0:00If I own a 100% of the stock of this company, the person on the planet I would most want to run this company is Jensen.
0:06But the company's been maimed. The whole ecosystem's been maimed. It will never be the same company. Wow, what a week of news. We have the biggest IPO ever. Dear Lord Dario coming out with Anthropic, we have Jensen Huang. Will he come back?
0:18Will the board give in? We shall see. Microsoft Outage. Outlook teams co-pilot down. And then SpaceX catches Starship. Incredible. this and so much more in the show this week. The winner here of course is Entropic.
0:33I think the liquidation preference has been weakened by the Nvidia drama.
0:36You buy SpaceX the stock entirely on the basis of what you think Entropic will be paying you one year from now for that compute.
0:43LPS are going to grade us all on how many 20 billion and up portfolio companies we have. Ready to go, [music] boys. Uh we have more on this week than I think almost any other week. We've got the largest IPO in history, I believe.
1:07[snorts] Uh and then we also have one of the greatest founders potentially coming back. I mean, the news just doesn't stop. Jansen Huang since we last spoke falls from Nvidia. Uh stock loses up to 601 billion in a morning. And then the biggest investors Gavin Baker, Alimita come out with letters and like 5,000 employees, 200,000 people signed the petition.
1:36Let's just start with do we think it's right that he was let go?
1:40What do you mean by right? If you were on the board, would you have let him go?
1:44If I were on the board with this guy who'd founded and built a company for 30 years, one of the things I've learned is decisions in haste are often wrong. Finding some way to say, "Take a leave of absence. We need to figure this out. Get to the bottom. Slow the whole thing down so you can make a better decision.
2:00I look when I've made dumb decisions, and I've made plenty, usually it's you're reactive, you're quick, you don't have time to think and let it settle in." in the same situation as a board member, I probably have tried to find a way to be to make a less irrevocable decision and get more time to think, right? So, I actually think that hey, take a leave of absence, interim CEO, whatever, and let's figure what's going on here. So, that's the first comment.
2:26And then just two other comments. Just the second thing is this is a messy thread because you have you know you have the personal uh allegations both with um a customer and with employee and separately you have this emerging dynamic of you know um compliance with export controls and all the dynamics around that and kind of getting inter intersh with the administration. So, one of the odds I've had here is you don't know what the board knew at any particular point in
2:56time. And you know, was it just as simple as, oh, I can't believe there's a second affair. I'm done. I've lost trust. Or where are these other dynamics coming into play? I just don't know.
3:04Right. But again, I go back to more time to figure out what's going on would have been useful. Can we just temper my hopes and expectations? Do we think that he will come back? As of this morning, he just made that statement which basically says, "If you want me back, I'd love to come back." Proving the one of the old rules, never resign in anger or even in shame, you know, take your time. So, he's now sitting there going, "Maybe I shouldn't have quit. Maybe I should."
3:29But yeah, so that's a statement now. But you asked a separate question. Will he come back? I want to say something about the board. Four or five of these board members have been on for 30 years. They backed Jensen uh 30 years ago when he was you in his early 30s. There's two VCs and then there's an audit chair and one other person. It's probably been the single most significant business relationship of all of those board members life. And I've been on boards for 10 years. I've never been on a board for 30 years. And I've never been on a
3:57board for 30 years of a company that went from a startup to the most valuable company on the planet. But I know how much I like my board, my CEOs that I've backed for 10 years, and how hard it would be for me to vote to replace them. I can only imagine how hard that must have been.
4:13I mean, Mark Stevens made $4 billion off uh you don't want to fire the guy, and he just sold a billion cash this year.
4:19You don't want So, you did remind me that while they did not um you technically did not fire, they also did I think again, you get a lot of leaks here. So I would just want to acknowledge one thing. When four or five people who are you wly experienced, have made a ton of money decide to to go against someone that they've really, as I say, been the most important successful business relationship with their right. You kind of really go there must be something that's really getting on goat, right? So given that, it's hard
4:47to imagine this board saying a week later, you know, upon sober reflection, we made a horrible decision. We're going to just vote you back in. That seems a big lift. That's the first comment. Then technically you could have a shareholder vote to replace the board and then the new board could it's technically possible. Um I think my guess is at the margin.
5:09The thing you don't know and I don't know is separate from all the relationship questions these whole department commerce department of justice comments on you know Nvidia's actions in terms of you know selling chips to Indonesia that may well end up in to Singapore that may well end up in China you know my guess is until that thing is run to ground I mean the department of justice and the department of commerce issued a statement on this recent just in this week which is interesting so does that pending issue which wasn't the crystallizing issue for
5:38the resignation. Obviously, the relationships were, but it's kind of out there. It's hard to imagine a board saying, "Oh, let's come back and fight this one." So, my gut would be in the absence of a board change, no. I mean, I could be wrong, but my gut would be no. And I could look like an idiot in two days.
5:55I'll tell you why. I think there's a high chance he comes back. A high chance, right?
5:59By this week, maybe. Maybe. Because, and this week is fast, right? He shouldn't come back this week. It should take a couple of weeks to happen, but he may. I'll tell you why. And listen, we're we're all getting facts and these leaks really bother me.
6:10This is the most leaky ship we've ever observed. It's horrific. It's it's disgusting. Um um but I think what's changed since then is that I don't think there's going to be a huge issue of of of the spy who loved him, right? I think that's fading. Maybe not completely cuz the facts are actually getting worse, but I think it's going to fade away. I think we're going to say he didn't know she was a spy.
6:29Let's move on. And I think this issue, cuz it's already happened, it's already been banned. this issue of of allowing data centers adjacent to China to use top-of-the-line chips and and shipping and trans shipping breaking open the servers and then then driving the the chips off the border. This has already become a massive issue this week. Okay, massive issue. This will reverberate for for for a long long time and it may be 20% of Nvidia's total revenue if you count China. I the problem is if Jensen's guilty, so is the CFO signed the financial statements. So's the head
6:58of supply and engagement. So is the CTO. So, I think you got to bring them back because otherwise uh you you got to fire all of them. They're all guilty. They all set up these data centers.
7:10And it's funny you should say that cuz actually the the CFO actually being the CEO now is interesting because she's going to be on the hook. Is she going to reaffirm the guidance she gave a month ago? Is she going to say that every all the accounting that I booked the CFO is still good when I'm the CEO? And it's very hard to walk it back and say, "But it was it was me, but I've changed my mind, you know, gentlemen." So yes, there is complexity there.
7:33How can she say it wasn't me when she sides the financials? I agree. And she It's her job more to know where every chip goes than his. He's the guy out eating eating chicken and smoozing. Her job is to know where every GPU is. No, seriously. She can't say it wasn't me. She can't say it wasn't me.
7:48Interesting. Well, it's interesting because the board has now decided it's their job, too, because they formed this board committee on um importation, exportation of chips. some basically some board level risk supervision which exudes to me that they think that's the big tail risk right that that something happened and you know deliberately or accidentally you have some kind of breach of whatever you know ambiguous litigation we have around these issues so that's clearly being the dominant issue now right and just one other
8:17comment here which is when I Harry you asked the question will he I mean there's the two questions will he come back should he come back let make the clear state if I own a 100% of the stock of this In the absence of the US government trying to put a C my CEO in prison, the person on the planet I would most want to run this company is Jensen. And I'd want to make everything else go away.
8:38The question is, can you with the morass of being public? If he were to come back, what price bump would the stock get?
8:46It wouldn't go back to where it was.
8:49No. Because Oh, I think so.
8:53The whole ecosystem's been named. it will never be the same company.
8:56You've got two things. The first question would be what percentage of your revenue really was coming in directly from China. And it's worth pointing out like 10 years ago back before it mattered. I think you China was a 15% plus or minus of the business. So it's a good slug of the business goes away. So 15% of your business goes away you go down by 15% maybe. I don't know.
9:14And then the second thing is and this is a weird phenomenon. you you see it is that every he's been the master banker of the whole AI boom and everyone's been yeah yeah yeah that's great that's amazing and then the way humans are the a people are awful the minute he's out of the picture then everyone is dumping on those deals and saying those deals are stupid and they're all going to blow up right the question is if he comes back can you kind of go back to doing those deals I don't think so I think you would not be
9:41able to use capital as aggressively as he has been and that would have some impact at the margin on revenue.
