this is what we wanted for ourselves and then people wanted it.
3:02When I graduated, it seemed like the only two jobs were banker or consultant and so I worked at a bank uh and Kareem was a consultant cuz it helped with his visa and uh we liked our jobs, didn't love it, and we were always kind of dreaming and we would read um uh some of the essays that Paul would put out and uh watch some of the early startup school videos. And what stuck with us was, you know, don't just try to come up with ideas in the abstract, but I I remember the essay of like how to get ideas, how to get startup ideas. And uh the conclusion that I took from it was
3:32you should just notice problems in your regular life. And after a year of working in an office and not leaving until it was dark outside, uh finally a group of friends got exhausted enough that we booked a flight. We thought we were smart. We use incognito mode. So we we we'd get a non-personalized price.
3:48And the next day, another friend wanted to join. And I looked at the flight to send her the uh details and I was like, "This is weird. The flight is $100 less.
3:57Um, is this right?" And turned out it was. And I got really frustrated. In my job, I would read credit documents and indentures. And so I just read the policy. It turned out the airline would give you a refund if you let them know within 24 hours. And so I called, it was done within an hour. You know, my friends and I had almost $1,000 back.
4:17And I just sat there. I'm like, "This could be happening all the time.
4:19this could be happening all the time and like you know we had taken I had taken enough computer science to know like oh if you give a computer a website to go check you can go scrape and and check the price and policies are relatively structurable like what can we do about it and so it led to a year of kind of tinkering and trying to figure out what's the right form factor could you pull the data from credit cards not enough information there doesn't have the itemize your receipt could use email there was these productivity apps to help you organize your inbox or write
4:48faster but no one had ever used email as a way to collect information information and then send you know to go and build refund requests. And so we just started buying some things. Uh turns out they were dropping in price a lot more often than we thought. Uh we tried building these triggers. Initially was built in VBA as a script. That was what we knew.
5:06And we started getting refunds. We asked our friends, "Hey, I know we're your friends. It's a little weird, but can we get your email login [laughter] and try to save you some money?" And just we kept pulling. And so that was how we got there. And I I think when we had met, it was such that for one in 20 people uh within uh minutes of you signing up for Parabus, you would save money.
5:30And we're like either we believe in this or we don't. Let's try this.
5:33What was it like to get first users? And you know, what did you have to do to get your first thousand or 10,000 users?
5:39We did everything. We carried signs around New York. We talked to friends.
5:42We we didn't have too many friends, so we ran out of them very quickly. Uh, hilariously, where we got a lot of our first users for Preparabis was uh on Reddit. There was a subreddit called Beer Money. Um, where it was people who wanted $5, uh, to to buy a beer on the weekend. And so, um, uh, Kareem just ripped it and just wrote a post of, "Hey, we have this app that save saves you money. You can connect your email."
6:06And, uh, we woke up and we had a few hundred users and was kind of off to the races. But, you know, it was everything was hard fought. I I think the advice around just try to constrain all the complexity to one metric for us it was users. We wanted to grow that 10 plus% per week and we made various trade-offs.
6:24Um we learned a lot about how to simplify the story just of stores owe you money, we're going to get it for you. The big problem that we had with that business was uh it seemed too good to be true. Uh and so what would help you overcome something that seemed like wait a minute you're doing you're saving me money you only charge if you save me money but you want access like what's the what's the catch when we talked to customers you know we tried to listen into them explaining it to friends like we used to do the Craigslist uh test
6:53where we'd pretend to be market research people uh doing research for our own company and be like yeah we don't know what this app does or whatever and you'd ask people like what do they think of it they'd go through they'd explain what they like we'd see them leader and we explained actually we're the founders and you know did you ever tell other people about it just to pitch it and they would go and say you know there's this app called Parabus it's really great it saves people money whenever you buy things and it goes on sale you should know though it it keeps 25% of what it uh of what it saves you so that thing people naturally when they're
7:23telling their friends about things they want to show you the positives and the negatives you want to look out for that it's real it's real that it's real and we listen to enough of these conversations we're like huh could we give people something that would make it easier um to overcome the negative. And we realized actually we should put in like a two-sided referral deal um that would motivate people to tell more friends if every time you refer someone parabus keep less um uh and so instead of charging 25% my rate will be 20% your rate will be 20% and we saw referrals
7:52explode. We figured out ways to get the news to talk about it and as we got that going on very quickly the growth rate just continued to grow exponentially.
8:00That's amazing. I mean, it's cool because when you set out to do Ramp Yeah.
8:05Uh it sounds like that was sort of the same vibe when you came out. You said, you know, save time and money. How do you do that again?
8:12Maybe we've only ever had one idea.
8:14Yeah. I mean, sometimes uh if it's a good one, that's all you need.
8:17I think it's just like a deeply human desire to get more for for less, you know, and maybe rich or poor, everyone likes a good deal.
8:24Yeah. Yeah. We had had that insight of if you had a very simple value proposition, you can communicate it very clearly. People want to use those types of products. And when we were at Capital One, we learned about financial institutions, how they work.
8:41These were incredible business models that were incredibly profitable. It wasn't that any individual person was bad, but just organizationally the the incentives were such that people were designing products that made their customers just a little bit worse off um to make the company better off and we thought it could be so powerful if we actually wanted the same thing.
9:02Did you start there? What were some examples that you know seemed particularly surprising?
9:08When you have a hammer, every problem looks like a nail. So one, there's very few new competitors in, you know, uh, uh, in making new bank accounts or perhaps in making new credit cards.
9:18I mean, these are all regulatory, uh, sort of captured things at some level.
9:24We think so. I mean, most of our competitors then, their founders wore top hats, not because they're eccentric, they just were born in the 1800s. Like it's just like not a lot of new competition, right? And the the tools that most people had conventionally were you could have cards with cash back or with points. And to kind of break down the the logic tree, the the job of companies people know is make more profit each quarter, grow quickly, and eventually the you know long-term the profit dollars become really great. So every quarter um your team is on this
9:52rat race in in the car business to grow purchase volume to get people to spend more money and drive more purchases which drives more topline revenue. And then you want to keep uh a higher net margin. One of the largest costs um for credit card companies was the costs of those points and reward schemes. Uh and so the incentive institutionally became well if you could convince people uh that the points were worth a lot, they were going to go spend more and get them to not use them.
10:20That's right. [laughter] Or devalue them or do these kind of things. And they were in different departments. So everyone was optimizing different things but somehow uh wasn't align. And we were product people uh inside of this group and inside of the card division and and we used to do all kinds of user research and you could boil some of these exercises down to asking customers what would get you to use our products more.
10:41Do you want a point or cashback program and if you ask people and you really listen to what they said not just was it A or B, but what they were telling back to you. They would say something along the lines of I actually just want more in my bank account. which if you pull on that, then you're like, "Huh, well, maybe if you don't spend $100 on that subscription that you're paying for that you've forgotten about and you cancel that at the end of a month, you might have $99 more in your bank account than
11:11if you just got one% back. Why isn't there a card or software that does that?" And if you could do that well, you could have a not a 10x but an almost 100x better value proposition for uh for customers. Um the other large problem in that business was people were terrified that it was a race to the bottom that if you're just slicing up a small margin uh well it's you know this gets boiled away.
11:40[snorts] uh and if you could actually compete on the basis when I say value of actually more dollars in your account but you do this through technology you do this actually not by saying I'm just going to give a larger rebate you could have more dollars to invest in new things and so in some ways the the early insight was not even yet a technological insight but a business model insight of if you could take these profit pools um of um sometimes financial products and use them to invest in great software led to some of our early products like the card
12:09that not only wants you to spend less but does your expense reports. Um it led us to be able to invest in great bill payment um software where we had a lot more dollars actually than businesses just doing that type of software. And now you see this platform uh where not only are we seeking and pursuing to be aligned with our end customers. uh and so we measure how many fewer dollars and hours they actually spend. But because you've sort of thought about the model more holistically uh we have more
12:36dollars than many of our competitors who are just underinvesting uh in actually making their customers businesses better.
12:43So the 0ero to1 for ramp really was that you know how do you actually go in and similar to parabus you're spending all this money on subscriptions are you using them or not let's make it easy to unsubscribe. Was that sort of like the initial 0ero to one that worked? It's perfectly said and there's one extra twist which is important I think for people thinking about building aic businesses which is the ability to act or do something. One of the challenges that we felt at Parabus was we could see and were authorized on behalf of
13:12customers to look at hundreds of millions of emails per day.
13:16A small amount of them were online retail purchases or flight or hotel bookings. But there was we believe billions of dollars we could be going in savings. But our only mechanism to ask was email customer service and hope they give a refund to the end customers. We were fascinated with the idea of could you actually embed this into the movement of money? Could you be close enough to the metal that maybe to put it directly, it's one thing to see that you are wasting money. It's another thing to
13:45be able to stop the purchase um and actually prevent uh dollars going out of subscriptions that you don't want to go leave. And so that was declined.
13:53Exactly. We're taking it down further.
13:55So that's what part of pulled pulled it from just building the intelligence to actually could you be at the operational layer.
14:01That makes sense. You know Paul Graham talks about this a lot. It's like you know when you're going 0ero to one uh it's actually a feature to go sell to startups as opposed to like the biggest enterprises like you'll get the biggest enterprises later like was that true for you? It was um and there's I mean just extraordinary companies that um years ago were small startups and now they're huge companies and we've grown with them. I I think about cursor in
14:29cognition. Um both organizations we serve when they were just a handful of people to they built extraordinary companies and so that's absolutely right. I think if you can build for the future, build for the past and you had to pick one, I'd pick the future every day. Well, fast forward a little bit. Um, RAMP has just reached $60 billion valuation. Uh, congratulations.
14:49And you called this the end of the beginning. Um, what does that mean? And you know what what if you had to say like okay well that's the first chapter.
14:58You know what was that and then of course what's the next?