9:50Boys, is it not fundamentally so bad for the venture ecosystem not having Jensen losing his aggression in direct deals?
9:59Yeah, it sucks. I mean, just start with a very basic comment. I mean the winner here of course is entropic because the biggest single thing that Jensen was pushing the thing that was most significant for I think the ecosystem was with his post acquisition and hugging face a open an open way US alternative right was his big agenda and it takes real money to build these models I mean you know you look at the statement in the S1 that it took I think 10 billion to train the
10:28last anthropic model no one else has the dollars to build an open source product. So if he is not able to come back and that agenda doesn't get pursued, you don't end up with a US open- source openweight product of significance.
10:42Second comment is given the whole China dynamic, you probably end up with more push back on using as J Jason pointed out two weeks ago Chinese openweight models. The winner is the closed weight provider in the US who's now got pricing power. Apparently, there's been leaks and rumors of senior anthropic people smiling happily about this because it is just good for them. They're not big NVIDIA customers and OpenAI is. So, their competitor is weakened and the provider of the cheap alternative product has been weakened as well. This
11:12I mean, there's a lot of conspiracy theories and who did the leaking, right?
11:15Um, but to Rory's point, I think what Nvidia did was perfectly legal. it was okay to to set up data centers outside of China that was used essentially remotely by Alibaba and friends. It was completely legal and as of now it's not right. Apparently it no longer is. It was legal. But when you're anthropic and and you're feeling uh and you're feeling distilled and ripped off, that seems like the crappiest loophole on planet Earth. How could they get away with this? Right? You're just stealing our IP. You're stealing our hard work uh by
11:44building this data center a couple a couple hundred miles away from our biggest competitors. It's uh it it's uh it's epic. Um I don't know that I don't know that Daario is gloating. Um but um but man, it's it's a boost. Speaking of a good day for Anthropic, it's about to be their big day. The the special day that we've all been waiting for. And again, we're slightly before what will be the news item of the day, so to speak.
12:117x oversubscribed. Some numbers reporting up to 10x overs subscribed for the IPO. uh up to a$ 1.4 to$ 1.5 trillion dollar price. Largest IPO ever.
12:25[snorts] How's this gonna go?
12:27Can I bring up my one big takeaway from it? Um, for what it's worth, it it has nothing to do with the 1.5 trillion we've talked about. The overs subscribe book is mildly interesting. Ror can give us our thoughts. I know we knew this, but I didn't realize it till I wrote it up this morning. Um, at 100 billion in revenue, which is where Enthropic will be by Q1 or whatever at run rate, right?
12:47Google had 81,000 employees. At 100 billion in revenue, Meta had 71,000. At 100 billion in revenue, Anthropic will have less than 6,000. Now, we've talked atomically on the show and many folks have, oh, that's no big deal. It's it's it's it's um it's inference and AI costs and AOR's 10 billion instead of humans. That's why this is like not a SAS model.
13:08It's not the margins are different. blah blah blah blah blah. All true, but let's just think about the human implications of that.
13:15The next hundred billion dollar company, yes, it got there faster than ever. Yes, it's the greatest venture return of all time potentially that, but it got there with the 12th employees of Google and Meta. A 12th, not like 30% less. Like the average go to market team according to iconic data is 30% smaller with AI.
13:32Like this is the all the all the Harveys and Schmarveys and Tarveys and Sierra about 30% smaller. Some are a bit smaller, but a 12th the size. I mean, uh, to me, this says jobs are even worse than [laughter] than what we've been discussing. A 12th, they got to 100 billion with a 12th employees. Who cares? At the end of the day, you know, as long as it's fundable, whether it's GPUs or BPUs or EPUs, that that is mind-bogglingly different for tech and our economy to get there with a 12th of humans. No, I I don't mean to be one of the folks
14:01that is anti-AI, but it is worth reflecting on in the moment when when we have when the average employee is making 41 million and and Ashton Kutcher is making more than I mean, good god, 600 million. I want to quit venture. But this employees thing to me for a moment is the most important thing in all of this because we've already used the products. Yes, this is a way more compute leverage, human non-lever play.
14:22You're exactly right. Which is why the humans who are there make more money because there's less of them. So you can share roughly the same part among a smaller number of people.
14:29Yeah. It turned out not to be that crazy what they're paying, right? 400,000 for a for manager. It's okay.
14:33You want the small number of people you have to be really good. I'm not sure it's as disastrous for labor as you think. It's not like every company's going to be 90% more efficient. I think these are the guys who can leverage compute the best. And I think I don't want to get lost in the weeds here. don't think most old companies like I don't think an old school consulting company is going to end up with $5 or $7 in inference for every dollar in labor and we've discussed this a lot you know that ratio will vary between old school companies software companies and then companies like
15:03anthropic and they'll be on the leading edge of it and you know so I think that the companies that are net additive will be compute intensive so I don't think it'll be as grim for jobs as you think Jason but nonetheless it is wildly noteworthy did you see the rumored 40% layoffs of service now today.
15:20I couldn't figure out I just thought I couldn't figure out if it's a rumor rumor, you know, is it real?
15:24I think it's true. I think it's a big deal. I I think it is more telling than you just to challenge you a little bit.
15:30Um and even segments that that don't appear that appear to be very humanentric, they're going through a lot of changes. Front offices, back offices are being automated. Um food delivery is being automated. I mean um and uh you know 80,000 to 6,000. I think this is the biggest disruption of our lifetimes beyond AI itself, right? Which is bigger. But my god, guys, does the anthropic IPO change venture in our world in significant
15:57ways? For me, I see LPs much more willing to redeploy cash that they're going to get from it. They're feeling flush in some cases. Uh I see a lot of anthropic early employees be angels in UK based companies. Any other ways where you're like, this has a meaningful knock-on effect? Well, of course it will. I mean, depending on where it ranks versus SpaceX, it's the biggest or second biggest IPO by absolute by dollars raised. More importantly, it happened in 5 years, not 20. You know,
16:25SpaceX, I mean, Founders Fund invested in SpaceX in ' 0708. It was founded in ' 02. It was, you know, so it's a good 26 plus years ago, right? This is founded 5 years ago and got to a trillion dollars.
16:38It just massively raises the bar of what is even vaguely possible. you know, the people who did it early, you know, all credit to Spark in particular and then Menlo in the following round are going to make out like bandits and as Veni said in that great post of his, you know, they're going to be playing with the house money for a long time to come and congratulate them. You know, well done, great decision, well executed, well written and yeah, they're going to make out like bandits and the rest of us are going to go, "Wow, I'm working really hard for one10enth or 120th of what you're going to make." And that's
17:05just the nature of an extreme power law business. it can get in your head because you can work really hard and you'll be like wow by anyone else's standards we're doing great but that's the single biggest win in history and one and the fastest so yeah it's going to raise the bar of what's possible in I mean you can see it even in the market right now I think what it does is you willing LP willingness to deploy and then GP willingness to take bets yeah [snorts] you know I mean everyone's like that bet worked we should do more of them
17:35I think you know I was just looking over the weekend at Carter's Q3 data which um you know since what's his name went to open router doesn't get as much attention [laughter] as it used to.
17:43Peter, Peter, right? Since he was so great at the data, I didn't even see anyone talk about it, but I I looked at it over the weekend. This is obvious, but to answer Harry's question, so Q3 2026, the most recent data they have, um, deals down 21%, dollars up 2.5x.
17:58To answer his question, so deals are going to keep going down or plateau, and the dollars will keep going up. That is just a radically different world than when we met and maybe even radically different than when this podcast started.
18:09This is it's and everything else. I mean, it's just a derivative of what you talked about. It's a derivative of of going of, you know, tripling and quadrupling down on winners. It's a derivative of AI spend, but fewer rounds, 2.5x the cash. Um, that's the world today and that's what that's the risk GPS are being paid to take and are are happy to take. Weird new world of venture.
18:29So, it's so different, right? I know you're going to be graded. The LPS are going to grade us all on how many 20 billion and up portfolio companies we have. That's how they're going to look at our portfolios. How many 20 billion and up? When I when I started it was unicorns, right? Um I don't know what it was when Rory started. Um but um you had like one unicorn in your portfolio. LPS would seek you out. Like not the best ones. Okay. But folks come out of the woodwork. I'm doing a unicorn analysis on a Google search. I found you have two. Are you are you are you raising?
18:57Now it's going to be 20. How many 20 billion and up startups do you have that ideally you invested at before a $20 billion valuation? That would help, right? Um I think that's that's how LPS are going to grade GPS. How many 20 billion and up? It's a new world.
19:10The funds who got in early on in um Anthropic, they're going to do amazing.
19:17They're probably going to have eight or ninex funds. And the amazing on big dollars, the amazing thing is the median fund in 1996 had a 6x DPI, right?
19:26Because they were all just doing seed and A and then the companies went public and it wasn't even a unicorn. You got you put something in at 20 million pre, it went public at 500, you had a 20x, life was great, right? So the odd thing is the multiple isn't that different than the two bubbles ago, but obviously the dollars involved are huge. If there's only 10 20 billion outcomes, then the earlier you go B A seed, the probability of you landing on one of those 10 or 20 outcomes logically just
19:55has to go down, especially with lots of people there, right? It's why you could argue that the the the the structure of having early and growth is the is is a very good structure for this environment because it is worth noteworthy that anthropic no one got into anthropic from the venture side before five no one meaningful before 5 billion when spark did it still pre-revenue right from the growth fund right so it's just interesting if you're going to be graded on if you're going to be graded on getting $20 billion
20:25outcomes and have been very clear on this then you just got do whatever it takes to get those $20 billion outcomes.
20:30And if and if you can get some of them at the A, that's freaking amazing. But if the only way you get some of them is at the C, well, that's fine, too, right?
20:36Especially if the non20 billion outcomes can't get liquidity in the same fashion. I think one shift we're seeing, we mentioned playing with the house money is all of the mega funds raised in Q126.
20:48And I thought, great, you know, we'll raise in 27. And I was like, great, we'll raise in 27. We'll be out of that cycle. Fine. Every single fund is queuing up out the door for Jan 1. We have to get the bag. Every mega platform is raising in Q1 for what will be the biggest funds that they raise. It's a 12 month deployment cycle before they raised from last time. How do we think about this?
21:15Generally, when you when you raise money quickly, you tend to not make as much money. And when you know right is that I think that this is that this is that stage in the cycle.
21:27It's worth remembering you know the cleverest checks in anthropic were written in early 23 and early 24 when the world was very different. I mean if you go back to where you were then it was much people were much more scared. I think in general um I think now people are going to put money out with high velocity. It's not clear to me you'll end up with anything like the same return because I think that's just always the case.
21:51So, but yes, that's what's going to happen because people go to people.
21:54I think to deploy it that quickly also inherently fuels the rapid markups that we're seeing. And listen, the best AI companies grow so quickly. Does it justify going from 10 to 20 to 40 in 6 months? Sure, on a spreadsheet, of course it does, right? But maybe the need to but maybe the pace of deployment also self-justifies it. And if it does, to Rory's point, it will compress returns. Maybe it's fine, right? Maybe 8x compressing to 4x or to 3x is fine.
22:20But I it it it it seems to be potentially partially fueling that, right? It can't all be the revenue growth since last month. So we have investment committee time, Jason, in the show me the money vein. We have three deals on the table today. We have Khi, the prediction marketplace that's taken the US market by storm, $65 billion price. Not cheap. We have Mccor raising at $20 billion, but one of the leaders in the data space. And then we have
22:49Fractile, $720 million at a $7.5 billion price, producing inference chips that compete against the likes of Grock, Cerebrus, and others. Yeah. Where are we going?
23:04Well, look, I'm disappointed at what you've brought to IC this week. We're going to do a deal because we're going back to market in January. We have no choice. We're going to do a deal. But last week, I love Last week we had Zipline, right? A little expensive, but Rory and I love Zipline. Who else did we have last week? We had foul, right? Um [clears throat] I mean, you can't argue with its success. And who was the third one we had last week? I think you picked the third one, Harry. It was a great great group of three, right?
23:26Um I know we're only able to deploy a few hundred million. It was a good week. Revolute. I mean, come on. I mean, Revolute is just a question of of of of the scale of the outcome. That was a great that was a that was a fun one.
23:37This week, I don't like this one. Um Cali, I don't like the regulatory risk at 65 billion. I I think this is hubitic. We may make money. Um, but I'm still uncom, you know, I'm still uncomfortable with the lawsuits and the other issues. We'll see. I'm just I I I'd rather stay low. Fractile no revenue, the 11,000th inference chip startup. I mean, when is it going to end, boys? When is it going to end? At 7 billion. Who the hell knows what this thing is? And Meror, listen, I I like Brandon, right? I mean, he he's he's
24:06he's an old soul at 20. Um, and and this is a great space because the the the the uh you know, Anthropic and everybody else doesn't want to do this work, but they're still doing the dirty work. And I just I just can't predict the future of dirty work. So, Mercur is one of those ones where I'm jealous of the guys that did the last round, you know? I'm jealous of the guys that did it at 10 or five or two. And and I I'm going to pick it because we've got to put money to work. It's November
24:3517th, but I like last week a lot better.
24:37All right. Can I can I can I explain to you then why you're the associate and I'm the GP at this firm because cow is the Fair enough.
24:45Cuz cow is the unwavering market leader in what is a monstrous sports betting market in the US.
24:50Monstrous market. You have states that are going to get addicted to this revenue so much that they won't allow for it to be banned in a new administration. So that's a pretty good place to be. We can see a 3x here. Mor.
25:05Dude, it's not impossible to see a $10 billion span from the LLM providers on the data that Mccor sells. If you believe that everyone's going to own their own intelligence, they're going to buy more data for it. It's an even bigger market. That's another $10 billion unlocked. That's a hundred billion business. So, at 20, it looks pretty good. I agree with you. And Fractile, dude, they've got a $250 million order from Anthropic. You've got Nvidia that are being weakened. You have Cerebrus, which some say is in trouble,
25:32some say is booming. TBD, Andrew is amazing. I love him and I buy him and Cerebrus, so you know, hopefully it's great. But dude, we're going to see the specialization of chips and it's a $7.5 billion entry. Come on. Well, so which side are you on, Rory?
25:53All three companies. Look, the positives in all three. As you'd expect in the latest stage business, you have to assume that every company is good because if they're not good, they wouldn't be raising late stage money, right? We're not, you know, the universe is not totally idiotic, right? As I said, at the stage we invest at those business risk up the wazoo at the series A and B, right? By the time you get to these companies, you should be done with business risk. You're like, you're dealing with typically a market lead or a number one or number two, a big ass market, and then the only question is
26:20value relative to TAM, right? So it's not surprising all three companies are great because they're all priced recently at good prices. So you got to say to yourself val so you got to drill down one level from it's not enough to say they're amazing companies Harry you got to in each case get to grips with value right think of fractile is look to state the obvious the most defensible technology on the other hand service is at mid20s market cap they had a great quarter they're going to do a billion plus just under a billion this year probably going to triple next year to three billion so that's the fast
26:50inference public company that shipped the chip that's you know in production that's booked the billion in revenue this year and they're at valued at 28. You know, would I would I buy that over fractile if I could do public or private? I don't know. I don't have a good enough sense on the fractile edge.
27:06And you you hear amazing things, but I just look at value relative to TAM and relative to comps and I go, I don't know. Right.
27:12Yeah. Fractile is not the value play.
27:15Let's just be clear.
27:15No, it's not the value [laughter] play.
27:17Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, Mercury, I think Jason said it right. You This is one of those markets where you continually go, "Oh, I don't know. I don't know." And then it just they spend more money. I mean the amazing thing if you read the anthropic S1 is 75% of their compute and then they they also I think someone disclosed their training budget. It's freaking huge. 70% 75% of their compute goes to making the next model, right? It's something like 10 billion. So they're each going to spend a billion billion something on training data. So you're right. You have bad
27:47news, you have five or 10 customers. Good news, they each spend a billion dollars. It's good for Tom. I don't know what it means for value. Right. And then Cali. Yeah, reluctantly.
27:56You know, the great thing there is, yes, it's wildly, yes, sports gambling is wildly addictive. The predictive market stuff, they they are pushing more of that now, but that's one where that could be huge. I really would want to sit down and understand. I mean, you say the market is huge and it's very big, but you know, you're already at 65 billion. They're doing five billion in revenue, so they're growing like a weed.