15:01I talk about from a product level and how we operate is we were really thinking about both when we wrote that post. one if you've operated inside of a company you have right like uh on one side you have kind of your your payroll system who reports to whom department locations a lot of hierarchies there on the other side you have your your ERP um your system of records where you store here's what we spent this month here's what happened um here's all the money we received and in between is like a total cluster for the finance team uh classically because the banks could move
15:31money and the software people could build weird aftermarket software uh if you looked at companies and realities. I mean, it's still true for most companies today, but for non-RAMP customers, it's you have one system for credit cards, another for expenses, another for bills, another for procurements, another for travel, another for you can go on and on and on. It's really cludgy. And so, if you actually want to go and you know, even just educate, oh, if you're an employee and you want to buy software, you might teach have to teach them to
16:01use multiple systems. you have an incomplete view and you end up with waste, wasted time, wasted money, all that. And so part of the first chapter was building kind of the complete mesh layer almost Pac-Manning up all of the different types of tools so you could actually use one very simple and streamlined box to make sure there's fewer dollars leaving your organization.
16:20And today the median company uses ramp uh saves 7.5% per year on their expenses, which is multiple times what what interchange even could be. uh and is helping them grow a lot faster. We did very little um from a product perspective trying to be disciplined uh on uh if our goal was to help people cut costs, we did less in our software of how do you help grow revenue faster. And so part of this chapter 2 is not just how do you go and help make sure there's
16:49fewer dollars leaving organizations, but actually for the dollars you are trying to to to spend, how do we make them have a higher multiplier? How can you collect revenue? And so we've launched accounts receivable recently. Um, uh, Glass and Inspect and some of our new AI tools are actually expressly designed to make every member of teams more productive.
17:10And so from a product lens, uh, it's really about, uh, not just less waste, but it's more about faster growth, time, and money going further. From a a company perspective, roughly a little less than four years ago, ChatGpt launched. This is GPT 3.5. It was the most advanced model in the world and you and I both remember it couldn't really do arithmetic, right? 2 plus 4 equals who knows basic things couldn't do it. Yeah.
17:36I mean, it was a cool toy.
17:37It was amazing. You know, sometimes they have paragraphs that made sense. You go back and forth and that was when it was a stoastic parrot still, but it evolved quickly and it's evolved to this place where, you know, it solved Navier Stokes, a problem that mathematicians, the best in the world for the past 200 years, could not solve. And then I think 3 weeks later on a random Thursday night it dropped proofs to several hundred more problems. I think most people still haven't internalized just the pace of progress and what it means. And while most people still haven't yet adopted AI
18:06in their own workflows, I think even fewer organizations have sought to ask in a world in which this kind of intelligence exists, have I designed my organization in the right way? And so part of chapter 2 is about uh I think this continued reimagination of what an organization of the future can look like and how we build the tools to power that. Yeah, it seems like I mean sitting where we're at now like you know recursive self-improvement is happening
18:34inside the labs uh at least reportedly and you know the next 9 to 24 months are going to be pretty astonishing moment where like model capabilities just you know are taking off. Um and then simultaneous to that you have this you released this crazy stat about the top 1% of um spenders spend 80% of the spend on AI tokens right now. Is that right?
18:59That is exactly right.
19:00And so it seems like simultaneous to this crazy thing that's happening the actual ability for you know sort of even startups to like radically change the way they do things is flat. I mean, it's the people who uh were going to adopt it at least in this like 24-month time frame seemingly have embraced it and they they're they're doing it, but you know, there's this large like 99% that currently says actually like we
19:29have no this like like some kind of skill issue or something. I it's it's very wild actually. This is not like a fringe thing. It's actually like kind of a societal like GDP affecting sort of mission. It is I think going to be the most transformative bizarre years I've lived through in my life and maybe all of us listening and thinking about this but the future is here it is not evenly distributed that is for sure.
19:55So I mean internal to ramp like that's what you've been doing um you have a number of uh internal tools you know you have inspect a coding agent you've got research which is your internal AI analyst and then glass is sort of your knowledge and shared workflow system.
20:10What have those things done for you andor like how do they even come about?
20:13Like how did you structure the team?
20:15Like you know you're you're one of the 1% yourself. So for the people who are a part of the 99 like tell us the story of like your own transformation so far.
20:24Change is very hard for people like and maybe to give an example. We've spent so much time in the finance world. So, sometimes we'll hire people outside of like an investment bank or a private equity firm and they'll show up at a company and uh one of the ways that finance teams, maybe your finance teams, if you're listening to this, we'll go haze those people is they probably have become just like really good at Excel on Windows and they know all the hot keys and they're they're great at it. And then you haze them by getting them like a Mac and you give them Excel and they're like, I don't know how to use
20:52this. Like, it's too complicated. And in some sense it it's funny, but it sort of exhibits this basic truth of like even learning how to use the tool that you've maybe used for multiple years in like a slightly different operating system can be like hard for people to make that that change. And that's why many finance orgs still they're like the only team uh still operating on like a Windows machine inside of a startup.
21:15And so in some sense to go to any member of your team or life, your family and say like, "Hey, I know you've been doing work this way for 20 years.