28:19But I suppose my question there would be what's a sober assessment of the real TAM? You know, how many bored 25year-old dudes are there betting on sports? How big can it be? Assuming full legalization, and then can you get prediction markets on top?
28:33So, I'd probably do the work on that. I think we're all aligned that we're Doom Mor actually. No, I think Jason said it right. It's like it was cute. It's the I'd always want to do the last round because you're like, "Oh, wow. They pull it off again." But yes, I don't know. I I Great business. They appear to be the winner. I mean, it's not really a winner take all business. You've got Surge, you've got Scale, but these guys appear to have pushed their way in in a very impressive fashion.
29:00They've they've done amazingly well.
29:01Their proximity to the labs, I think, is really very very cool to their success.
29:05And Brendan's amazing.
29:07I think that we just put in 200 million and move on to next week because this I like these, but last we're going to have an even more banger banger group next week. So, let's do 200 and move on.
29:16We'll loan 1%. We'll we'll and you know even if we don't make that much at putting 200 million to Merkur 20 billion we'll learn even if we don't make that much it'll be it'll it'll be good to learn and you and you know what you know what we missed on the Nvidia thing and you asked about the relating to IC you know what I really think I think the Nvidia this whole Jensen thing damaged a lot of things in venture I think it damaged Harry's 100% confidence in the liquidation preference I mean what was Nvidia going to buy reflection is that who they're going to
29:45buy for something billion that deal's And now there's some chance Hugging Face won't close. Harry's running around doing these deals at IC left and right in 12 months always telling us our liquid. I mean, I'm I'm I'm joking, but not. I I think the liquidation preference has been weakened by the Nvidia drama because Nvidia would always buy it. Nvidia or friends would always buy it or backs stop it or or come in and bail out Nscale or do something or buy out the team. Buy out the reflection team, buy out the poolside team, buy out
30:14the hugging face team. I can't lose on these deals because of my liquidation preference. Well, with Jensen gone, maybe you can lose on these deals. I don't think the CFO is going to buy all these kids and bail out their pool sides and and tool sides. I don't think she's going to do it.
30:27And I [laughter] don't think when they hire some retired guy from wherever from uh from uh from AMSL or wherever he's going to go buy all these kids for 17 billion. I don't think he's going to buy Clem for 15 billion to win open source. I think these liquidation preferences are are going to be they're not going to be worth the paper. their e signed on.
30:45Harry, dude, I agree. But the hugging face acquisition, like perfect timing. Like assuming it closes.
30:54Assuming it closes. Close to perfect timing.
30:58Perfect timing would be closed.
31:00And And the biggest risk is probably regulatory if we all get caught up in stuff. Okay. I hope there's there's there there's a you know I mean I mean Elon and Twitter proved it sometimes it can be hard to get out of a deal, but yet there's also many outs. Do you really think the CFO wants to do hugging face right now? I mean, I don't know if it's the top of the list right now. I I don't think it the whole team's super excited about this right now.
31:21I would say the Yeah, I would say though that the cost of like it's small relative to market cap. So, all other things been equal, they'd want to do it. But I think the issue is more if if if Nvidia is going to be subsumed in regulatory morass. And there's such at a random comment on the regulatory side.
31:36One of the things that's scariest if you're invidia is it would appear on the other side of the table in Washington there are two different sides on the issue. There are the you know sell [ __ ] to China people you know Lutnik and commerce are doing that and then you have the don't sell [ __ ] to China people and it seems Marco Ruby and some of the other people in that. So one of the real complexities you're not just dealing with a government that might be mad at you. You're dealing with a government that might be mad at itself. So you could easily see getting caught up in a bureaucratic swirl for the next two years. And if that happens and then
32:06you've been asked to, you know, the department, whatever, the FTC has been asked to approve, you know, some hugging face acquisition. No, maybe we should just kick this back. Don't want to piss off Marco Marco. Don't want to piss off How, you know. Yeah. So, you're right.
32:19The regulatory risk here definitely went way up. I hope they got a good breakup fee because they deserve they deserve to be not screwed over by this. I mean, you could imagine the good guys. You've run out of good guys.
32:32Sorry, just briefly, we can move on, but you could you could imagine 2027 being a banger year in many ways. But if Jensen isn't there and say Salesforce doesn't buy anybody because they're digesting these deals this year, the world would look very different if Nvidia isn't doing deals and Salesforce aren't doing deals next year. Okay? It'd be a very different year than our than then you can't lose with our lick prep year of 2026. It'd be very different. [snorts] Poolside could be bankrupt. They didn't have they said they didn't have the capital. That's why they sold, right?
33:02Oh, don't be negative, Jason. Please.
33:04No, no, I'm not. I mean, amazing outcome, but but but but what was great about poolside, it was it was an element of transparency we don't usually see, right? Everyone's full of it, right?
33:13This is saying, listen, we cannot afford to keep this business model going. We've we've done great job, guys, but we can't raise the 10 billion, 20 billion gap. Will thinking machines survive? I just don't know. You know, it's could be a very different world.
33:27We have a friend in the show, Mr. Brian Hallagan back in the hot seat, baby. Well, HubSpot has, you know, had a challenging 18 months. I think everyone would agree. And they've, you know, categorized the refounding moment. Dash and Brian, it's been awesome to see them get back together. What's the take on this, Jason? I got to start with you.
33:46Did they have to do this? Like, was it like Well, look, HubSpot basically for two years, it's been under pressure as many have, right? Stock price fell 50% this year, but let's ignore the up and downs of the stock price. I think Rory will be with me on this one. For years, even when there are other even during the the start of the SAS apocalypse and the 2024 dramas, they reliably closed 10,000 net new customers a quarter by like clockwork. Now, those customers had different values at different sizes.
34:1210,000 10,000 10,000. Um, two quarters ago 6,000, one quarter ago 5,000, next quarter they're guiding below 5,000. Monday went from like which is a peer went from like 1,200 10 plus net new customers 10 plus seat net new customers to under 200 okay fell by 80%.
34:33So something had to change and it had to change urgently and the tough question with love is it will work okay we can talk about why it will always work to have the founder energy in the back the the founder ability to make decisions others can't. the founder being more connected to product always works but but man I'm not saying it's too late but it's tough [snorts] that decline has already been in place and I don't really care you know revenue up and down stock price who cares but net the thing is net
35:02new customers I I this is like when I started investing this was my my lighthouse metric and we get distracted it is the only thing that matters at scale and people hid this for 2 years with endless price increases endless um and so you can m if you have high an decent NR and high and price increases, you can mask 20% growth for several years and people that don't look closely won't know. But if you don't if you're not attracting net new customers, your business is if it's not terminal, it it it is you're into deep value mode,
35:31right? You're into DP mode because there are no new customers. So he's got to turn he and Dash have to turn this around almost instantly, which is a big or otherwise you risk falling below the hard deck of net new customers. And I don't I don't envy them. So, it will work. The question is, will it work enough? Um, and everyone's in founder mode. Dev's back at [ __ ] who was on the show, right? Um, uh, back at workday, back at HubSpot, back at UiPath, it's all working.
35:59The question is, is it enough?
36:02Is it enough? And Jason, the last thing I'll say is every VC and Yahoo points to Finn and Intercom. Rory was a large investor. I was a tiny investor since the early days. I'm not I'm not sure intercom worked. And I say this with love. I I don't mean it literally, but let me finish my thought. It definitely worked. Okay, Owen came back in 2024, instantly fixed pricing and other issues. That worked before AI. Like immediately his first week, he he fixed the endless price increases and customer ripoffs that existed before him. Then he
36:31went all in on agents and AI in the very beginning. It worked, right? However, however, even with all that, even with the incredible blood, sweat, and tears of the founders, right, staying the whole journey, Owen coming back, they only got it to 100 100 plus million of aentic revenue. Did it really work?
36:47We'll never know as part of Salesforce. We'll never get the next card of the story. And every VC that says this as a case study. I think it's an example, but I don't think it proves the case that this works. I think it just all that pro goes all the way. We didn't get to see intercom go to a billion of aentic revenue. We never saw the next act of of Owen and Friends. And that's okay.
37:08People made money, but we this was never truly proven that this works, that this coming back. We just we just know it works to some extent. And so it's it's it's effing hard.
37:16Well, that's was my going to be my question, which is like it's effing hard.
37:19What is enough? You said that enough several times. I love Daniel and UiPath.
37:27But like I think it's all TBD. It's are you can you become a growth stock again or do you become Zoom or or and Dropbox?
37:36Well, can you tell me can you tell me one that has become a growth stock again?
37:40No, I mean there are there are some that look like it. There's the Octto and Twilios that I mean the growth isn't astronomical but but the stock prices show so much hub so much benefit from from a expansion. They all agreed there's no one above 30% in the public markets of that category. Obviously, Palanteer is it's doubling, but to your point, there's no one from the SAS era who has reacelerated back above 30%. I kind of agree with your comment, Jason. I I
38:09think it's is one, it is really hard to dramatically change the trajectory of a billion dollar revenue company, right? You're probably playing for some version of instead of having only 5,000 customers going down to 2,000, I can get it back up to 8,000. I can do better. I can point the growth rate up to 25% and I can survive and be a successful, viable, interesting public company that matters.
38:32But there'll be a five-year period where the startup, the Sierra growing forex year on year will have the growth and the sizzle and the cache that's just very hard to compete with. Right? So yes, I agree. And it's worth, by the way, one random comment on this going back to the Jensen thing. It's kind of funny. It is worth noting when three or four boards felt their back was to the wall and they have to save the company they break the glass and get the founder back just saying to the board hold that
39:01thought right because it is noticeable for all the faults that founders can bring to the table it is just worth noting that many and and in every case it was the right move dyn right with Brian I think was definitely right with Owen de makes a ton of sense it is noteworthy that that's the person you need that early on person who knows what to do here but I agree It is it is hard especially in the apps level. I mean I think I I don't know where the current [ __ ] growth rate is. Some of I mean some of the things like data dog if you can co-attach to the infrastructure boom
39:30you can get your growth rate up. But fundamentally I mean going back to your comment Jason at the I mean there's two different things. at the app level if you're selling a SASbased app you know it the problem you're up against is it could be that the new thing that the customer buys in the AI first world is just so different that you know to a rounding era all you're doing is you building a slightly better version of yesterday right and that's why I thought the the I don't
39:59know if I love the positioning but the Brian Haligan's comment they're going to be the customer relationship harness I think is what they said which is clearly an attempt to position themselves in the new world which is smart. I'm not sure that the average HubSpot customer and remember we were investors in the series I think C back in 2010 so we did very well. I'm not sure the average HubSpot customer of a 50 to 100 250 person company really has an opinion on harnesses but clearly what they're doing is trying to position
40:28in that kind of new product world. But it's hard. It is really hard because you know even if your new business goes great and I think the intercom new business was going really well, you're still trapped in this bigger slower growing thing. See, you know, Wix/Base 40 base 44 for details. It's it's it's very hard to dramatically change those trajectories. I always say to Daniel, I'm like, "Dude, why would you go back? [laughter] It's so brutal.
40:57Like, you have a nice life now. Like it's just oh but man man loves to struggle. man loves to struggle and actually John I see I see a level of aggression in all of them whereas like they've made so much money already like it doesn't matter like it used to and so they go with just unlimited aggression confidence that they didn't have before which is I think so I I will say I I think that's true and and no it's very hard for an outside CEO to do that right certainly
41:25hard for the CFO that that you know promoted to CEO two days ago to do it um I will say I think that that of course that's true it's a level of aggression And that's why I think it will work. I think Brian will work. I think they will all work to what Rory and I do.
41:43And what I mean hesitation is the wrong thing. I hear a h when I when I when I talk with a lot of C founder CEOs, not necessarily that went back but are there or whatever is they also recognize there may be a limit. To Rory's point, the 30% may be the the best I can do. I already have 320,000 customers at HubSpot. You know, Salesforce hasn't even disclosed its customer account for like four years. That's telling despite being a 50 billion in revenue. They don't they stop disclosing it. That whenever someone
42:11stops disclosing a metric, it's telling one way or the other, right? So Salesforce is clearly a master of selling you five to 10 expensive products, but not so much in bringing in net new logos. Um I think folks, and I'm sure even Daniel, you can ask him who are offthecharts smart. I think he also probably has a limit. Okay, I can only do this so so much visav agents and LLM no matter what I do with UiPath. It's never going to grow like it did in the past. What is the maximum? And there's a certain logical thinking here to try to
42:40maximize the reality outcome. Upgrade the team, do the layoffs, do whatever, but there's a hint of hesitation that maybe whatever limit is as good as it can be right after 20 years, 15 years in the you know 25 years. So um I don't know and to some extent that's not surprising. I mean one of the things we had said back I think in 2018 was that we foraw this SAS slowdown and it's not because AI is going to replace it as much though that was the second issue we said at the time but the more important
43:09thing is the times get saturated people have a CRM people have a hubspot you know some of these markets are more finite than one thinks it it's hard to grow a customer account infinitely especially in the enterprise side so I'm not surprised at the the Salesforce comments but well looks true but I would say for what it's worth there is a mystery to me here. The fact that Monday and HubSpot have seen their net new customer account decline so radically over the last 3/4 that is a fundamental change on the way
43:37SMBs are buying software today. This is radical change and I don't think it's vibe coding your own software. It's that's that's ridiculous.
43:45Jason, who who are the winners here? Is this like Atio and Zero and the new If you look at the ramp data, I guess Adio's benefited, but they're so small in the grand scheme of things. It's a rounding error. It's a rounding error, right?
43:58I think the winner candidly is probably claude a topic in a sense of for small SMBs where the workflow and the off and all the kind of corporate legacy stuff isn't that important you can crank something out now that will suffice as a CRM app right no no no the people who use Monday are not going and vibe coding with code their own CRM you can do you know I was I would have
44:27said look I said no on the show six nine months ago and then I have you know every single associate and principally has cranked out their own front end using claude for our Salesforce instance and no one logs into Salesforce anymore they've built surprise they went to HBS and work in San Francisco
44:46yeah how I think the answer if you want my I think it's in the middle okay I don't think your average to Harry's point I don't think your average SMB that is not tech-savvy is vibe coding their own front end to Postgress or Salesforce rep. I just I see no evidence that's happening. I'm pretty close to the Replet team. I can tell you CRM is not one of their core verticals, okay?
45:04At a billion in revenue. Okay, it's just not I briefly asked Anton. He never brought it up as something that they're doing. I don't think it's a big deal. But here's what I do think is happening to Rory's point. I just think it's subtler.
45:15I think folks are just trying not to buy this software for SMBs. They're just saying it's not so much that I'm buying it. They're they're sitting around like, you know, and and and in the old days when we started, you'd bring in a VP of sales and what's the thing he he or she would do their first week? Bring in sales by first week I got to roll it out and I got I'd probably have to hire a consulting firm to help us small, medium, and large. That was a day one kind of thing. I think that you can't argue with the data. I there's not a is a benefiting. Yeah, Ram says a little bit. Another 10 million of revenue.
45:42That's not enough to explain what's happening. SMBs are saying I don't want to buy this crap. I just don't want to buy it. I'm going to whether it's a little bit of data analysis in chat GB without knowing I'm doing doing data analysis. Whether it's running it in Google Sheets for another 6 months because with chat GBT it's good enough.
46:00It's just I don't want to I don't want to in my small business I don't want to spend 40 grand a year for HubSpot right now in this world. I just don't want to do it I think is what's happening or Monday. Um and these pro Monday is not even expensive but and this is something I did not anticipate that SMBs would just say I don't want to buy this stuff.
46:16Um, on the other hand, I can say in my portfolio selling to SMBs, anyone that's automating away front office, back office humans is is exploding. My god, it is the easiest thing. Nothing's easy to sell. But I have three portfolio companies selling $500 to $1,000 a month front office, back office, Aentic Solutions that that that as long as they can get a prospect on the phone, they can close it that day.
46:40And p but they don't want to buy these software products. It's not enough. They're just going to bumble along with what they do. They It's not a P1 or a P 0. You know what my P 0 is? My receptionist quits every Wednesday.
46:54So, oh, you have an agent that will do that 24/7. Reschedule all the appointments, handle billing, handle everything for me. It actually it actually works. $800. I'll I'll sign this afternoon, kiddo.
47:07That's what people want to buy. Not not conbon crap.
47:11So, I didn't anticipate this would happen because we grew up in a world where you couldn't survive without the software, right? You couldn't survive without it. Clearly, people can, right?