21:29You should just use AI now."
21:30It's like a really big ask. It's like a lot bigger than just same program, different OS. It is really hard. Uh and so in some sense like actually thinking through and giving some people the the grace to figure out like how do you actually relearn everything that you you kind of know.
21:48Did you have to do that like at the team level? You're like okay we're going to start with I mean engineering is an obvious place to start and you've always had like incredible you know IMO gold like you know the best of the best um engineers. They were like hey actually we're just going to start doing this probably. What what happened inside of the company is what hap is is is what is happening in the world where 1% of the people were using 80% of the tokens who were also like becoming the most extraordinarily productive people like
22:16you'd have you know not exaggerating 100x engineers people who were just so radically productive and they're being faster and others who are behind and some functions moving fast and it would start breaking parts of the organization. For example, you'd have engineers who maybe were 10 or 100x as productive. of designers uh who were 2x as productive. Um product people maybe got with the program and they were 5x as productive and companies traditionally have these ratios right like six to eight engineers to one product manager
22:45to one designer and it's a big problem if the productivity um of one function or another doesn't get there and so you'd start having like all these pain points where engineers were out running um other parts of the company.
22:56Fascinating. You'd have people who suddenly were growing faster and for capacity models like we had to go hire all these people and you'd get these hiring requests where there was this inverse correlation. The more AI you used uh often you were radically more efficient so you didn't need as many people and if you weren't using it at all maybe you would say that you were Yeah. and you would request a lot of people. And so it it got to this point where earlier this year we just said
23:25like and by the way this business is growing more than 100% per year. We said we're not hiring for a whole quarter.
23:31And part of why we we did that is first of all hiring is takes a lot of work. Um to find people, interview people, onboard people, you get less productive before you get more productive. But two like I I didn't want learning AI to be like a in 5% of your time. Like it needs to be like your core competency. And the and the whole question was how do you get people to this aha moment where finally you see it and you understand it and you never want to go back. Um and so part of it was how do we create the conditions to do that? Another side of it is actually just it you don't encounter these problems as much in
24:00small startups where you're just getting going and your whole environment maybe is on your your local device. Uh but inside of large organizations what happens is you say go use cloud code then someone from your sales team says fine I'll do it and then they download it and then they have to open terminal and they're like what's terminal and I have to install these packages and they finally get it done and then they have to ask it or someone of can I connect it to data bricks or snowflake or google or slack or stripe and you can't do anything. It's like I think most
24:30people's experience with AI is it's this unbelievable alien intelligence and there is a wall and like a little slip and you can write a note chat and you can pass a note to it and then it can pass a note back to you which is so far from when you looked at how these unbelievable engineers who were getting 100x productivity gains where you know I think about inspect what makes it so useful and it's 85% plus of how of all the poll requests that we have uh at
24:59ramp um the uh the number of poll requests per engineer is still growing like 40% every month roughly and so it's a radical velocity improvement. It can see all the data that the engineer can see. Uh it has access to its you know to to the code. Uh it has uh its own virtual machines, its browser, it's it's everything. It's not just a great intell it's it's it's merged with your team. I always remember that scene in Matrix where you know Keanu wakes up and he's
25:27like I know kung fu or if you've watched like Avatar uh you know the whole premise was like the the main character knows all the things that like his ancestors uh know uh and so it it has this almost like super vision this super insight.
25:42There was almost this desire to say actually how do we make it easy for everyone to do these things to know all the things that the company knows. um when you get a complaint from a from a customer um about a bug, you know, Inspect can go and read that email. It knows all of the recent code changes, it can can locate it. Uh it can go write the change and it can email the customer back. And so instead of back to where we started of like these capacity models, you have to go hire, you know, 30 other
26:10people, you can just fix it in 15 minutes and all these compounding advantages just go. And so sounds like building your own harnesses around these things. Um it's not just the harness, it's also the integrations like the uh authentication is built in and then standardization across the whole company like oh yeah we just use inspect like you know have some people over here using this thing and some other people using this other thing and I don't mandate any tools for people you
26:38can use whatever you want and we do like we there's an incredible culture of experimentation there was a great post from enthropic about the early days of cloud code and ramp was believe the first alpha customer and like trying to tinker with them. Uh cognition we were the first customer of of Devon uh cursor one of the first like people have access to great tools and we let people choose what in their own opinion is the best for them and uh that's the goal. So what
27:07would you recommend like I mean as people you know there are people out here watching who actually probably run thousand person organizations but you know they're telling their engineers you know you can have two clawed max accounts and that's it like you know what's your policy what would you recommend like how you know how does the uh you know 99% become the 1%. Not that the way that we do things is right for everyone. But this is why uh we've released uh inspect uh in glass. I
27:37believe really strongly if other organizations are able to be more productive the world be better. And so some folks just welcome to see if if what we built internally is great for for you. Um, but more than that, and I think like the the question behind the question you're getting at is like I actually think like the ROI era of like AI is here, right, in some sense where when you put like a flat budget or something and you just say we're going to spend only $1,000 or only $100 or whatever the number is and that's it.
28:06It's sort of in my opinion like a bit of a silly way of doing things like like I I put it this way. I'm there are some people where I'm thrilled that they're spending $1,000. Other where I couldn't be more angry. If someone spends $1,000 to make $10,000, I'm trying to throw money at them. If someone's spending $1,000 to do their weekly prep for no value, I don't know. Like maybe we shouldn't do that. And so like it is a completely incomplete way of looking at the world of just asking how much did we
28:35spend. And this is where this is now the obsession of ramp of how can you actually go measure even semantically not just like who spent uh and show this in one place across all of your tools but understand okay uh we spent $5 on a new landing page that new landing page picked up you know converts 3% better uh which generates $5,000 more per month or whatever it is. And so part of where we build in maybe a different way than than others is we don't sell tokens, we buy
29:05them. Um uh we seek to measure them and we help companies connect back what they're spending to the outcomes.
29:12YC's next batch is now taking applications. Got a startup in you?
29:16Apply at y combinator.com/apply. It's never too early and filling out the app will level up your idea. Okay, [music] back to the video. I guess so.
29:26Glass specifically that's it sounds like it's kind of your um other people might just throw people at codeex or cloud code with and it's like you figure out how to hook hook up the systems whereas glass is your company brain like it you know you can use a frontier model with it but it's got all the integrations and then is it like all info about the company like uh analytics like finance you know customer support like all the things about um running ramp are like all in
29:56there and then who gets access and you know how does it work you know we're 1930 people I I was looking here last 24 hours 1925 used it so people use it to do their work you know do their whole work and to know what's going on and exactly and there's a lot of design decisions that went into to this first of all to to your point it connects automatically um to all of the core systems that a
30:24company uses right so whether it's your data warehouses, your analytic suites, maybe you're using Zenesk for um customer support, that all that data is getting pulled into it. And so at a company level, there's much more of a complete view of what actually is occurring and you can make connections between data sets. But for an individual, you have the access permissions that you should have and that can vary by by company. There are shared skills. Um, so if someone from the sales team figures out like a a better way to do research and a scene conversion, it shows up and pops up
30:54becomes the default for others. Uh, there's model selection. Um, so if an open model series is better or uh, you know, cloud or openi, you can use any one that you want. There's smarter defaults. Um, you know, I would venture to say that uh, maybe the majority of spend on frontier models uh, could be done um, by you know, a simpler model. there's smart trade-offs built into it.
31:18Um, for example, our background coding agent, um, sometimes it's we are happy to have the process and reasoning take 10% longer um, for a 50% cut in price and so there's better defaults. I think when you start to get all this data, not only are you paying, you're not paying 10 times for for everyone to keep relearning the same lesson, but you're actually able to develop and start to see at the organizational level, what is the decision-m, what is the reasoning that makes this company different. Not
31:48just like what is individual person doing, but like what is the unique viewpoint uh and way that ramp operates and functionally you're teaching your system to do that. So even if someone great does great work and leaves, it's in a skill file.
32:02It's in the skill files. It's there.
32:04I guess some of this is um it's not just for everyone to be able to do their work better. It's actually really useful for you and Kareem as co-CEOs. You're able to actually dive in and see like well what is that process? Is there something in glass that says like okay well there's one process for um you know refunding a customer for this or whatever workflow when you have you know people just cobbling things together like you might not get that visibility and there might be like five different ways to do something.
32:32Yeah that is exactly right. [snorts] I mean you you functionally are able to understand like what are the standard operating procedures what are the reasons of how something is is able to get done. uh but you're you also can start to see like there are discrepancies you know maybe to speak to how glass helped us develop a great product that has come to life um maybe on the finance side of the house I'll give you an example so every company ramp does YC um uh unfortunately needs
33:01to have expense policies kind of falls out of sarbain oxley and audit requirements and and all kinds of thing but uh it functionally means that every time that someone makes a purchase someone is supposed to review it um that's not you and is culminating in large organizations where you have highly paid people uh just reviewing the expenses for everybody. Um and it kind of makes no sense and these people aren't thinking about expenses or what the policy says or where it's incomplete or wrong um and are actually wrong quite often. Um either they'll just submit and
33:29approve everything or waste their time doing it. And we had built a similar product um for the policy agent where functionally it knows your full expense policy. it's able to at 99% accuracy um go and you know either approve it, decline it or say like policy is incomplete and every time that things are uh approved or change or overridden uh it learns and if things are in conflict or things incomplete it writes and adjusts the policy as the company
33:56changes. And so to your point um companies are not discrete rule engines like they evolve um the style of thinking and the reasoning can evolve but you can trace the lineage and understand the decision-m in a way where sometimes large companies are bureaucratic insec like inscrutable organizations.
34:15Yeah. I guess uh this is a very interesting moment for um transparency inside all organizations that choose to do this company brain model because it's very open like before it was silos and you know a VP or an executive might be able to like have very tight control over what information goes and you know it usually is probably one of those things you might have seen at a financial institution that doesn't quite serve its users well. Right.