47:19Clearly, people can. And they want to put that energy into things that that are different. And that's what's happening. They may buy HubSpot or Monday or someone or Adio, but they may put it off a year or two and and and that may end up being never like we don't know. That's my theory because I I looked at the RAM. I looked at others.
47:34It's not substitution.
47:36It's not going to other not sufficient to explain this. It's they're just they're just done. They want to do stuff that has high ROI. This used to be high ROI software. It isn't today.
47:46I feel we've got to talk about Microsoft going down for 2 days. Uh I mean, seriously, my Rory, you'll be surprised I'm still dating the same girlfriend. She stayed with me. Sure.
47:59Yeah. She wakes up and she's like, I got no emails. I don't know what to do today. Teams is down. Um uh Co-Pilot's down. Outlooks is [laughter] down.
48:09um uh down for 36 hours or so and then we had [clears throat] flights grounded in the US FAA problems in terms of L3 Harris and one of the contractors and worth pointing out based on the initial comments that in neither case is there an allegation of you know severe as I understand it's not a cyber issue it's not AI cyber it's not even directly speaking AI these are old school
48:37problems that people just missed. So, in fact, you know, in the case of um the FAA, it was a router issue that kicked off the whole thing. In the case of Microsoft, I don't fully know, but it appears to be some kind of network configuration thing. I mean, I have seen a post that basically says it turns out if you whack all the senior engineers and think the AI is going to figure it out. This is the kind of thing you miss.
48:57I can't comment on that. I don't know. But they appear to be fundamental, you know, classic IT screw-ups that, you know, have reverberated quite a lot. So, but but like you know the NSA today went down as well for their internal coms and is down now. Um and I'm just like hang on a minute. Like the core systems that run our society, freaking air traffic control, Microsoft, we've never had the fragility of systems
49:27in my lifetime. It feels like this. I think they've been more fragile. But what here's how I think about it. I think it's DDoSing 2.0 or DDoSing for the AI era. Okay, you could always take down a website back in the day. I mean, websites used to be so fragile, you could do anything. You could hire some nefarious agents offshore and I could take down Scales website if I was pissed off, right? It was pretty easy to do uh because we could bring down that penny those pennium servers uh pretty darn quickly, right? Um with with agents and other things, we we can find however you
49:56want to DDoS it. And this Microsoft thing apparently was a load related bug that it existed for 4 months and they hit some sort of uh maximum load they had on before and it went down. Now, and I completely agree with Rory as our DevOps teams declining quality and sec ops team declining quality, i.e.
50:13optimizing. This is going to happen more, but also not only is everyone going to get hacked like we've talked about for months and now we're seeing it happen constantly, right? Google said we saw the first truly autonomous agentic hack this week. Everyone's going to be dodoed. Everyone's going to be overloaded their servers. It's too easy.
50:29It's too easy to spin up agents. It's too easy to break Microsoft. It's too easy to just break and every system can be broken and is fragile. So, it's just another thing we didn't anticipate being able to do, which was attack anything.
50:40What What really was it really just an old level three uh uh Lynxis router from 1998 that took it out? Or was it a load issue or was it someone probing the edges of a network, right? Or is it I think every network's going to be probed. It's going to be probed with traffic, with load, with hacking. All the vectors are going to be hit. And so everything everything's going to be hit.
50:59And it's not all going to be truly security and stealing credentials and API keys. It's going to be load based, too. Anything that can be taken out with massive load. You're going to spool up agents and you're going to see if you can take it down. Let's take down everything. I ran spool up a thousand 10,000 agents uh on Quinn or whatever and see who they can take down. It's not that hard. And this is a tough one. this cascading if you've ever run a B2B service this there's not few things more stressful than cascading web servers because all of a sudden it goes you have a thousand servers 10 go down it's
51:29really stressful and then you sort of fix it another 10 go down another now now you spread the load a thousand loads on 900 800 700 600 and like you want to jump off the roof because it it gets it gets even as you find the solution it gets worse and worse it's going to happen to everybody and I think you're chiming in on that you know even though those two examples weren't at least obviously AI cyber related you know this we've definitely seen a plethora of other companies wrestling with you know smaller cyber breaches in
51:57the last 3 6 months that clearly probably are related to just the ability to hack almost anything more quickly so there's a lot going on and to your point I just highlights the I mean you know this not perhaps poom or any of that stuff this is one of the big risks in the AI boom which is when you see what it's like to with, you know, I mean, I frankly I could live without, you know, Outlook. I didn't even notice and I I don't love teams, but um I think, you know, when you see the FAA go down for a
52:26day or can you imagine a week? I mean, that would start to get economically very painful. You know, when you start to think about back, it does highlight the dude the week the weekend was economically very painful. By the way, by by the way, teams and teams and outlook, I'm with you completely.
52:41The devastation that causes for 4 hours of down time. I don't it's probably going to mean all these companies really having to think about you know what level of competence is required to deliver these systems and there's probably going to have to be a substantial kind of upering in I want to say the seriousness the professionalism the the the capabilities of any company or any company that's you know offering a kind of missionritical offering in today's world I remember I
53:10remember when docuine suddenly started to become huge and I would really go to other board member who had a cyber background just basically sitting everyone down and saying, "Look, now you're going to get hacked. This is what you have to do." And they did it. We spent the money to be, you know, as reliable as it takes. And I think all these I mean, you you can't continue to have the FAA run on a shoestring and a bunch of I mean, did you see the thing?
53:30They just announced they're getting rid of floppy discs, right? Ironically, actually, floppy discs are probably impervious to many of these issues.
53:36gaps. [laughter] There is going to have to be a lot of spend on making these work and making these work and and durable because this is not we can't be doing this two weeks in a row. Like you if if if the FAA went down again this weekend, I think people would lose their collective [ __ ] and they'd probably, you know, put Sean Duffy's head on a spike.
53:59[ __ ] wild. Have you seen Die Hard 2 where like they're unable to connect air traffic control to planes? That's what was happening. Like there was a loss of [ __ ] terrifying.
54:09Yeah, you've got 400 terrifying. I mean, I read the article how they got them all. There's 4,000 planes in the sky and you have a nationalwide ground stop. Not I know that one's scary. I just think more tactically related to venture and startups. I I think in some ways the optimizely thing is worse. I don't mean in terms of global because because Rory made a really important point. We're we're we're we're on the one hand we're in the era of can one person build a billion dollar startup right on the other hand we're in an era where I don't
54:38think we can trust anything except companies with S tier security teams okay and optimizely is a moldy oldie of B2B right and it gets it it gets uh prompt injected or whatever happens CNN the BBC zoom everyone's using it stealing credit cards stealing PI um every mediocre third party plugin and app is a is the security issue. That's the That's what happened to Fireworks, too, right? And then and then and then and then Notion and uh and who else
55:07blame Fireworks by name, which you never see before, right? Before you'd always see one of our vendors had an issue, it impacted less than 1% of them. Notion sent to their entire million-doll customer base attacking fireworks, right? And so, I'm not I'm not picking on them. I mean I'm a little bit but like where this plays out on the one hand we want one person billion dollar startups with no frankly no security okay nothing nothing you can't I have
55:36you ever built a real production app yourself you have no you know you can do security audits on the one hand right so so we want this massive innovation but these products are going to be totally insecure and I don't think you can trust any old product that that that that's a plugin I just don't think you should use any web analytics I don't think you you I don't know if you should use any new startup uh payment startup besides Stripe or uh or Aden. It's just just the risk here is so high in the in the automated agentic hacking, right? And so how that plays out for startups is
56:04confusing to me. On the other hand, our we can scale like never before. On the other hand, your security risk is like never before or you know unless you're the best of the best of the best.
56:13It goes to the point that you said Jason, which is actually the scary thing is the fireworks team is exceptional. The engineering team is truly bestinass. If their security team and sec ops team is is 10,000 times better than 99.9% then I really am quite worried.
56:33Yeah, I'm sure they're great. It's their job and it happened in a corner of their application too. And that's where it often h that's what that's what whether it's a human or AI, you're looking for the edges in the corners. It's not like all of Fireworks data was exposed, right? It was this corner for testing where they stored some keys that they found their way into, right? Um, and that's with probably a hundred great 50 great people in sec ops and DevOps, right? Oh, yeah. Curser called them out, too. It's pretty bad, right?