34:41Absolutely. in some of these are like fundamental questions of like what mode is an organization in are you seeking to create value like I think at as a company is just getting started there's no revenue there is no asset there is no code uh there is no IP and so everything is oriented on like we must go create we must go do stuff and I think these organizations tend to be very open by default you hire smart people you pay them for their judgment startups are great that's why startups are great
35:09that's why there's creative destruction I think so. I think it's better.
35:13Well, I mean the processes end up um oifying companies because they have something to protect.
35:19That's right. Uh and then they're also interestingly um a 20th century sort of phenomenon in that um this is right you know human beings only have their 40 hours a week and you know we can keep you know seven plus or minus two things in our brain at any given moment and then I mean the models today even the cheaper ones can do a million tokens that's like three Harry Potter books.
35:44That's like superhuman even in a pure like rifle shot memory case. So you know of course the organizations are going to change and they're not going to be these sort of siloed um you know sort of protected information silos that like roll up to a single person who's then like accumulating you know I started my career Microsoft so that was my experience with large organizations was like you had these fftoms that uh had like you know a locust of control and you know there's long books written
36:14about like how oified and terrible Microsoft of that era was that can end now. I mean even in large organizations do you think that the 99 at least some percentage of the 99% that refuses to do it do you think that those are actually uh a victim of like this these thftdoms and sort of like the information like it it requires a top- down cultural change that you know either the CEO is not willing to take the board is not willing
36:42to support the CEO or the executives on mass are like at war with one another and so they you know just won't do I think that is exactly right and I do think it is this interesting question of if you look at who survives and how do businesses go on and transform. the history is very clear of like the odds are not good for companies um by default over a long enough time horizon you will go bankrupt right over a long enough
37:10time horizon if you don't innovate you will die and it's interesting to question like what businesses continue to survive and why um and I do think the primary cause of death of these organizations is some kind of indigestion the coordination costs get too high uh information is overly siloed uh they don't make the hard calls Uh, and you're right. I actually think with AI, there are heavyweight companies that could start moving like lightweights again. And you're starting
37:40to see signs of that where large companies are suddenly growing faster, which functionally defied gravity. Uh, the larger you'd get, the slower you would get. And you're seeing these inflection of of companies. And that's part of what happened at RAMP where now we do over 2 billion a year in revenue and we're growing significantly faster uh you know more than 25% faster um uh now than we were a year ago. And I thank you but I I think a lot of other organizations can can do this and I also think
38:08a lot of organizations get stuck in the form factor of like what do they sell and how do they organize around that. Sometimes ramp is compared to American Express because we started by issuing cards. And I find the history of that company very fascinating. Like it started in 1850. And their first product was basically like the Pony Express.
38:24Like you could put stuff in the back of a wagon and they'd get it to Ohio or whatever. Uh what in the heck does that have to do with a global financial conglomerate um you know of the 21st century? And uh in some sense I think that they unlike the other companies that we don't remember sort of understood that what they actually were doing was selling trust. Um that if you gave them gold or some bank note it would get to where you needed to it needed to be. And so of course it's
38:53logical that um as the world became bigger uh they should go into the traveler's checks industry. Um do they have cards so that if you go to a merchant and you're out of cash no problem they'll take care of you. And a lot of great companies understand like what their mission is. is what are they in the pursuit of? Um, ultimately every company is trying beyond their missions trying to convert $1 into more and they're open to the details uh [snorts] as to how they're going to get there.
39:18And I think this is a period that requires enormous reimagination of like why do we work this way? The AI argument is so interesting right now because there's really you could make basically two arguments and both of them are very extreme. Um because like the size of a firm is um defined by the friction of like the different parts of the firm. I think it's like uh this professor co has like a cos's theorem the right uh and then basically it could go one of
39:46two way. I mean it could go both ways in different industries. I'm not really sure. Like one view with the fast takeoff and sort of the the doomer AI angle is like um it's inevitable that like one of the labs will run away with it and then they will capture a light cone of all future value, right? And so that's the argument that like actually the ideal number of firms is one and it'll serve like all the needs of humanity or something like that. And then way on the other end is like there could be hyper specialization
40:15and you know the world is um often like uh monopoly or duopoly because people are sort of uh beholdened to brands and seven plus or minus two things you can keep in your head but agents actually sort of um can bring about like hyper specialization. So there's no reason why there can't be thousands or tens of thousands of firms each making a billion or billions of dollars like hyper specializing in providing like exactly what is right for like a particular set
40:44of people or companies and you know that's sort of the white pill version of this that like YC is hoping for. Oh, I want to talk about this because I actually think like the last two months have been incredibly fascinating if you look at what's occurred in the data and I actually believe support worldview number two very strongly.
41:02Me too. I mean we're we're betting on it but you know we we got to fight for it too. we have to fight for it and and look like I I think that so much of people's priors and ideas about what what the labs are going to going to turn into were we're we're based in a time period where GPT3 I I 3.5 I don't know it's hard to translate its intelligence directly to IQ but uh certainly below far below the average human to maybe the
41:29four series started to get to uh a little bit below or around average human five and six have have surpassed It's insane.
41:36And if you have a job that requires 120 IQ and every time that you go from 70 to 90 to 115, the returns to that are going to be incredible. But there's this question of what happens when you go from like 120 to 150 for tasks that don't require it. Like put differently, you know, it might be that accounting is solvable with 120 model. Like we're good. We're good on accounting. I have friends who you know fired their CPA and you know Claude does their taxes now and
42:05CPA Claude and what I would say really directly that no one has talked about this but it's very clear in the data which is over the last two months Jeban's paradox broke fascinating like it it used to be for that period of time these are made up numbers let's say you discount the price of intelligence by 10% it becomes 10% more affordable you would see the increase in consumption uh of quantity of intelligence used more than offset like railroads came down in price and
42:33they spiked up the usage of railroads this is it and you know I I imagine railroad telecom like there you know there's it's a repeating effect for anything that like networks and brings people together and AI was that until recently until recently uh and and who knows like maybe new model families can go and break that again it may not be permanent maybe we're at like a local maxima for for now uh and there's ways to go and drive adoption I mean I would argue it's probably related to what we just talked about. It's like you know RSI is here
43:03the model capabilities are going like this and then suddenly like the capability of society to absorb that is more or less a limit like all the you know all the people who uh were going to become AI psychosist out have done it and they're going to benefit from this. Yes. But then you know what about the 99% is a little bit captured by like internal politics or you know not invented here or like lots of you know just like we're too comfortable right now we don't want to deal with it. Something's going to
43:32change. something's going to change and it gives me hope for I mean the world but also especially for startups right like like the interesting question is now let's say that the cost of intelligence and it should very clearly continue to drop uh maybe intelligence will be you know almost free uh you know in the future what is possible to build what kind of businesses what kind of problems can be solved that once you've crossed this threshold uh of of cost you can go from impossible to possible can
44:00you go from zero to one and suddenly new innovative businesses go and can exist. Classically, I I think the story of capitalism is uh the value to the ecosystems of inventions are much larger than the value captured by the creator of these inventions. Uh and so I think I think it's going to be just a completely wonderful and fascinating decade ahead.
44:23I want to get back to what you were saying about um glass cuz you're you know I think we were talking about glass like you changed the way everything works. it um popped your growth by 25% uh like in excess of what you know the the previous rate which is pretty significant at large scale. How much of that like making glass and these internal tools has in has actually changed the core product for people who use ramp significantly. In the second quarter,
44:52there were 7,000 poll requests um that were created by non-engineers, which is great, right? And the interesting part is like probably two years ago um the number of poll requests created by non-engineers was functionally zero.
45:06You just can't I mean you're going to like get git and you know who's going to let you commit?
45:11Yeah, exactly. Who's gonna let you who's going to approve like this person's code? The majority of those are coming from the customer experience team.
45:18And this happens in companies all the time. Someone reports a bug, what do you do? Maybe you send a response, hope it works. You get 10 of these things. Someone's writing a user story. Uh you go in a classic organization. Maybe they're still on like agile or some horrible methodology.
45:33And uh they write up a ticket, they go try to convince, you know, product manager it's worth it. They prioritize it. They give it to a designer. Maybe it makes it to an engineer and two months later you have this thing.
45:44Yeah. or more often like it goes into a bug database and uh gets marked P3 won't fix like goodbye. It'll never get fixed.
45:52Go somewhere to die.
45:54There are whole things in schwab.com that like will always be like that.
45:58[laughter] It's like unbelievable. You know what is interesting is in in a world where the cost of doing something goes from 3 months down to minutes, things start getting better all the time. um you start moving quickly like the software starts getting more intuitive uh to use. Um people can actually feel a lot more agency. You're not just move the cheese from here to there, but actually you can go build it.
46:23Kind of sounds like Toyota in the '8s.
46:25Yeah. remember like um suddenly these Japanese cars started flooding the American market and they were way better cars and they didn't break down all the time and it all came from like a process innovation with you know and Kaizen like just this idea that uh the person on the factory line can change their process on the fly that's the same as like letting you know your customer support person who's like talking to someone experiencing a real pain go in and press a button and then actually oh that thing's done now like
46:55literally literally like that same day and the implications are profound. One, people's expectations of each other go up. You know, saying no or we're going to do this, you know, on Monday instead of today like becomes why would you do that? You can go do this today. And so everyone like their their game is raised and you start seeing like I I think about the last five months every single month we've had a major like product release. It used to be at ramp and we move very fast. We count the days of how old we've been. you would have
47:24one or two major releases a year if you were lucky. And you see this expressed in faster growth rates. You see this expressed in terms of for sales people their quotas go up. Uh so then don't feel bad for them. They're making more.
47:35Um and so when you get these things right, um you know, I don't think this is a phenomenon unique to RAMP, but like I just think company not just makes more money, but uh you deliver faster products to more people and people's businesses get better. And I I like the stat which I'm more proud of is not just the 25% growth rate. Um it's that the median customer on ramp a year ago is able to cut their expenses by about 5% per year. It's 7.5%. And what does it
48:03mean if you can waste 50% fewer dollars?