57:00Well, it just shows the it just shows the stakes, right? That notion cursor and Harvey would call out a vendor. I remember when Harry and I were in London about a year ago at Saster AI London a year ago, and OpenAI had some breach with a third party vendor right while we were there. I can't remember which one it was. They they I remember they didn't name them. I mean, they did cancel the contract. [laughter] I forget who it was, but it was a classic. We've had a small issue. It was only with our CRM and and external. It didn't access any of our data, but man, now it's fireworks, notion cursor, and
57:30Harvey. Fireworks, fireworks, fireworks.
57:32Dude, I think we've just lost all elegance though in this business. Like before VCs didn't bash each other as much. Companies didn't b Now it's just like all out brawl. Um, I do want to touch on one M&A that seemingly kind of flies under the radar, but I actually think it's quite interesting. It's open AI buying a company called Adessia. It's like Instinct but for travel specifically. Um, and it's the founder of Sonda, Francis Davidson. And my my question that I thought was interesting
58:02off the back of that is, does this signal the end of verticalized personal assistance? Your financial personal assistant, your travel personal assistant, and it's just a horizontal play. Any thoughts on this?
58:15Well, who founded Sonder?
58:17Yeah. I'm I'm I I love Sonder. It's just ended up being a terrible business model. So, I'm happy for him because it was one of my favorite products. Like, I use so many Right. In Coven Garden, I stayed at a three-bedroom in in Sa every time I was there. It was a gem, right?
58:30Um so, I'm glad he had a win in the end.
58:33Seriously, it makes my heart warm as a founder, right?
58:36Uh I listen, I'll tell you my one learning I because everyone comes on, you know, we had Jack Alman and others.
58:41Why aren't you using instinct Jason?
58:43I'm so deep in Muse now. You don't know all the workflows that we are running across Aster and Muse now. Muse is our ex our horizontal agent. Muse, we're so deep on Muse.
58:52Wow. What do you use it for?
58:54We use it for outbound. We use it for competitive review. We use it to I I use it to edit all of my content. I use it to create clips and other things. Um I use it to find all the gaps and everything we're doing. I we use it to do analysis of our web traffic of our Sastro annual attendees. It does everything constantly around the clock.
59:13And I have so many workflows in it that that that the the burden to use another one is pretty high. Like it it it is a shallow moat but man it's become wide with like 20 or 30 workflows, right? Any single gap we have and we have tw we have so many agents at right 21 agents for humans. Any gap we can't fill we we spool spool a muse up and our muses talk to each other. Mine and Amelia's talk to each other. They have their their little web chat channel their email address.
59:39They don't tell us. They talk to each other. So, whatever I'm working on and she's working on, they can collaborate together. Our two muses, um, Carson and Friday are their names. Um, and any gap, any gap we have, it also any sing, it reviews every single inbound venture deal I get. It reranks them automatically. It sends me an update. It reads the ones that I didn't read and it reminds me if there's any good ones that I didn't get to and get any attention.
1:00:01It does it every single night.
1:00:02So, you've given him full access to your email.
1:00:07Yeah. Full access for full time. credit cards?
1:00:12No, it did order it did order flowers uh for a big deal closing on the team without telling me. So maybe that's a thoughtful reminder about the flowers. Um so no credit card yet. Um but it's so useful that I probably would go to the effort of locking down a Mercury account like with like a $1,000 cap if I needed if I needed it to buy stuff right now.
1:00:31Um we don't need it. We have so many other systems for that. We have Bill and Brex and others. uh but you would if we didn't have bill but are you more bullish on matter as a result of your exposure now to muse what I am worried about for startups and others is um as humans we're we're we're very we we go out to buy a vendor and we we basically if we're early adopters we see what the hell's out there bless their souls bless those CIOS with emerging vendor uh groups and stuff like
1:01:00that most of us look at the two leading vendors as humans we do our best we can to evaluate when we buy one and maybe over two years we turn over. Agents have a different um way of doing it. But once one really works, you're not going to change unless there's a reason to change. It gets locked in. So there is I don't know if I'm more I think I think Mark was right to push this at the time he did because I think January would be much harder than now. He's going to have a 20 million person install base to build on. And I don't think people want
1:01:30to go from Muse to Instinct to Grock to dots and back and forth. There'll be folks in tech that do it, but these once you have these workflows running and they're really really good, you don't want to move them.
1:01:41You can, but you don't you don't want to.
1:01:43I'm with you. I have like 50 automations on Instinct running and like be a real bate to have to change them all.
1:01:50You would do it if there's something that you can't do in Instinct that's important. If you, for example, Muse is very, very good at at headless browser interactions. So, you might find there's something that it's so good at headless browser. I'm just saying I'm not saying this is true of the Instinct team, but you might find something. It's so good at headless. Like, for example, it can like like Muse is the best thing. We're we I still we still get a million views a month on our WordPress content.
1:02:11Nothing else can interact with with WordPress that I found as an agent. Muse does it perfectly. So, let's say you had a WordPress. You might do it just for this one and then give it another. But it's because it could do one thing that is at least a P2 you couldn't get otherwise. But, but otherwise, you're not going to move off instinct.
1:02:26Jason, how much do you think you cost exactly, Mr. Zuckerberg, you said four to five bucks last week and all that.
1:02:34Um, and we get the we get whatever the the pro is. How much? I don't know, $200, $500 a month, $1,000 a month for 20 bucks.
1:02:41I mean, I'm sure with Claude with my $200, I'm spending $10,000 a month where No, I mean, it's it's a lot.
1:02:46The good news for both companies is you're not the typical user. The business model will survive, right? And the poor dude.
1:02:53Well, maybe or maybe I'm the future just in the present. Could well be that you Yes. You think think that of yourself.
1:03:00That's the caption. To be honest, Rory, I don't mean that with hubris. I I I understood what you're saying. I mean to learn from. I mean to learn from, right?
1:03:07No. Exactly. What percentage of people will have that dynamic a set of interactions on an ongoing basis is the question.
1:03:13I think what'll happen in B2B is you'll wake up and you'll you're you're about you get you get the quote from the HubSpot rep. It's $30,000 for your for your right and you wake up and you realize Muse can do it. Not not all of it, but more than you thought. And you might put off that purchase a month because Muse, it turns out Muse Muse can go to your email list and email all the 20 VC listeners. It can go and identify, you know what Muse is really good at? Go into the scale database into Salesforce, find the top 200 founders we want to
1:03:43invite to a VIP dinner and cocktails and invite them. And it does it. And you're like, why do I need marketing automation software?
1:03:50You might do that without realizing you're replacing marketing automations offer because you just ask Muse. I guarantee you if your Muse is hooked up to any CRM or database, it can do just what I said because we've already done it. Invite the top 200 CEOs to 20 VC's office tomorrow night, I probably instinct can do it, too. And that's that's what you pay $100,000 a year for marketing automation software to do.
1:04:09Except the humans had to figure out the list and pick it and get it wrong. Um, and then invite the failed cosmic. Look, we don't want to get the interesting question. It's so funny. use the the the Facebook the ultimate consumer company and what you're basically saying is it's powerful enough to effectively be a small business agent right and the question is you know will you ever will there be a better small business agent you'll switch to or is in fact this the correct answer for you I think the listen I know Harry wants to move I think for me technically at a product the interesting thing that
1:04:37people don't get about muse okay is it is so overengineered agreed it is so overly because it because of Alex and all these great guys, right?
1:04:48The best of the best built this, right?
1:04:50They they this they talk about this thing being a little consumer app to make reservations, but it can do it is it is the ultimate expression of OpenClaw and it is amazing software. It is the best software I've used since since like anthropic 3.x got good. It is so overengineered for the use cases in the popular media. It's epic. Jason, can I ask you a really hard one, but for someone today who doesn't have Muse?
1:05:13Yeah. What would you tell them would be a great first use to see the power of it to get started? Yeah. Like what would you It's easy. It's easy. First of all, Muse is free for It's the most generous free category I know of. So, sign up. It's free. Um if you don't know, ask ask if you have any friends that have Facebook, ask them for an invite. It's pretty easy to get. Okay. Um and here this is this is the magic. Look around your little business, your little office. What isn't getting done, Harry? in in your general
1:05:42business workflows, what isn't getting done. Okay? And just ask Muse if it can do it. Probably can't. This post didn't get done. This email didn't get done. We're not following up on on customers.