48:07Uh by the way the average company in the US has a 8% profit margin. Can you actually accelerate the growth uh of not just the companies you're serving but hopefully the whole world?
48:17Yeah. You know, I uh tweeted something that like was a little controversial at the time. It's like uh either you die a system of record company or you live long enough to become an AI harness.
48:28Does that resonate with you? Like are you guys releasing AI harness like things for your customers yet? Do you think that that tweet is correct or false? I think it is correct. Actually, I'm I'm going to agree with it. We are strange in our industry of like sometimes people think of ramp as a fintech and like that's just not us. We're more of a productivity company.
48:48It's like how do you waste fewer dollars? How do you make your your dollars and hours go further? And if you believe that AI is this radical tool for productivity, if you believe that there are 100x engineers and 10x engineers, how could you not try to make everyone 100x engineers, you must start thinking about AI harnesses. Glass is a AI harness.
49:09But customers can't use their own glass yet inside the ramp.com interface. Or can they? So there's pieces of ramp where like if you want to interact aentically, if you want to go and adjust policies, if you want to go and do custom research, it's like an MCP, I'm sure.
49:24Exactly. Um, and by the way, MCP usage is growing about 10% per week right now. We've had it for 2 years. Um, it is exploding in terms of usage and I think will become a dominant way that ramp is used in the not too distant future. Uh, but you can actually use uh as of this week, we're onboarding customers onto Glass for their own companies.
49:44Yeah. So, it's happening.
49:45Let's talk about hiring a little bit.
49:47You said, um, you know, hiring people because they built m businesses on Minecraft as teenagers is, you know, one of the good ways. What are some of the other ways that you've been able to sort of hire the the best and the brightest?
50:00Have you ever heard the story of Sutton's Law? Mm-m. So, there was a bank robber and it must have been in like the 30s or 40s and the story goes, you know, he would he would go rob banks and he'd go to jail and he robbed banks again and go to jail and one day a reporter, you know, catches him. He's outside of the courthouse and they're like, "Why'd you do it? Why did you rob this bank?" And he looks back at the reporter and he says, "Cuz that's where the money is."
50:24[laughter] Which is sort of funny. It's like, you know, where else were you going to rob?
50:28Good demand function as any. And if you want to find people who are good at building stuff, you go to places that demonstrate that they like building things. Um, uh, Minecraft is a great example. If you are building a business as a 14-year-old, um, in private servers that other people will use and pay money for, uh, it is a clear sign that you can make things that people want. Uh if you want to find people who are good at solving algorithmic problems, well go look and see who at the age of 16 is
50:56winning at you know math counts or the IMO or the IOI. I mean name the function. Like it's a little bit of of of people just get stuck at looking at resumes and how people present stuff.
51:07And I I'm just not as interested in that as I am of is there any proof that someone has done great work in the past uh on their own?
51:16And look I think there are people who haven't pushed themselves to do it and you still can find people through more standard mechanisms but uh in some sense Sutton's law is sort of brilliant and under you know study it's the same thing for hiring you know yeah why often I think you know we do we have to make choices in 10 minutes or so and then uh the funny realization at some point was like people are just broadcasting who they are at all times and they're like notice me notice me so
51:44you know sometimes you just have to look and you'll see what they are. You'll see what they're about. You know, looking back on, you know, all the success and all the things, you know, all the adversity you've gone through like building this, you know, multiple great businesses, you know, what's one thing that if you could send a time machine back or just one, you know, message to the 18 or 20-year-old version of yourself, um, you know, what would you send? You know, I remember, and this is part of why YC was so transformative for us. I had never
52:13started a startup. if I didn't really understand what they were, how they operated, it seems so foreign. And whether you're someone who's just waiting to get started or you're a founder and you're on your journey, you're going to encounter, you know, obstacles and impasses all the time. I think that in life, whether that's because it's the grades you get at school or when you open up Instagram, people are trying to show that they they're cool, they know what they're doing. Um, you know, everyone's
52:42trying to look like they've got it all together and it leads you to not ask for help. And I think one of the things that I mean, the most powerful piece of advice I've gotten through Parabus, through RAMP, through just trying to change my life and other people's is I think one of the most powerful words you can say as a founder, CEO, or just person is is actually like, I need your help. I'm trying to figure this out. Here's the problem I have. And it's so rare. uh I
53:11think for founders to go and say like I actually have this problem. Uh I need this advice. And I I think it was one of the things that I remember just vividly of of like when I think about what office hours were and and are for me of like, you know, it's really just three questions. How much did you grow this week? What's your biggest problem? And what are you going to do about it?
53:40I think is actually trying to pull people into mode of thinking of like where do I need help show your reasoning but but ask for it feel comfortable actually just like working through that and and if you get used to doing that early in your life or at any age like you can solve things uh by confronting it and so I think I spent a lot of time waiting to ask for for help and um it's gone a long way Eric thanks so much for joining us thanks Gary