1:05:53We're not following up. We had we had a dinner last night at scale. Did you follow up with the founders and asked them how I did it? No. I asked my my my secretary, but didn't want to do it because you didn't want to figure it out. Ask Muse. Muse will figure out everyone that came to the skilled dinner last night and it will craft a really good email and ask them how it was.
1:06:11Think about something you just didn't get done and ask Muse. You will be shocked that I think five times out of 10 it will do a better job than someone in whatever humans you have left in your office, it will do a better job. I try this. Your jaw will drop because between the memory, the browser agent, how it handles everything, the quality of the LLMs, um the way it the way the LM is tailored to around these workflows, right? rather than arguing with you or being developer focused. Um it's very task focused. Um you will you will be
1:06:39shocked what it can do. It can do you hey you know what you want to get know a little bit more about AO or go just ask ask Muse how is my AEO Jason does it make you more or less bullish on instinct. As I said in our IC I I there have to there's going to be some vendors I just worry about uh runaway infrastructure costs. There have to be some limits to it. There can't be just Rory's endless handwaving of great founders figuring it out. [laughter]
1:07:07You being slightly physicious, but I'm not bullish on it today, but I haven't seen I haven't I haven't seen all the justification about how simple this will get. I'm not I'm not because I do think I do think this this product gets maimed if I can't run this thing this gift from Meta, which is that I can run these agents 24/7. It's got a cash cow that powers the business. If you instinct the com I would just comment is if the typical user of these products is a Jason who wants a whole bunch of B2B
1:07:36functionality then by definition he's going to gravitate to the company who can afford to give him all that functionality for onetenth of the price it cost them to deliver it which is probably going to be meta rather than instinct right so but the question maybe the other question is if the vast majority of users today and I accept your point Jason don't need that level of compute and aren't running their entire SMB on the infrastructure then at least instinct has a chance to compete and maybe can win on the basis of you
1:08:04know moving faster being standalone but still it is scary when I mean it's scary when a large company with 5 billion 4 billion of human reach is producing a product that arguably technically is more overpowered than your product and has distribution of the wazoo now didn't work for threads but there you go but I could be missing It's come a long way from that little question about that oneperson travel agency.
1:08:31I freaking love the diversion. That was awesome.
1:08:34Um, anything that I've missed that you think we should cover?
1:08:37Sorry. Why? Why? What? What happened with Adessia?
1:08:41He bought the company agents. It was He bought it for the agent for age, right?
1:08:46I think 20 deals. I guess my comment is I I know this is Captain Obvious, but I I think I think we're past the era of aic apps. We're past the era of AI CX and crap. We are truly in the agentic era next year like these horizontal agents, these autonomous agents and this this is the big win for for most of us at a lay level. Most of us are not in I mean cloud code is the greatest app of of all time but most of us as humans are not cloud coding all the time. This is it gets good next year. it it gets good
1:09:15with agents for and so we're going to see 20 of these Adessia deals to the biggest challenge I find is the biggest challenge I find is actually workforce mindset which like we have big teams here now and actually just getting people to go could an agent do this what can I replace with agents what are we not doing that agents could do it's not a primary mentality for a human brain that's worked for 10 years to absorb that's and those people will disappear because what will happen is this is a
1:09:44transition phase where you're trying to get humans to to be agents. When you do what I just did and you ask Muse to do it first, then what's happened is you just won't hire that person next. I mean, our agents do all of our collections. Okay? So, our previous collection consu contractor who build us three or $4,000 a month, we get build one hour. Okay? So, it will just get inverted and we will stop trying to get humans to work with agents and we'll just start asking agents to do it and we'll we'll we'll plug humans in into the gaps. It's a transition phase. And
1:10:12what'll happen is you'll you then you won't even fire them. Like they'll they'll think they get a better job and they'll quit and you don't you'll stop backfilling people is what happens slowly away.
1:10:22I I sat down I sat down with one of our guys and I said just to let you know I agree right now the clips that you make we can't do with AI. In a year we will be able to. You need to get better or you will be replaced.
1:10:35I think that's right. I tell you we went from 20 people to to three humans and 21 agents. You say that and it's true, but you know what? You know what it requires today? It basically requires managing your agents for even more time.
1:10:476 hours a day, 8 hours a day, 10 hours a day. Do you want to be sitting in front of Muse for eight hours a day?
1:10:55It doesn't have to be you, but it'll be someone on your team, right? So it's not I just wish I was Manlow with the carry. [ __ ] off. [laughter] It's glad to see good to see you again. It's almost got to split it two ways.
1:11:11Oh, come on. [laughter] Yeah. Okay. Uh Sound Sound Ventures or Menllo. Who would you rather be? I'd rather be Sound Ventures.
1:11:18I would too. 435 million to 7 billion. Ash two GPS. Two GPS. Call it a day. Don't have to work for anybody you don't want to.
1:11:28Amen. Uh Norwest raises $4 billion fund from one LP Wells Fargo. Jesus, I wish wish we all had a Wells Fargo in our lives. SpaceX guts. It's Grock video team.
1:11:40If you're going to do I'm going to stop it there. You're you're at the tail end of the agenda. If you're going to do SpaceX, you can't talk about You just got to give him credit for Starship. Just want to say we can do Starship. Starship.
1:11:50Look, there's not much to say except that is a freaking amazing technical achievement. And you know, honestly, I personally find the the interpersonals on the guy to be a pain, the politics to be a pain. But that's a stunning stunning stunning achievement. And when you look back on the top five things of the year that matter most, that's going to be one of them. You know, all the kind of orbital costs plummeting down by virtue of that. So I thought it was just cool and a sustained effort over you half a decade to make it happen.
1:12:18I get you, but it's not SMB CRM, is it?
1:12:20I mean like No, it's not. It's not going to sell any help. But it but yeah it is stunning to realize despite that that now the whole rocket launch business is sub 10% of the um SpaceX market cap. Rory would you buy SpaceX? Not at this price because it's not about this rockets. The truth is the rockets which are amazing, unique and differentiated make the Starlink which is very amazing, reasonably differentiated especially for kind of
1:12:47the noncrowded area stuff but then most of the business and most of the market cap and most of the TAM according to their own S1 is all about compute. So really you're saying to yourself would you buy compute and that gets into the whole dynamic of you know forecasting compute for the next 5 years which is just a different question. I might buy it, I might not buy it, but I wouldn't buy it because of this amazing technical achievement. You buy SpaceX the stock entirely on the basis of what you think Entropic will be paying you one year
1:13:16from now for that compute. Will they be canceling or will they be buying more?
1:13:19It's the only question. Well, that sounds like a long only investor right there. Uh [laughter] uh, no. I think you buy SpaceX cuz you read Shawn Maguire's Excel model.
1:13:31I thought people give him [ __ ] for that. I thought, you know, it's it I I saw the comments on that. I thought, you know, it's kind of I didn't mean that.
1:13:39No, I know you didn't. I just want to say I want to say it, too, though. I was like, everyone was like, "Oh, you didn't take into account tax, dude. It's the big picture. How much money 5 years from now for each of the three markets?" It was, you know, you don't have to believe in it to say, "Yeah, that's that's a perspective." All right, boys. Anything I've missed? Should we should we record a little bit at the end in case Jensen's back by the time we do it?
1:13:57I knew, boys. I wasn't surprised at all that Jensen would come back. I told you it would happen by Thursday. Alman was back in what, 80 hours? How long was it for Jensen? 100.
1:14:06Do you know what Jason, that's a really interesting question. So, I predict that Jason that Jensen will come back. Yeah.
1:14:12In the next week or over a period of time.
1:14:15Oh, no. I think Jansen will come back in the next 3 days.
1:14:18There is a record now so that he's got to come back in the next 3 days otherwise the chorus dies, anthropic IPO happens, Trump does something else and it fizzles. This is the moment. This is the mother lode.
1:14:33I don't think that'll happen. I mean, be great, but but if it doesn't happen, it won't happen.
1:14:38Well, yeah, some things don't happen, Harry.
1:14:40And that's the mistake of Jensen and the board, which is news cycles have never been faster. And I think if they just put it on chill, then anthropic IPO would have happened. Daria be outside the stock exchange. Woohoo. Woohoo. And it would have fizzled.
1:14:56Okay, cool, boys. What a joy as always. It's a wrap.